How can we design trade policies that benefit Missouri while fairly addressing global economic realities and inevitable trade-offs?
analyze a current trade question affecting Missouri with data and the unit’s concepts, take and defend a position answering the strongest opposing argument, and present it to a non-specialist audience.

The semester’s final task brings together everything you have learned about markets, government and the world in one real policy question.
Effective trade policy requires rigorous data analysis, an understanding of economic principles, and a clear-eyed assessment of who gains and who loses.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
What do you think are the biggest challenges in creating a trade policy that works for a diverse economy like Missouri’s?
comparative advantage
Tap to revealLower opportunity cost of producing a good.
appreciation
Tap to revealA rise in a currency’s value.
tariff
Tap to revealA tax on imports.
Smoot-Hawley
Tap to revealThe 1930 tariff that provoked retaliation during the Depression.
foreign direct investment
Tap to revealBuilding or buying productive assets abroad.
Choose a question
Many everyday items, from clothing to electronics, involve components or manufacturing processes from multiple countries, highlighting the global nature of production and supply chains.
A current trade issue that affects Missouri: tariffs on a category of imports (steel, aluminum, vehicles and parts), retaliatory tariffs on Missouri farm exports (soybeans, corn, pork, beef), the North American trade agreement, the auto or aerospace supply chain, or support for an industry facing foreign competition. It must be live — something being decided or debated now.
A new tariff protects a U.S. industry but draws retaliation on Missouri pork exports. Which analysis is most complete?
Evidence
At least four sources: trade data from the Census Bureau or USDA; one primary government document (the tariff order, a trade agreement text, a USTR or Commerce Department notice, or congressional testimony); and at least one source representing each side — for example, a union and an exporters’ association, or two think tanks with different views. Note each source’s interest (HR.1).
Trade policies are designed to benefit everyone, so there’s always one clear best policy for a country.
Every trade policy creates both winners and losers, making policy decisions complex choices about priorities and trade-offs.
Analysis
Apply the unit’s tools. Comparative advantage: who has it, and what does specialization imply? Prices: how would the policy change what consumers and businesses pay? Exchange rates: how might the dollar’s movement amplify or offset the policy? History: what does Smoot-Hawley suggest, and how is the present case different? Winners and losers: name the specific groups, in Missouri and elsewhere, who gain and who lose, and estimate the size of each effect where the data allow.
Position
State what U.S. policy should be, or what Missouri should do within its own powers. WHST.11-12.1.b asks you to develop claims and counterclaims fairly: give the opposing side its strongest form, with its evidence, and answer it. Acknowledge the limitation of your own position — every trade policy has losers.
Positive and normative
As all semester, mark which claims are predictions that evidence could test and which are judgments about priorities. Readers who disagree with your conclusion should still find your analysis sound.
The address
Three minutes for a non-specialist audience — a community meeting, not an economics class. Define tariff and comparative advantage in passing, state your position early, give the one fact that matters most, and answer the other side.
Unit 4 checkpoint
Do this before you start the task. It covers the whole unit and tells you what to review first.
Country A makes 10 cloth or 5 wine per worker; Country B makes 6 cloth or 6 wine. Which has the comparative advantage in wine?
A country with an absolute advantage in every good cannot gain from trade.
Using Ricardo’s numbers, England’s opportunity cost of one unit of wine is units of cloth.
The dollar moves from 18 to 20 pesos. A 3,600-peso chair now costs a Missouri buyer:
A stronger dollar helps Missouri exporters.
At $1 = 20 pesos, a $50 case of pork costs pesos; higher U.S. interest rates tend to make the dollar .
Who pays most of a tariff on imported goods, according to most studies of recent U.S. tariffs?
Most economists see Smoot-Hawley as the main cause of the Great Depression.
A 25% tariff on a $600 import raises its price to $ if fully passed on.
A Japanese automaker builds a plant in Tennessee. This is:
Which is a positive statement?
Comparative advantage shows that every worker gains from trade.
Submit: Trade Policy Position Paper (1,000-1,200 words) + 3-minute address
Task: Analyze a live trade question affecting Missouri with data and the unit’s concepts, take a position, answer the strongest opposing argument, and present it to a non-specialist audience.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Question and sources. The trade question, four sources including trade data, a primary document and one per side, with each source’s interest noted.
- Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed draft. A partner representing the opposing side checks that you stated it fairly; submit a revision note.
