How does the fact that we cannot have everything shape all human decisions, from individual choices to government policies?
explain how scarcity forces choices, calculate opportunity cost, reason about marginal benefit and marginal cost, and predict how monetary and nonmonetary incentives change behavior.

Economics is not mainly about money. It is about choice under scarcity. Time, money, land, labor and attention are limited; wants are not. Because we cannot have everything, every choice gives something up. That single fact — scarcity — is why economics exists.
Because resources are limited but wants are not, economics studies how individuals and societies make choices and what they give up in the process.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
The condition of limited resources relative to unlimited wants.
Consider a choice you made recently where you had to give something up. What was the opportunity cost of that choice?
A student gives up a $120 shift to attend a free concert. What is the opportunity cost of the concert?
Opportunity cost
The word ‘economics’ comes from the Greek ‘oikonomia,’ meaning ‘household management,’ reflecting its original focus on managing scarce resources within a household.
The true cost of any choice is the value of the best alternative given up. Spending Saturday working a six-hour shift at $18 an hour has an obvious benefit, $108. Spending it studying for the SAT has an opportunity cost of $108 plus whatever else you would have done. A university education’s cost includes not only tuition but the earnings a student forgoes while studying. Economists ask not “what does it cost?” but “what does it cost instead of what?”
The value of the best alternative given up when a choice is made.
Economics is all about money and how to get rich.
Economics is primarily about how people make choices when faced with limited resources and unlimited wants, whether those resources are money, time, or attention. It examines what is given up with every choice.
Because you already paid for a gym membership, you should keep going even when it is no longer worth your time.
Thinking at the margin
Most decisions are not all-or-nothing but a little more or a little less. The relevant question is whether the marginal benefit — the extra benefit of one more unit — exceeds the marginal cost — the extra cost of that unit. A café deciding whether to stay open an extra hour compares the extra revenue with the extra wages and electricity, not the café’s total costs. A student deciding whether to study one more hour compares the expected gain in the grade with what that hour would otherwise be worth. Rational decisions continue an activity until marginal benefit equals marginal cost.
Sunk costs — costs already paid that cannot be recovered — should not affect a forward-looking choice. Sitting through a bad film because you paid for the ticket is a sunk-cost error: the money is gone whether you stay or leave.
A cost already incurred that cannot be recovered and should not affect future decisions.
A fine is a incentive; public approval is a incentive; “the state should raise the gas tax” is a statement.
Incentives
People respond to incentives: rewards and penalties that change the costs and benefits of choices. Monetary incentives include wages, prices, taxes, fines and subsidies. Nonmonetary incentives include time, convenience, status, social approval, guilt and legal consequences. Missouri’s motor fuel tax, 29.5 cents a gallon, is a monetary incentive that raises the price of driving; the driver-license point system, which suspends the license of a driver with eight points in eighteen months, is a nonmonetary one that changes how people drive. When an incentive changes, behavior changes — sometimes in unintended ways. A city that pays a bounty for rat tails may find residents breeding rats.
Analyze three real decisions — one yours, one a business’s, one a government’s. For each, state the opportunity cost, the marginal benefit and marginal cost of doing a little more, and one incentive that could change the decision. Label each claim you make positive or normative.
Positive and normative
Economists separate positive statements — claims about what is, which can be tested (“a higher cigarette tax reduces smoking among teenagers”) — from normative statements — claims about what ought to be (“the state should raise the cigarette tax”). Positive analysis can inform normative debate but cannot settle it, because normative questions also involve values. Throughout this course, label which kind of claim you are making.
Cost-benefit reasoning (HI.6) — comparing the costs and benefits of an action — is the central tool of this course, and you will apply it from individual decisions to government policy.
Key terms
The additional benefit or cost of one more unit of an activity.
Claims about what is (testable) versus claims about what ought to be (value-based).
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- You skip a five-hour shift paying $19 an hour to go to the beach. What is the money part of the opportunity cost?
Check your answer
Answer: $955 × 19. The full opportunity cost is the best alternative given up, which here includes the pay. - You paid $15 for a film and it is bad after 20 minutes. Should the $15 affect whether you stay? Name the idea.
