THE VR SCHOOL
  • Schools & Districts
    • License the academy
    • Free program for your students
    • Request a demo
  • Catalog
    • AI & Data
    • Cybersecurity & Web
    • Programming
    • Health Science
    • All Guilds
    • All courses
  • Families
  • Accreditation
  • Log In
  • Request a demo
  • Home
  • Courses

RLP Economics — Principles of Economics

Curriculum

  • 4 Sections
  • 20 Lessons
  • 10 Weeks
Expand all sectionsCollapse all sections
  • Unit 1: Economic Reasoning and Markets
    5
    • 1.1
      Scarcity, Choice and Thinking at the Margin
      50 mins
    • 1.2
      Supply and Demand Lab — Building and Using the Model
      50 mins
    • 1.3
      Deliberation Lab — Price Controls and Missouri’s Ban on Local Rent Regulation
      50 mins
    • 1.4
      Workshop — Adam Smith, Property, Competition and Liberty
      50 mins
    • 1.5
      Performance Task — Missouri Market Analysis Report
      150 mins
  • Unit 2: Firms, Competition and Labor
    5
    • 2.1
      Competition, Profit and Entrepreneurship
      50 mins
    • 2.2
      Location Lab — Why Farms, Factories, Ports and Stores Are Where They Are
      50 mins
    • 2.3
      Deliberation Lab — Unions, the Minimum Wage and Missouri’s $15 Floor
      50 mins
    • 2.4
      Workshop — Wages, Productivity, Skills and Technological Change
      50 mins
    • 2.5
      Performance Task — Labor Market Report and Briefing
      150 mins
  • Unit 3: Government, Money and the Macroeconomy
    5
    • 3.1
      What Government Does in a Market Economy — and When It Costs Too Much
      50 mins
    • 3.2
      Measurement Lab — GDP, Jobs, Unemployment and Inflation
      50 mins
    • 3.3
      Deliberation Lab — Fiscal Policy, Deficits and the National Debt
      50 mins
    • 3.4
      Workshop — The Federal Reserve, Interest Rates and Financial Markets
      50 mins
    • 3.5
      Performance Task — Economic Policy Briefing
      150 mins
  • Unit 4: The Global Economy
    5
    • 4.1
      Why Nations Trade — Comparative Advantage and Its Gains
      50 mins
    • 4.2
      Exchange Rate Lab — What a Stronger or Weaker Dollar Does
      50 mins
    • 4.3
      Deliberation Lab — Tariffs Then and Now: Smoot-Hawley and Today’s Debate
      50 mins
    • 4.4
      Workshop — Capital, Labor and Borders in a Global Economy
      50 mins
    • 4.5
      Performance Task — Trade Policy Position Paper and Address
      200 mins

Deliberation Lab — Fiscal Policy, Deficits and the National Debt

Unit 3  ·  Deliberation & Civic Discourse Lab  ·  Lesson 13 of 20

Deliberation Lab — Fiscal Policy, Deficits and the National Debt

🕐 50 mins
The Big Question

How do government choices about spending, taxing, and borrowing shape our economic future and what trade-offs must we accept?

By the end of this lesson I can…

describe the aims of fiscal policy — taxation, borrowing and spending — and its influence on production, employment and prices, and deliberate on deficits and debt using CBO and Missouri State Auditor data.

Hands direct taxes and borrowing toward public spending while a growing debt stack weighs on the future.

Fiscal policy is the government’s use of taxation, borrowing and spending to influence the economy. It is set by Congress and the President at the federal level, and by legislatures and governors in the states.

Key Takeaway

Fiscal policy uses government spending, taxation, and borrowing to stabilize the economy, but persistent large deficits and a high national debt can have significant economic costs and limit future choices.

📖 Read for this lesson

The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.