- Stage 3 — Final paper. 1,000-1,200 words with analysis, winners and losers, position and counterclaim.
- Stage 4 — Three-minute address for a non-specialist audience.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Economic analysis (9-12.GV.1.EC.A, 9-12.GV.3.EC.A) | Comparative advantage, price and exchange-rate effects applied correctly. |
| Historical comparison (9-12.GV.3.EC.A) | Smoot-Hawley used as evidence, with differences noted. |
| Winners and losers (9-12.GV.1.EC.A) | Specific groups identified with evidence of the size of effects. |
| Counterclaim (WHST.11-12.1.b) | Strongest opposing argument stated fairly and answered; own limitation acknowledged. |
| Sources (WHST.11-12.8, 9-12.GV.1.EC.A) | Four credible sources, interests noted, positive and normative labeled. |
| Address (SL.11-12.4) | Clear for a non-specialist audience; position early; other side answered. |
Missouri’s two largest export markets in 2025 were Canada ($6.7 billion) and Mexico ($4.3 billion), and tariff disputes with either one can fall hardest on Missouri soybean, corn and pork growers.
After analyzing your chosen trade issue, how has your understanding of ‘winners’ and ‘losers’ in trade policy evolved?
How confident are you that you can analyze a real trade question and defend a position that answers the other side?
The Shift
- Trade policy involves complex choices.
- Every policy creates winners and losers.
- Data and reason strengthen your position.
The Trade Policy Dossier: Four Live Questions and the Evidence on Each
SLS reading for Economics, built on USTR and Census Bureau trade data, USITC Publication 5405 (March 2023), Federal Reserve H.10 exchange rates (via FRED), BEA national accounts (via FRED) and Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump (2026); retrieved November 5, 2026 · SLS original
Why this reading. The position paper needs a live question, four sources of the right kinds, and an analysis that actually uses the unit’s tools rather than mentioning them. This reading supplies four questions that are genuinely open, the evidence on each side of each, the primary government documents you can cite, and a method for naming winners and losers with numbers attached. It does not tell you what to conclude. Figures are drawn from the federal sources listed at the end; the Missouri cases are chosen because they are the state’s own largest exports and its largest trading partners.
1. The facts you can build any of these papers on
| Fact | Figure | Period | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Missouri goods exports | $19.6 billion, a record; 4.2% of Missouri GDP; the 25th largest state exporter | 2025 | USTR |
| Missouri’s top export markets | Canada $6.7bn (34%), Mexico $4.3bn, Israel $736m, Germany $700m, India $625m | 2025 | USTR |
| Missouri’s largest export categories | Transportation equipment $5.7bn, chemicals $3.7bn, machinery (except electrical) $1.6bn, food $1.4bn, other fabricated metal products $872m | 2025 | USTR |
| Missouri agricultural exports | $5.1 billion, 10th largest of any state; soybeans $1.5bn, corn $514m, soybean meal $398m, feeds $385m, pork $378m | 2024 | USTR (USDA data) |
| Jobs supported by Missouri goods exports | about 74,000 | 2023 | USTR |
| Missouri exporters | 5,597 companies, 84% of them with fewer than 500 employees | 2024 | USTR |
| Imports entering the United States destined for Missouri | $15.8 billion, about 0.57% of the national total | Jan.–Sept. 2026 | Census Bureau |
| U.S. goods trade with Mexico | exports $297.6bn, imports $481.6bn | Jan.–Sept. 2026 | Census Bureau |
| U.S. goods trade with Canada | exports $265.9bn, imports $304.6bn | Jan.–Sept. 2026 | Census Bureau |
| U.S. goods trade with China | exports $83.5bn, imports $215.0bn | Jan.–Sept. 2026 | Census Bureau |
| Average effective tariff on U.S. goods imports | 8.2%, against 2.7% in 2024 Q4 (customs duties ÷ goods imports); 6.8% in 2026 Q3 | 2026 Q2 | BEA, via FRED, computed |
| Measured pass-through of 2018–2021 tariffs to import prices | about 1% price rise per 1% of tariff; American importers bore nearly the full cost | 2018–2021 | USITC, March 2023 |
| Dollar against the peso, Canadian dollar, euro | +0.1%, +1.1%, +4.0% (the dollar bought that much more of each) | Oct. 2025 to Oct. 2026 | Federal Reserve H.10, via FRED |
2. Four live questions, with the case on each side
(a) Tariffs on imported steel and aluminum
The question: should the United States keep national-security tariffs on basic metals? For: domestic capacity in metals is a genuine security input, the industry is concentrated in regions with few alternative employers, and the USITC estimated that the Section 232 tariffs raised American steel production by 1.9% and aluminum production by 3.6% on average over 2018–2021 (its Table ES.1). Against: the same report estimated that downstream production fell, with industrial machinery, motor vehicle steering, suspension and brake components and other fabricated metal products among the most negatively affected industries (production quantities down by up to nearly 3 percent in 2021); on Chinese goods under Section 301 it found nearly complete pass-through of the tariff to U.S. importers’ prices; and far more Americans work in industries that use steel than in industries that make it — every Missouri manufacturer of vehicles, machinery and fabricated metal products buys metal. Missouri angle: the state exported $5.7 billion of transportation equipment, $1.6 billion of machinery and $872 million of fabricated metal products in 2025, all of it made from metal that the tariff makes dearer. Primary document: the Section 232 proclamations in the Federal Register; the USITC report.