Check your answer
Answer: No — it is a sunk cost, gone whether you stay or leave. Decide on the future benefits and costs of the next 90 minutes.Sunk costs should not affect forward-looking choices. - Positive or normative? (a) A higher cigarette tax reduces teenage smoking. (b) Missouri should raise the cigarette tax. (c) Rent control reduces the supply of rental housing over time.
Check your answer
Answer: (a) positive; (b) normative; (c) positivePositive claims can be tested with evidence; normative claims say what ought to be. - Monetary or nonmonetary incentive? (a) Missouri’s motor fuel tax, 29.5 cents a gallon. (b) The rule that suspends the license of a driver who has accumulated eight points in eighteen months. (c) A parking fine. (d) Social approval for carpooling.
Check your answer
Answer: (a) monetary; (b) nonmonetary (a legal consequence); (c) monetary; (d) nonmonetaryMoney rewards and penalties versus time, legal consequences, status, approval and similar. The tax is 17 cents plus an added 12.5 cents (RSMo 142.803); the point rule is RSMo 302.304.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- A café in Columbia, Missouri is deciding whether to stay open later. Each extra hour costs two workers at the state minimum of $15.00 an hour plus $12 of electricity. Expected extra revenue is $140 for 8-9 p.m. and $38 for 9-10 p.m. How late should it stay open?
Check your answer
Answer: Marginal cost is $42 an hour. Stay open 8-9 p.m. ($140 > $42); close at 9 p.m. ($38 < $42).Compare marginal benefit with marginal cost for each extra hour, not total revenue with total cost. - Studying one more hour for a test is expected to raise your score by 6 points for the 1st extra hour, 3 for the 2nd and 1 for the 3rd. You value each point at $4 of your time’s worth, and each hour of your time at $10. How many extra hours should you study?
Check your answer
Answer: Two hours. Marginal benefits are $24, $12 and $4; the marginal cost is $10 each hour. Stop before the third, where $4 < $10.Continue while marginal benefit ≥ marginal cost; marginal benefit falls as you study more. - Estimate the opportunity cost of one year at a Missouri public university for a student who would otherwise work full time at the state minimum wage of $15.00 an hour (2,000 hours a year). Use illustrative figures: tuition and fees $8,200, books $1,000. Why is rent left out?
Check your answer
Answer: $39,200 a year: $9,200 in direct costs plus $30,000 of forgone earnings. Rent is left out because she would pay it whether she studied or worked.Opportunity cost counts what is given up because of this choice; costs paid either way are not part of it. - Missouri’s motor fuel tax is 17 cents a gallon plus an added 12.5 cents a gallon since July 1, 2025, for 29.5 cents in all (the added part may be claimed back as a refund). Before any refund, how much tax is in 40 gallons of fuel? Is the tax a monetary or nonmonetary incentive, and which way does it push fuel use?
Check your answer
Answer: $11.80 (40 × $0.295). It is a monetary incentive that raises the price of driving and so pushes fuel use down, other things equal.40 × 0.295 = 11.80. A tax on a good raises its price and lowers the quantity demanded.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- A city pays $5 for every old tire residents bring to a recycling center, hoping to stop illegal dumping. Predict one intended and one unintended effect of the incentive.
Check your answer
Answer: Intended: fewer tires dumped in ravines and vacant lots. Unintended: people bring tires from outside the city, or collect tires that would have been recycled anyway, raising the program’s cost — like the rat-tail bounty in the lesson.When an incentive changes, behavior changes — including behavior the designer did not expect. - A bakery’s cost of making each additional batch of bread rises: $30, $36, $45, $60, $80 for batches 1 to 5. Each batch sells for $50. How many batches should it make, and why not stop at the batch with the lowest cost?
Check your answer
Answer: Three batches. Batches 1-3 each add more revenue ($50) than cost ($30, $36, $45), for a gain of $39; the 4th would add $60 of cost for $50 of revenue. Stopping after batch 1 would give up the $19 that batches 2 and 3 add.Make each batch whose marginal revenue ($50) at least covers its marginal cost; the 4th ($60) does not.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- A price rises from $60 to $75. What is the percent change?