  • Deficits, Debt and the Budget: CBO’s Numbers, Missouri’s Rules, and Both Sides of the ArgumentCBO, The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (February 11, 2026); U.S. Treasury Monthly Treasury Statement, September 2025, Table 9, and Financial Report data via FRED; Missouri Constitution, Art. III, Sections 36 and 37, Art. IV, Sections 24, 26 and 27, and Art. X, Section 18; Missouri State Auditor, Report No. 2025-101, Analysis of General Revenue Fund Financial Condition (Dec. 2025), and Citizens Summary and press release on the Hancock Amendment review for the year ended June 30, 2025 (June 2026); retrieved November 5, 2026 · about 15 min

    It carries CBO’s figures, the Treasury’s record, the verbatim Missouri constitutional rules on budgets, borrowing and the Hancock limit, and the State Auditor’s account of the General Revenue Fund, then the strongest case on each side, so you can answer the deliberation question with real numbers.

fiscal policy

Government use of taxation, borrowing and spending to influence the economy.

Before diving in, what do you think is the main purpose of the government collecting taxes and borrowing money?

+50 XP

During a recession, unemployment insurance payments rise and tax revenues fall without any new law. What is this?

Automatic stabilizers cushion downturns through existing tax and benefit rules.

The aims

💡 Did You Know?

The U.S. federal government has carried a national debt for almost its entire history, starting with borrowing to finance the Revolutionary War.

Beyond paying for public goods and programs, fiscal policy aims to stabilize the economy — to support production and employment in recessions and to avoid fueling inflation in booms. The idea, associated with John Maynard Keynes after the Great Depression, is that when private spending collapses, government spending or tax cuts can support total demand. Expansionary policy (more spending, lower taxes) raises demand; contractionary policy (less spending, higher taxes) cools it.

Myth or Fact?

Missouri, like the federal government, may borrow whatever it needs to cover ongoing operating deficits without asking the voters.

Myth. The Missouri Constitution (Article III, Section 37) allows state liabilities above $1 million only with the approval of a majority of voters, so operating deficits come out of savings, not borrowing.

Automatic stabilizers

Some fiscal policy happens without new votes. In a recession, tax revenues fall and unemployment insurance and other benefits rise automatically, cushioning the drop in spending. In a boom the reverse happens.

Record your 90-second deliberation position on deficit reduction, citing at least one CBO figure and labeling your positive and normative claims. In two replies, synthesize the other speaker’s evidence and identify one question that more data could answer.

0 words

Deficits and debt

When the government spends more than it collects in a year, it runs a deficit and borrows by selling Treasury securities. The national debt is the accumulated total of past borrowing. Federal deficits have been large in recent years, and the Congressional Budget Office projects rising debt relative to GDP, driven largely by growth in Social Security, Medicare and interest costs as the population ages.

deficit

The amount by which spending exceeds revenue in a year.

national debt

The accumulated total of past federal borrowing.

The government’s budget works exactly like my family’s budget: if we spend more than we earn, we go broke.

Unlike a household, the federal government can borrow by issuing Treasury securities and does not need to balance its budget annually, though persistent deficits have distinct economic costs.

Why it matters — and the debate

Borrowing lets government respond to emergencies such as wars, recessions and pandemics without sudden tax increases, and borrowing for investment can pay for itself if it raises future output. But persistent large deficits have costs: interest payments crowd out other spending; heavy government borrowing may raise interest rates and crowd out private investment; and a high debt limits room to respond to the next crisis. Economists disagree about how much debt is too much and how fast to reduce it — a mix of positive questions (what happens to interest rates and growth?) and normative ones (who should pay, and what should be cut?).

Missouri’s version

Unlike the federal government, Missouri cannot borrow to cover its ongoing operating costs without a statewide vote: Article III, Section 37 of the Missouri Constitution denies the General Assembly the power to create a state liability above one million dollars (apart from refunding existing bonds) unless a majority of voters approve it, and Article IV, Section 27 lets the Governor hold spending below appropriations when revenue falls short of the estimate. A deficit in the General Revenue Fund therefore has to be covered from savings built up in earlier years, or closed by raising revenue or cutting spending. Revenue from income, sales and corporate taxes moves with the economy, so the state keeps a Budget Reserve Fund as well as a General Revenue balance, and the Missouri State Auditor reviews the state’s finances: its December 2025 report found that General Revenue spending had run ahead of revenue and, on the Auditor’s stated assumptions, the balance would be used up in fiscal 2028.