(b) Retaliation against Missouri farm exports
The question: how should the United States weigh agricultural retaliation when it sets tariffs? For acting anyway: if the threat of retaliation vetoes every trade measure, the country cannot respond to unfair practices at all. Against: farm goods are the classic retaliation target because buyers can switch suppliers in one season, and once a market is lost it is slow to come back. This is the 1930 petition’s prediction in modern form, and Missouri, with $5.1 billion of agricultural exports (soybeans, corn, soybean meal, feeds and pork leading), is exposed. Beef is another Missouri product you could take up, but this reading carries no beef figure, so if you choose it you must find the USDA data yourself. Primary document: USDA export statistics; the retaliating country’s published tariff schedule; the 1930 petition in the Congressional Record of May 5, 1930 as the historical comparison.
(c) Tariffs on vehicles and parts, and the North American trade agreement
The question: should the United States tax imported vehicles and parts, and how should it treat Canada and Mexico under the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement? For: assembly plants and their suppliers anchor communities that have few other large employers, and a tariff that makes imports dearer can move production toward domestic plants. Against: a vehicle assembled in North America crosses borders several times before it is sold, so a tariff on parts is a tariff on the American plant that uses them, and retaliation by Canada or Mexico lands on exporters. Missouri angle: transportation equipment is Missouri’s largest manufactured export ($5.7 billion in 2025) and Canada and Mexico together took $11.0 billion of the state’s $19.6 billion; research one real plant — Ford’s Kansas City Assembly Plant in Claycomo or General Motors’ Wentzville Assembly — and Boeing’s work in St. Louis County for the aerospace side, and say what you can and cannot show about their trade exposure from public sources. A brewer such as Anheuser-Busch, headquartered in St. Louis, is a different case worth testing: which of its inputs and sales cross a border? Primary document: the USMCA text and USTR notices; Commerce Department notices in the Federal Register.
(d) Who decides: the constitutional question
The question: should tariff authority sit with Congress or with the President? For executive authority: tariffs are leverage in negotiations that move faster than legislation, and Congress has delegated the power deliberately, with conditions, in Sections 201, 232 and 301. Against: the taxing power is Congress’s, and a tariff set by one official can be changed by one official, which is bad for the firms that must plan around it. Primary document: Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump (Feb. 20, 2026), in which the Supreme Court held that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act does not authorize the President to impose tariffs, observing that “Had Congress intended to convey the distinct and extraordinary power to impose tariffs, it would have done so expressly, as it consistently has in other tariff statutes,” while distinguishing Section 232’s “sweeping, discretion-conferring language that IEEPA does not contain.”
3. Applying the unit’s four tools, properly
Comparative advantage. Do not write “comparative advantage says trade is good.” Identify which country has the lower opportunity cost in the good your policy touches, and what specialization therefore implies. Then say what the theorem does not claim: it says total output rises, not that everyone gains, which is exactly why a policy argument is possible.
Prices. A tariff raises the domestic price of the imported good and of domestic substitutes. Work out who pays: the household buying the finished good, and the manufacturer buying it as an input. The USITC’s near one-for-one pass-through is the number to anchor this on, and the average effective tariff rising from 2.7% to 8.2% between 2024 Q4 and 2026 Q2 (6.8% in 2026 Q3) is the scale.