Check your answer
Answer: 25%(75 − 60) ÷ 60. - Solve 1,200 − 40P = 400.
Check your answer
Answer: P = 20Subtract 1,200: −40P = −800.
Missouri’s motor fuel tax of 29.5 cents a gallon is a monetary incentive that raises the price of driving, while its driver-license point system, which suspends the license of a driver with eight points in eighteen months, is a nonmonetary one that changes how people drive.
Think about a school rule or a local policy. What incentives does it create, and what behaviors does it likely encourage or discourage?
How confident are you that you can reason about a decision in terms of opportunity cost, the margin and incentives?
The Shift
- Scarcity forces choices, and the true cost of any choice is the opportunity cost.
- Rational decisions compare marginal benefits and marginal costs, ignoring sunk costs.
- People respond to incentives, and economic claims can be positive (testable) or normative (value-based).
Three Decisions: Opportunity Cost, the Margin and Incentives
SLS original, built on Missouri statutes and state agency pages (Revised Statutes of Missouri sections 142.803, 142.822, 302.302 and 302.304; Missouri Department of Labor and Industrial Relations, Minimum Wage) and the U.S. Department of Labor; retrieved November 5, 2026 · SLS original
Why this reading. Your worksheet asks you to analyze three real decisions — one of your own, one a business makes, one a government makes — and for each to give the opportunity cost, the marginal benefit and marginal cost of doing a little more, and one incentive that would change the answer. This reading works all three decisions out in full so you can see what a finished analysis looks like, and gives you the real Missouri rates and rules you need to do your own. What to look for: in each worked decision, find the sentence that says what was given up, and the sentence that compares one more unit rather than the whole activity. Those are the two moves the worksheet is testing.
1. Scarcity is the reason economics exists
Scarcity is not the same as poverty, and it is not the same as running out. Scarcity means that the resources available — hours, dollars, land, workers, attention — are limited relative to the uses people would like to put them to. A billionaire faces scarcity of time; a city with a large budget faces scarcity of land. Because resources are limited and wants are not, every use of a resource is also a refusal of some other use. That refusal is the subject of this lesson.
2. Opportunity cost is what you gave up, not what you paid
The opportunity cost of a choice is the value of the best alternative you gave up to make it. The two errors students make are opposite ones:
- Counting only money paid. A concert with a free ticket is not free if you turned down a paid shift to attend it. If the shift would have paid $120, the opportunity cost of the concert is that $120 plus anything else the evening displaced — sleep, study time, a family obligation. “Free” describes the price, not the cost.
- Counting every alternative. Opportunity cost is the best alternative forgone, not the sum of all of them. You cannot both work the shift and study and sleep; you count the one you would actually have chosen.
This is why economists say the cost of a university degree is not only tuition. A student who studies full time for four years gives up four years of earnings as well. Those forgone earnings are usually the larger number.
3. Reasoning at the margin
Very few real decisions are all-or-nothing. The useful question is almost never “should I study?” but “should I study one more hour?” The extra benefit from one more unit is the marginal benefit; the extra cost of that unit is the marginal cost. Keep going while marginal benefit exceeds marginal cost; stop where they meet.
Marginal analysis has a property that surprises people: total costs and benefits are irrelevant to it. A restaurant can be enormously profitable overall and still be right to close at nine o’clock, if the tenth hour brings in less than the wages and electricity it consumes. And a business can be losing money overall and still be right to stay open tonight, if tonight’s takings more than cover tonight’s extra costs.
The mirror image of that rule is the sunk cost: money or time already spent that cannot be recovered. A sunk cost is the same whatever you now choose, so it cannot change which choice is better. Staying at a bad film because you paid $15 does not recover the $15; it spends ninety minutes on top of it.