Effects on prices

Fiscal expansion when the economy is already near full employment can raise inflation, because demand grows faster than the economy’s capacity to produce. Many economists attribute part of the 2021-2022 inflation to large fiscal support combined with supply disruptions; others weight supply factors more heavily. HR.1 asks you to distinguish valid from fallacious arguments — watch for arguments that treat the federal budget exactly like a household’s, and for arguments that treat deficits as costless.

Deliberation question

Should reducing the federal deficit be a higher priority than new spending or tax cuts over the next five years? Use at least one CBO figure.

Key terms

automatic stabilizers

Taxes and benefits that change automatically with the economy, cushioning swings.

crowding out

The reduction in private investment when government borrowing raises interest rates.

Practice

Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.

Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)

Fluency

Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.

  1. Illustrative federal figures: spending $6.8 trillion, revenue $4.9 trillion. What is the deficit?
    Check your answer
    Answer: $1.9 trillion
    Spending − revenue.
  2. Debt held by the public is $28 trillion at the start of a year with a $1.9 trillion deficit. About what is it at year’s end?
    Check your answer
    Answer: About $29.9 trillion
    The deficit adds to the accumulated debt.
  3. Expansionary or contractionary? (a) A tax cut. (b) Spending cuts. (c) A new highway program. (d) A tax increase.
    Check your answer
    Answer: (a) expansionary; (b) contractionary; (c) expansionary; (d) contractionary
    More spending or lower taxes raise demand.
  4. In a recession, tax revenue falls and unemployment insurance payments rise without any new law. What is this called?
    Check your answer
    Answer: Automatic stabilizers
    They cushion downturns through existing rules.

Application

Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.

  1. Illustrative: federal debt held by the public $28.2 trillion; GDP $29.0 trillion. What is the debt-to-GDP ratio, and why do economists use a ratio rather than the dollar figure?
    Check your answer
    Answer: 97.2%. The ratio compares debt with the economy’s capacity to carry it; the dollar figure grows with prices and output.
    28.2 ÷ 29.0.
  2. On $28 trillion of debt, the average interest rate rises from 2.5% to 3.3% (illustrative). How much do annual interest costs rise? Name the cost of this for other spending.
    Check your answer
    Answer: From $700 billion to $924 billion: $224 billion more a year. Interest crowds out other spending.
    28 trillion × each rate.
  3. Missouri’s General Revenue Fund took in $13.431 billion in fiscal 2025 and received $0.219 billion in transfers; it spent $14.132 billion (Missouri State Auditor, Report 2025-101). Find the fiscal 2025 spending deficit. Then suppose revenue falls 2.10% in fiscal 2026 (the consensus estimate), transfers stay at $0.219 billion, and spending is $15.430 billion (the Auditor’s estimate): how large is that year’s deficit, and what is left of the $4.320 billion year-end balance? Why must Missouri keep a balance at all?
    Check your answer
    Answer: Fiscal 2025: 13.431 + 0.219 − 14.132 = −$0.482 billion. Fiscal 2026: revenue 13.431 × 0.979 ≈ $13.149 billion, so 13.149 + 0.219 − 15.430 ≈ −$2.061 billion, leaving about 4.320 − 2.061 = $2.259 billion. Missouri cannot borrow for operating costs without a statewide vote (Article III, Section 37), so a deficit can only be covered from savings.
    13.431 × 0.979, then add transfers and subtract spending.
  4. In a recession, 100,000 more Missourians receive unemployment insurance of up to $320 a week (the maximum weekly benefit amount in section 288.038 of the Revised Statutes of Missouri) for 20 weeks (illustrative). If all receive the maximum, how much is paid out, and how does this act as a stabilizer?
    Check your answer
    Answer: $640 million. It supports spending when incomes fall, without any new law.
    100,000 × 320 × 20.