Exchange rates. A currency movement can cancel a tariff or double it. A 10% tariff on goods from a country whose currency has fallen 10% against the dollar leaves the price to American buyers roughly where it was — and it makes American exports to that country dearer at the same time. Use the real figures: in the year to October 2026 the dollar rose 0.1% against the peso, 1.1% against the Canadian dollar and 4.0% against the euro, so an identical tariff on Mexican, Canadian and German goods had different effects on the delivered price.
History. Smoot-Hawley is evidence, not a slogan. American exports fell 66.7% and imports 65.2% between 1929 and 1932 while nominal GDP fell 43.1% — and much of that was falling prices and collapsing incomes rather than the tariff. Use it for the specific lesson it supports, which is that others retaliate and exporters pay, and state at least one way the present case differs: targeted rather than general, an institutional dispute system that did not exist in 1930, and purposes argued on security rather than protection.
4. Naming winners and losers with numbers
The task’s rubric asks for “specific groups identified with evidence of the size of effects.” Build a table like this one and fill every cell, marking clearly which entries are measured and which are estimated:
| Group | Gains or loses | Through what mechanism | Rough size, and how you know |
|---|---|---|---|
| Producers in the protected industry | Gain | Higher domestic price, larger domestic market share | Measured: output and price changes in the USITC study |
| American manufacturers using the input | Lose | Higher input cost | Estimated: input cost share × price rise |
| Households buying the final good | Lose | Pass-through to retail prices | Measured: near one-for-one pass-through to import prices |
| Missouri exporters facing retaliation | Lose | Foreign tariff on their product | Estimated: export value to that market × expected volume loss |
| Workers in import-competing regions | Gain, unevenly | Employment retained in specific plants and towns | Estimated, and concentrated — the strongest part of the case for restriction |
| Federal revenue | Gains | Duties collected | Measured: customs duties, $306 billion at an annual rate in 2026 Q2 ($275 billion in Q3) |
The last row is where most student papers go wrong. Tariff revenue is real money and it is collected from American importers, so it is simultaneously a gain to the Treasury and a cost to domestic buyers — a transfer, not new wealth. Saying so is the difference between analysis and cheerleading.
5. Sources, interests, and the counterclaim
Your four sources should be: trade data from the Census Bureau, USTR or USDA; one primary government document (a Federal Register notice, a court opinion, an agreement text, congressional testimony); and one source on each side whose interest you state in a clause. A steel producers’ association wants higher metal prices; a machinery manufacturers’ association wants lower ones; a farm bureau wants open export markets; a union in an import-competing plant wants the plant to stay open. None of these interests makes a source untrustworthy. They tell you what each one is likely to leave out, which is what you check.
Then write the counterclaim the way its best advocate would, before you answer it. If your position is that a tariff should be lifted, the strongest opposing argument is not “tariffs protect jobs” but something like: the gains from cheaper imports are a few dollars spread across a hundred million households, while the losses are concentrated on a few thousand workers in places with no other employer, and research on regions exposed to rapid import growth found those losses lasting for years. A policy that maximizes the total while destroying a town has answered the wrong question. Answer that. And acknowledge your own position’s limitation, because every trade policy, including the policy of having none, has losers.
Finally, mark your positive and normative claims as you have all semester. A tariff at this rate would raise the delivered price of this good by about this much is testable. That cost is worth paying to keep this industry in the United States is a judgment. A reader who disagrees with your conclusion should still be unable to fault your analysis.
Sources: Office of the United States Trade Representative, Missouri (ustr.gov); U.S. Census Bureau, imports by state of destination (Sept. 2026 year to date) (census.gov); U.S. Census Bureau, trade in goods by country (Mexico, Canada, China) (census.gov); USITC, Economic Impact of Section 232 and 301 Tariffs on U.S. Industries (Pub. 5405) (usitc.gov); Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, slip opinion (February 20, 2026) (supremecourt.gov); Federal Reserve Statistical Release H.10, Foreign Exchange Rates (via FRED) (fred.stlouisfed.org); Federal customs duties receipts and goods imports (BEA, via FRED) (fred.stlouisfed.org); Federal Register (agency tariff and export-control notices) (federalregister.gov); Wentzville Assembly; Kansas City Assembly Plant; Boeing Defense, Space & Security; Anheuser-Busch (Wikipedia, for locations only) (en.wikipedia.org)