The Message-Sending Signal Device
How can we design a device that uses light or sound to send a message to someone far across the room?
The mystery: When you tap a drum with rice on top, the rice jumps and you hear a boom. Is the sound connected to the jumping?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
ask questions about the loud gym and tell the problem a new tool could solve.
Phase 1: Spark
A test. Half the class talks and claps. One friend stands far away. Your teacher whispers, “Line up.” Can the friend hear it?
Will the far friend hear the whisper?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Good questions help. Engineers ask questions before they build. Why is it hard? Who needs help? What should happen?
Coach’s gym. The gym is big. Many children play. Balls bounce. Shoes squeak. It is noisy. Helpers are at the far wall.
Worked example 1: a good question. Mia asked, “How far away are the helpers?” That question helps. A far sound is harder to hear.
Worked example 2: telling the problem. Sam said, “The helpers cannot hear Coach because the gym is loud and they are far away. Coach needs a new tool to send his message.” Sam told the problem. He told why it is hard.
Light or sound? A message can be a sound, like a beep. A message can be a light, like a flash. The lighthouse used both!
What we will learn. First we will learn about sound. Then we will learn about light. Then we can choose.
Your teacher reads each card. Point, or show thumbs up or down.
Show the problem.
Draw the gym. Draw Coach on one side. Draw the helpers far away. Draw lines for the noise in the middle. Tell your teacher what the problem is.
We named our problem. Next time, we start our investigations. We will feel sounds with our hands.
Exit ticket: finish this sentence out loud. “The helpers cannot hear Coach because ___.”
Pacing (40 min): whisper test 6, reading 7, mini lecture 10, guided practice 10, drawing 5, exit ticket 2.
Setup: sort the Wonder Board into “sound,” “light” and “Coach’s problem” columns with picture headers.
Likely misconceptions: “Coach just needs to yell louder.” Ask: is that good for his voice? Does it work every time?
Supports: provide the sentence frame on a strip. Stretch: ask what would make a signal easy to notice.
Answer guide: “…because the gym is loud” and/or “…because they are far away.” Strong answers name both.
National Park Service, Lighthouse History at Point Reyes · U.S. government work, public domain
The National Park Service tells about a real lighthouse. It stands on a point of land by the sea.
This place is very windy. It is often foggy. Fog is like a cloud near the ground. The land sticks far out into the water.
Ships sailed past. Sailors could not always see the land. Ships could crash. People wanted to change that. They wanted sailors to stay safe.
So people built a lighthouse. It was first lit in 1870. Its bright light sent a message far across the water. The message said, “Watch out! Land is here!”
But some days the fog was too thick. Sailors could not see the light. So the lighthouse also had a loud fog signal. It made a sound that sailors could hear.
The lighthouse used light and sound to send a message far away. Coach Rivera needs a message to go far, too.
Source: National Park Service, Lighthouse History at Point Reyes (nps.gov)