Challenge

Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.

  1. Evaluate the argument: “The federal government must balance its budget every year, just like a family.” Name what is valid and what is fallacious.
    Check your answer
    Answer: Valid: persistent large deficits have costs — interest, crowding out, less room for crises. Fallacious: the federal government, unlike a family, borrows in its own currency, lives indefinitely and can stabilize the economy by borrowing in recessions; forcing balance every year would cut spending just when the economy is weakest.
    HR.1: separate the valid part from the analogy that fails.
  2. Illustrative federal budget: outlays $6.75 trillion, of which net interest is $0.88 trillion. What share is interest? If interest grows 8% a year and outlays 4% a year, what is the share after 5 years?
    Check your answer
    Answer: Now 13.0%; after 5 years 15.7%
    0.88 × 1.08⁵ ÷ (6.75 × 1.04⁵).

Review

Keep earlier skills sharp.

  1. Positive or normative: “Cutting the deficit should come before new spending.”
    Check your answer
    Answer: Normative
    It states a priority.
  2. CPI rises from 280.0 to 294.0. Inflation?
    Check your answer
    Answer: 5.0%
    14 ÷ 280.

Unlike the federal government, Missouri cannot create a state debt above one million dollars without a majority vote of the people (Article III, Section 37), and the Governor can hold spending below appropriations when revenue falls short (Article IV, Section 27), so a shortfall must be covered from savings, new revenue or cuts.

Given the potential costs and benefits, how should policymakers balance the need to address immediate crises with the long-term impact of national debt?

Quick self-check

How confident are you that you can explain fiscal policy’s aims and effects and argue about deficits using real budget data?

Not yetVery confident
SHIFT

The Shift

  • Fiscal policy uses taxes, spending, and borrowing to influence the economy.
  • Deficits occur when spending exceeds revenue in a year, contributing to national debt.
  • Large debt can lead to higher interest payments and crowd out private investment.

Missouri Learning Standards — Social Studies (Economic Concepts) addressed: 9-12.GV.3.EC.A, 9-12.GV.4.EC.A, 9-12.GV.3.EC.B, 9-12.GV.1.EC.A, SL.11-12.1, RH.11-12.6

Instructional focus: Deliberation on fiscal policy with budget data

Reading

Deficits, Debt and the Budget: CBO’s Numbers, Missouri’s Rules, and Both Sides of the Argument

CBO, The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (February 11, 2026); U.S. Treasury Monthly Treasury Statement, September 2025, Table 9, and Financial Report data via FRED; Missouri Constitution, Art. III, Sections 36 and 37, Art. IV, Sections 24, 26 and 27, and Art. X, Section 18; Missouri State Auditor, Report No. 2025-101, Analysis of General Revenue Fund Financial Condition (Dec. 2025), and Citizens Summary and press release on the Hancock Amendment review for the year ended June 30, 2025 (June 2026); retrieved November 5, 2026 · Public domain (CBO, Treasury, Missouri constitutional text and Missouri State Auditor reports)

Why this reading. Lesson 3.3 asks you to take a position on deficit reduction and cite at least one figure from the Congressional Budget Office. This reading carries those figures, the Treasury’s record of what actually happened, the text of the Missouri Constitution’s rules on state budgets and borrowing and the State Auditor’s account of Missouri’s own General Revenue Fund for the true/false, and then the strongest case on each side of the deliberation — written so that neither side is the straw one. CBO reports, Treasury statements, the Missouri Constitution and Missouri State Auditor reports are public documents. Where the arguments are ours, they are labeled as arguments.