4. Incentives, monetary and nonmonetary
An incentive is anything that changes the costs or benefits of a choice. It is useful to sort them:
| Kind | Examples | A Missouri instance |
|---|---|---|
| Monetary — changes dollars gained or lost | Wages, prices, taxes, fines, subsidies, deposits, tolls | Missouri’s motor fuel tax: 17 cents a gallon under RSMo § 142.803(1), plus an added 12.5 cents a gallon from 1 July 2025 under § 142.803(3) — 29.5 cents in all. You pay it inside the price at the pump. |
| Nonmonetary — changes time, effort, risk, status or standing | Queues, paperwork, publicity, social approval or shame, legal exposure, convenience | Missouri’s driver-license point system. A moving violation not otherwise listed adds 2 points (RSMo § 302.302), and the director of revenue must suspend the license of a driver who has accumulated eight points in eighteen months (§ 302.304). No money changes hands when points are assessed, but the prospect of losing the right to drive changes how people drive. |
Two wage floors you will need as numbers rather than adjectives: the federal minimum wage has been $7.25 per hour since 24 July 2009, and Missouri’s statewide minimum wage is $15.00 per hour for 2026, up from $13.75 in 2025 (Missouri Department of Labor and Industrial Relations). The state page notes that retail or service businesses with annual gross income under $500,000 are not required to pay the state rate, and that employers covered by the federal law must still follow whichever rule is stricter.
Incentives can misfire. Any incentive rewards the thing it measures, which is not always the thing anyone wanted. A bounty paid per animal killed rewards producing animals to kill. A tax refund rewards filing refund claims, so the rules must check that the fuel was really used as the law requires — which is why Missouri’s refund statute asks for the vehicle identification number and date of sale of each purchase (RSMo § 142.822). A school rewarded for its average test score has a reason to care about the students near the passing mark and less reason to care about the rest. When you name an incentive in your worksheet, write one sentence on what it would reward if someone gamed it.
5. Positive and normative
A positive statement claims something about how the world is, and evidence can in principle settle it. A normative statement claims something about how the world ought to be, and evidence alone cannot settle it, because it also rests on values. Sort these:
| Statement | Kind | Why |
|---|---|---|
| “A higher fuel tax reduces the number of gallons of fuel bought.” | Positive | Count the gallons sold before and after. You might be wrong, and the data would show it. |
| “Missouri should raise its motor fuel tax again.” | Normative | Even if the tax raises the money, whether the roads are worth the cost to drivers is a judgment. |
| “Raising Missouri’s minimum wage from $13.75 to $15.00 on 1 January 2026 increased hourly pay for covered workers who kept their jobs.” | Positive | Testable, and in fact tested. |
| “The state should raise the gas tax.” | Normative | Contains “should”. |
Words like should, ought, unfair, too high and deserve signal a normative claim. Numbers alone do not make a claim positive: “the tax is too high at 50¢” is normative with a number in it.
6. Worked decision one — a student’s Saturday
Maya has a Saturday free. She can work a six-hour shift at $18 an hour, or spend the day on an SAT practice test and review.
- Opportunity cost of studying: the shift, worth 6 × $18 = $108 before tax, plus whatever the day would otherwise have held. The opportunity cost of working is the expected score gain from the study day.
- At the margin: the choice is rarely all six hours. Suppose the first study hour is worth a lot (she reviews the question types she always misses) and the sixth is worth little (she is tired and re-reading things she knows). Each hour of study costs $18 of forgone wages — the marginal cost is flat. The marginal benefit falls as the day goes on. She should study until the extra value of one more hour drops to about $18, then work the rest.
- A sunk cost to ignore: she has already paid $60 for the practice book. That $60 is gone whether she opens it today or not, so it should not push her into a sixth hour.
- An incentive that would change the decision: if her employer offered time-and-a-half for Saturdays, the marginal cost of each study hour would rise to $27 and she would study fewer hours. A scholarship that paid out at a score threshold would raise the marginal benefit of the hours near that threshold and she would study more.
- Labels: “A higher Saturday wage would lead Maya to study fewer hours” is positive. “Maya ought to study, because education matters more than money” is normative.
