use my test patterns to change one feature, then check if version 2 has what it needs to work.
Phase 4: Build
Let’s think. Your cup phone’s string was droopy. It only worked 1 time out of 5. What one thing would you change?
What is the best change to try?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Signal makers, today you make version 2. Version 2 is a better copy of your design. You will change one feature. Your pattern tells you which one.
Change one thing. If you change many things at once, you will not know which change helped. So change one feature. Then test again.
Worked example 1: Jamal tightens up. Jamal’s droopy cup phone worked 1 time out of 5. His pattern said tight strings work. So he makes one change: he and his partner step back until the string is tight. Now it works 5 times out of 5. These are sample results.
Worked example 2: Rosa adds foil. Rosa’s light box made a dim spot. Her partner missed some flashes. Rosa lines the inside of the box with foil. Now the spot on the wall is bright. Her partner counts every flash. These are sample results.
Check the Signal Card. After your change, check each rule. Reach far? Easy to notice? Light or sound? Pattern? Kit only? Safe? If version 2 has all of them, it is ready for the final test.
Good and not so good. Every design has good points and weak spots. Engineers say both.
Listen. Point to your answer.
Make and check version 2.
Make one change to your best device. Draw a picture of the change on your Design Page.
Check your version 2 against the Signal Card. Put a check by each rule it meets. Tell a partner one good point and one weak spot.
The steam whistle at the lake was loud. But it had a weak spot. It needed hot steam to blow. From a cold start, getting the steam ready could take up to 45 minutes.
One spring day in 1902, the boilers were not ready yet, and a ship ran onto the reef. Later, a new fog signal used air pushed by an engine. It got going much faster.
Think about it: The whistle was loud, but slow to start. Why does a signal need to work right away?
Version 2 is ready! Next time is the final signal test.
Exit ticket: tell what light or sound idea helped you make version 2 better.
Pacing (40 min): warm-up 3, reading 7, case study 5, mini lecture 7, version 2 build and check 15, closure 3.
Materials: devices and charts, extra foil, string, tape, paper clips, the Signal Card checklist (one per team).
Case study note: keep the 1902 story calm. The page reports the ship ran aground; it does not report injuries. Focus on the design lesson: a signal must be ready when it is needed.
Misconceptions: changing everything is best; version 2 must be brand new (it is the same design, made better).
Supports: offer three picture choices of changes (add foil, tighten string, add a flap). Stretch: teams predict how many boxes version 2 will get.
Answer guide: a good change follows the team’s pattern. Good point / weak spot pairs: “bright, but only works if my partner is looking”; “works when it is tight, but the string is long to carry.”
National Park Service, Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore: Au Sable Light Station · U.S. government work, public domain
A lighthouse stood near a rocky reef in a big lake. A reef is a line of rocks under the water. Ships could crash into it.
The light helped on clear nights. But fog could roll in fast, in just minutes. Fog hid the light. So the keepers needed a sound signal, too.
At first, the keepers used a foghorn they cranked by hand. It was hard work. And it was not very loud.
So in 1897, workers made it better. They put big steam whistles on the roof. On a calm day, people could hear them up to 25 miles away!
The whistle had a pattern. It blew for 3 seconds. Then it blew again every 17 seconds. Sailors knew that pattern meant this place.
Later, people made the signal better again. The new kind got going much faster.
Version 1. Version 2. Version 3. Engineers keep making things better.
Source: National Park Service, Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore: Au Sable Light Station (nps.gov)