1. What actually happened: the record

The federal government spends more than it collects, borrows the difference by selling Treasury securities, and the accumulated borrowing is the national debt. The Treasury’s own accounts:

MeasureAmountAs of
Federal surplus or deficit, fiscal year 2025−$1.775 trillionyear ended Sept. 30, 2025
Net interest paid on the debt, fiscal year 2025$970 billionyear ended Sept. 30, 2025
Debt held by the public$31.71 trillionend of Q2 2026
Total public debt outstanding (including debt the government owes itself)$39.46 trillionend of Q2 2026

Two different debt numbers appear in public argument and they are not interchangeable. Debt held by the public is money actually borrowed from investors, pension funds, banks and foreign governments; it is the figure economists use, because it is the amount that competes with private borrowers for savings. Gross debt adds the securities that trust funds — chiefly Social Security’s — hold in the Treasury, which is the government owing itself. Whichever figure someone quotes, check which one it is.

Note the interest line. In fiscal 2025 the federal government paid $970 billion in net interest — more than it spent on almost anything else. Interest is not a policy choice in any given year; it is the bill for past choices, and it rises with both the stock of debt and the interest rate.

2. What CBO projects

The Congressional Budget Office is Congress’s own nonpartisan scorekeeper. Its Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036, published February 2026, projects on the assumption that current law does not change — a deliberately artificial assumption that makes the projection a baseline to argue from, not a forecast of what will happen.

CBO baseline20262036
Outlays$7.4 trillion, 23.3% of GDP24.4% of GDP
Revenues$5.6 trillion, 17.5% of GDP17.8% of GDP
Deficit$1.9 trillion, 5.8% of GDP$3.1 trillion, 6.7% of GDP
Net interest (deficit minus primary deficit)about 3.2% of GDP (5.8 − 2.6)about 4.6% of GDP (6.7 − 2.1)
Debt held by the public101% of GDP120% of GDP

Three reference points make those numbers mean something. Deficits have averaged about 3.8% of GDP over the past fifty years, so 5.8% is well above the post-war norm and 6.7% further still. Revenues at 17.8% of GDP in 2036 would be slightly above their fifty-year average of 17.3%, so the projected gap opens on the spending side, not because taxes fall. And debt held by the public at 120% of GDP would pass its previous record of 106% of GDP in 1946, at the end of the Second World War. The primary deficit, which leaves out net interest, is CBO’s way of separating what Congress chooses from what past borrowing costs: it is 2.6% of GDP in 2026 and 2.1% in 2036, so the whole rise in the deficit comes from interest.

CBO attributes the rise in outlays to greater spending on Social Security and Medicare and to growth in net interest costs, partly offset by declining discretionary outlays. Rising net interest accounts for much of the increase in the deficit between 2026 and 2036 — the deficit grows 0.9 points of GDP (5.8% to 6.7%) while net interest grows about 1.4 points (3.2% to 4.6%), and the primary deficit shrinks by half a point. All the figures in this table are CBO’s, except the net-interest row, which is our subtraction of two CBO figures from each other and is rounded.

3. Automatic stabilizers

Not all fiscal policy is voted on. When output falls, incomes fall, so income and payroll tax revenue falls with them; at the same time more people qualify for unemployment insurance, nutrition assistance and Medicaid, so those outlays rise. Nobody passes a law; the deficit widens on its own and cushions the fall in spending. In a boom the same rules run in reverse and the deficit narrows. Economists call these automatic stabilizers, and they matter for reading any deficit figure: part of a deficit is the economy, not the policy. A deficit that widens in a recession is the system working; a deficit of the same size at full employment is a choice.

4. Missouri is different, and the text says so

The federal government can borrow without a vote. The state of Missouri cannot. Four provisions of the Missouri Constitution work together; read the words, because the true/false turns on them.

The Governor must budget against estimated revenue. Article IV, Section 24 requires the Governor, within thirty days after the General Assembly convenes in each regular session, to “submit to the general assembly a budget for the ensuing appropriation period, containing the estimated available revenues of the state and a complete and itemized plan of proposed expenditures of the state and all its agencies.” The same section adds that “The governor shall not determine estimated available revenues of the state using any projection of new revenues to be created from proposed legislation that has not been passed into law by the general assembly.” Revenue that is merely hoped for cannot be counted.