7. Worked decision two — a café’s closing time
A café currently closes at 8 p.m. and is deciding whether to stay open until 9.
| The extra hour | Amount | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Extra revenue expected | $95 | Marginal benefit |
| Two staff, one hour, at $15.00 | $30.00 | Marginal cost |
| Extra electricity, milk, cups, cleaning | $22 | Marginal cost |
| Rent, insurance, the espresso machine loan | $0 | Not marginal — unchanged by the extra hour |
| Marginal benefit minus marginal cost | +$43.00 | Stay open |
Notice what the table leaves out. Rent and the loan payment are real costs of being in business, and if they cannot be covered the café should eventually close altogether — but they are the same at 8 p.m. and at 9 p.m., so they cannot decide this question. Notice too that there is a nonmonetary cost the owner may weigh: an hour of her own evening. If she values that hour at more than $43.00, she closes at eight and is behaving rationally.
- Opportunity cost of staying open: the owner’s evening, and the use the staff, the space and the cash could have had instead.
- An incentive that would change the decision: a local ordinance requiring a premium for hours after 8 p.m. would raise marginal cost; a nearby cinema changing its last screening to 8.30 would raise marginal benefit.
8. Worked decision three — a state’s fuel tax
Missouri’s motor fuel tax was 17 cents a gallon (RSMo § 142.803(1)). In 2021 the General Assembly added a second layer, scheduled in steps (§ 142.803(3)): 2.5 cents a gallon from 1 October 2021, 5 cents from 1 July 2022, 7.5 cents from 1 July 2023, 10 cents from 1 July 2024 and 12.5 cents from 1 July 2025. That is 17 + 12.5 = 29.5 cents a gallon today. The added layer carries a refund: § 142.822 lets a taxpayer claim an exemption and refund of it, by filing a claim between 1 July and 30 September after the fiscal year. Take the question a legislator faces at each step: should the state take the next 2.5 cents?
- Opportunity cost: not the tax dollars themselves — those move from drivers to the state, a transfer. The real cost is what drivers give up by having less to spend elsewhere, and what the state gives up if it does not collect: the road and bridge work that the revenue would have paid for. Either way something is forgone; the question is which is worth more.
- At the margin: the unit is one more step of 2.5 cents. For a household that buys 600 gallons a year (an illustrative figure, not a Missouri statistic), one step costs 600 × $0.025 = $15.00 a year; the whole 12.5-cent layer costs 600 × $0.125 = $75.00, and the full 29.5 cents costs 600 × $0.295 = $177.00. A small step on one driver is a large sum across millions of gallons; the marginal analysis asks whether the next step buys more than it costs, not whether roads are good in general.
- Who gains and who loses: drivers and trucking firms pay in proportion to the fuel they buy; people who use the roads little pay little. This is a distribution question, separate from the efficiency question, and both belong in a policy analysis.
- An incentive that would change the decision: the refund. If a driver must spend an afternoon assembling vehicle numbers and dates of sale to recover the added layer, the time is a nonmonetary cost that the money incentive cannot offset on its own. Whether claiming is worth it depends on whether the refund exceeds the value of that time — the same marginal comparison, applied by the driver.
- Labels: “Raising the tax by another 2.5 cents would reduce the gallons of fuel bought” is positive. “Roads should be paid for by the people who drive on them” is normative — though it rests on a positive claim (that fuel purchases track road use) which could be checked.
9. The checklist for your own three decisions
- State the decision as a choice between two specific alternatives, not as a topic.
- Name the best alternative given up, and put a number or a concrete description on it.
- Identify what “one more unit” means here — one more hour, one more container, one more customer — and give the marginal benefit and marginal cost of that unit.
- Name one cost that is not marginal and say why it should be ignored.
- Name one incentive that would flip the decision, say whether it is monetary or nonmonetary, and say what it would reward if someone gamed it.
- Label each of your claims positive or normative, and for each normative one, name the value it rests on.
Sources: Revised Statutes of Missouri section 142.803, Imposition of tax on fuel, amount (revisor.mo.gov); Revised Statutes of Missouri section 142.822, Exemption from certain fuel tax increases; refund (revisor.mo.gov); Revised Statutes of Missouri section 302.302, Point system (revisor.mo.gov); Revised Statutes of Missouri section 302.304, Suspension and revocation (revisor.mo.gov); Missouri Department of Labor and Industrial Relations, Minimum Wage (labor.mo.gov); U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division, Minimum Wage (dol.gov)