Borrowing needs the voters. Article III, Section 37 limits what the General Assembly may do:

The general assembly shall have no power to contract or authorize the contracting of any liability of the state, or to issue bonds therefor, except (1) to refund outstanding bonds, the refunding bonds to mature not more than twenty-five years from date, (2) on the recommendation of the governor, for a temporary liability to be incurred by reason of unforeseen emergency or casual deficiency in revenue, in a sum not to exceed one million dollars for any one year and to be paid in not more than five years from its creation, and (3) when the liability exceeds one million dollars, the general assembly as on constitutional amendments, or the people by the initiative, may also submit a measure containing the amount, purpose and terms of the liability, and if the measure is approved by a majority of the qualified electors of the state voting thereon at the election, the liability may be incurred

So a liability larger than $1 million cannot be incurred by borrowing unless a majority of Missouri voters approve the measure. That is the constitutional answer to the question “may Missouri borrow to cover ongoing operating costs?” — not without a statewide vote, and the emergency exception is capped at one million dollars a year.

The Governor can hold spending back. Article IV, Section 27 gives the Governor the tool for the case where revenue falls short of the estimate:

The governor may control the rate at which any appropriation is expended during the period of the appropriation by allotment and may reduce the expenditures of the state or any of its agencies below their appropriations whenever the actual revenues are less than the revenue estimates upon which the appropriations were based. The governor shall not reduce any appropriation for the payment of principal and interest on the public debt.

Article IV, Section 26 adds the partial veto: the Governor “may object to one or more items or portions of items of appropriation of money in any bill presented to him, while approving other portions of the bill,” and “shall not reduce any appropriation for free public schools, or for the payment of principal and interest on the public debt.” Article III, Section 36 sets the order in which appropriations are made: first the sinking fund and interest on outstanding obligations of the state, second public education.

A ceiling on revenue, too. The Hancock Amendment, Article X, Section 18(a), limits the other end of the budget: “the general assembly shall not impose taxes of any kind which, together with all other revenues of the state, federal funds excluded, exceed the revenue limit established in this section.” The limit is the 1980–81 ratio of state revenue to Missouri personal income applied to current personal income, and if revenue exceeds it by one percent or more, “the excess revenues shall be refunded pro rata.” The State Auditor reviews compliance every year. For the year ended June 30, 2025 he reported total state revenue of about $15.6 billion against a refund threshold of about $22.2 billion — so revenue was about $6.6 billion under the limit (15.6 ÷ 22.2 ≈ 70% of it), and the limit has not been exceeded since the year ended June 30, 1999. The 1981 base-year ratio of personal income to total state revenue is given as 5.6%, and Missouri personal income as nearly $388 billion; multiplying those two rounded figures gives about $21.7 billion, a little under the published $22.2 billion, because the constitution lets the calculation use whichever is greater of the prior year’s personal income or the average of the previous three years, and the Auditor’s release does not show the full calculation. A second limit, Section 18(e), caps how much new revenue the General Assembly may raise from tax and fee increases without a vote of the people: $150.5 million for fiscal 2025, against a projected net decrease of $855 million.

What the rules produce: the General Revenue Fund. Because Missouri cannot borrow for operating costs, an operating deficit has only one place to come from: money saved in earlier years. The Missouri State Auditor’s Analysis of General Revenue Fund Financial Condition (Report No. 2025-101, December 2025) describes exactly that. General Revenue is the one unrestricted state fund — it can be “budgeted and spent for any allowable state purpose at the discretion of the General Assembly” — and in fiscal 2025 it paid for 34.3% of state spending, against 43.1% from federal funds and 22.6% from other funds.

General Revenue FundAmount
Revenue, fiscal 2025$13.431 billion
Transfers into the fund, fiscal 2025$0.219 billion
Expenditures, fiscal 2025$14.132 billion
Spending deficit, fiscal 2025 (13.431 + 0.219 − 14.132)−$0.482 billion
Year-end balance, fiscal 2025$4.320 billion (peak: about $5.77 billion at the end of fiscal 2023)
Budget Reserve Fund (the rainy-day fund), June 30, 2025about $950 million
Change fiscal 2020 to fiscal 2025: revenue / expenditures / CPI+45.8% / +53.4% / +24.5%
Largest annual fall and rise in net collections, fiscal 2003–2025−9.1% and +25.8%

The Auditor’s finding was that deficit spending was reducing the large balance the fund had built up after the pandemic. The Auditor’s own projection — assuming the consensus revenue estimate of −2.10% for fiscal 2026 and +3.80% for fiscal 2027, average growth of 3.65% for fiscal 2028, and spending held at the fiscal 2026 level — showed spending deficits of about $2.06 billion, $1.56 billion and $1.06 billion in fiscal 2026, 2027 and 2028, which would take the $4.32 billion balance down to $2.26 billion, then $0.70 billion, then below zero (−$0.37 billion) in fiscal 2028. That is a projection built on stated assumptions, not a forecast, and the Auditor showed a second, harsher scenario as well. It is also a reminder of the warning in section 3: the part of a deficit that comes from the economy is not the same as the part that is a choice. The Auditor describes General Revenue as “historically volatile and unpredictable” — it comes mainly from personal income, sales and corporate income taxes — and says recent changes in tax law will put downward pressure on it.

On the rainy-day fund, the Auditor writes that, because of constitutional restrictions on its use, the Budget Reserve Fund is of limited use for shortages in General Revenue. A reserve exists, and it is small against a multi-billion-dollar gap — the same point economists make about reserves everywhere.

5. The deliberation: the strongest case on each side

The question is whether reducing the federal deficit should be a higher priority than new spending or tax cuts over the next five years. Both sides below are stated at their strongest, with the evidence each relies on. You are not required to find them equally convincing; you are required to answer the real one.

The case for making deficit reduction the priority

  1. Interest is crowding out everything else. $970 billion of net interest in fiscal 2025, and CBO’s projection that net interest rises from about 3.2% of GDP in 2026 to 4.6% in 2036, is money that buys no defense, no research, no benefit for anyone. It is also the fastest-growing item in the budget, and it grows whether or not Congress acts.
  2. Borrowing at 5.8% of GDP outside a recession is unusual. The fifty-year average is 3.8%, and those averages include recessions. Running large deficits at full employment uses up the borrowing capacity that exists for emergencies.
  3. Room to respond to the next crisis. The pandemic response was possible because markets would lend to the United States at low rates. A country already borrowing 6–7% of GDP a year has less room when the next shock arrives.
  4. Crowding out private investment. Heavy government borrowing competes for the same savings that fund business investment and mortgages, tending to push interest rates up and investment down, which lowers future output.
  5. Adjustment gets harder the longer it waits. Stabilizing debt at 101% of GDP requires smaller changes than stabilizing it at 120%, and changes made with notice let people plan.

The case against treating deficit reduction as the priority

  1. The ratio has a denominator. Debt is measured against GDP. Borrowing that raises future output — infrastructure, research, children’s health and education — can improve the ratio it worsens in the short run. Cutting such spending to cut the deficit can leave the country poorer and the ratio no better.
  2. The United States borrows in its own currency. It cannot be forced into default by an inability to obtain dollars, and demand for Treasury securities as the world’s safe asset has remained strong at debt levels many predicted would break it. The predicted interest-rate crisis has been forecast repeatedly and has not arrived.
  3. Timing matters more than level. Contracting fiscal policy into a weak economy can deepen the weakness and, by shrinking GDP, fail to reduce the debt ratio at all. Several European economies after 2010 are the evidence usually cited on this side.
  4. “The deficit” hides the real question. A deficit can be closed by raising revenue or cutting spending, and which one is chosen decides who pays. Making the deficit itself the priority smuggles that distributional choice past the argument.
  5. Opportunity cost runs both ways. Every dollar of deficit reduction is a dollar not spent on something. The comparison is not deficit versus nothing; it is deficit versus whatever the borrowing bought.

Where the disagreement actually lies

Economists broadly agree on the arithmetic in section 2 — CBO’s numbers are not contested by either side. They disagree about three things, and naming which one you are arguing about will make your position clearer than any figure: how much government borrowing raises interest rates and reduces private investment (estimates vary and the effect appears smaller than older models assumed); how large the return is on public investment, which decides whether borrowing for it pays for itself; and how much risk is acceptable, since the cost of a debt crisis is enormous and its probability cannot be measured.

6. Two fallacies to watch for, in yourself and others

The lesson asks you to distinguish valid from fallacious argument. Two appear in nearly every deficit debate.

The household analogy. “A family cannot spend more than it earns, so neither can the government.” A household does not print the currency it borrows in, does not collect taxes from its own members, does not live forever, and its spending does not determine its own income. A closer analogy is a firm that borrows to invest: the question is whether the borrowing earns more than it costs. The analogy is not useless — interest must be paid in both cases — but it settles nothing on its own.

Deficits as costless. The mirror-image error is to treat borrowing as free because the government controls its own currency. The $970 billion interest bill is real, is paid, and is rising. Both errors work by replacing a quantitative question with a slogan.

7. Positive and normative, labeled

Your position must mark which claims evidence could settle. Positive: CBO projects the 2026 deficit at 5.8% of GDP; debt held by the public is projected to reach 120% of GDP by 2036 under current law; net interest was $970 billion in fiscal 2025. Normative: the gap should be closed by raising revenue rather than cutting benefits; today’s taxpayers should not pass this bill to their children; a small risk of a debt crisis is worth running to fund investment now. A good 90-second position states one figure, one mechanism, and one value, and says which is which.

Sources: CBO, The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (read from the Internet Archive capture of Oct. 10, 2026, because cbo.gov blocks automated requests) (cbo.gov); U.S. Treasury Fiscal Data, Monthly Treasury Statement Table 9 (net interest, fiscal 2025) (fiscaldata.treasury.gov); Federal Surplus or Deficit, Treasury data via FRED (fred.stlouisfed.org); Federal Debt Held by the Public (Treasury, via FRED) (fred.stlouisfed.org); Federal Debt: Total Public Debt (via FRED) (fred.stlouisfed.org); Missouri Constitution, Article IV, Section 24 (governor’s budget) (revisor.mo.gov); Missouri Constitution, Article IV, Section 26 (partial veto) (revisor.mo.gov); Missouri Constitution, Article IV, Section 27 (governor may reduce expenditures) (revisor.mo.gov); Missouri Constitution, Article III, Section 36 (order of appropriations) (revisor.mo.gov); Missouri Constitution, Article III, Section 37 (limitation on state debts and bond issues) (revisor.mo.gov); Missouri Constitution, Article X, Section 18 (Hancock Amendment revenue limit) (revisor.mo.gov); Missouri State Auditor, Analysis of General Revenue Fund Financial Condition, Report No. 2025-101 (auditor.mo.gov); Missouri State Auditor, Citizens Summary: Review of Article X, Sections 16 through 24 (June 2026) (auditor.mo.gov); Missouri State Auditor press release, Auditor Fitzpatrick finds state revenues in compliance with Hancock Amendment (June 23, 2026) (auditor.mo.gov)

Up NextComplete & Continue →

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Measurement Lab — GDP, Jobs, Unemployment and Inflation
Prev
Workshop — The Federal Reserve, Interest Rates and Financial Markets
Next

© 2026 The VR School | Career content by Wiley | Powered by Sejal Learning Systems.

Join free · Accreditation · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service

Modal title

Main Content