use our dark box evidence to explain why we need light to see.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Think. A cat is sitting in a closet. The door is shut. There is no light at all.
If you open the door a crack in a dark house, can you see the cat?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Our evidence. In the dark box, we saw nothing. With the flap open, we saw the toy. A tea light and a glow stick could be seen in the dark.
Our explanation. We see things when light comes to our eyes. Light can come from the thing itself, like a glow stick. Or light can shine on the thing and come to our eyes, like the toy when the flap was open.
Worked example 1. Lily said, “I think we need light to see because the toy was in the dark box but I could not see it until light came in.”
Worked example 2. Omar said, “I think some things can be seen in the dark because I saw the glow stick in the dark box. It makes its own light.”
Thinking about Coach. A light signal can be seen in a dim gym because it gives off its own light. That could help Coach Rivera!
Use your words. Today you will explain with “I think ___ because I saw ___.”
Point to the best answer. Then say it with the sentence frame.
Show your explanation.
Fold a paper in half. On one side, draw the dark box with nothing to see. On the other side, draw the box with light and the toy. Draw an arrow of light going to an eye. Tell your teacher your “I think, because” sentence.
We need light to see. Some things give off their own light, so we can see them in the dark. Next time, we explain what materials do to light.
Exit ticket: tell a partner why you cannot read a book in a closet with no light.
Pacing (40 min): warm-up 4, reading 7, mini lecture 8, guided practice 9, fold-paper model 10, exit 2.
Likely misconceptions: “cats can see in total darkness” and “my eyes get used to the dark.” Animals and people can see in very dim light, but not in no light at all. Glowing animal eyes are shining only from light that hits them.
Supports: pre-drawn box outlines. Stretch: explain how the toy can be seen when light shines on it (light bounces to our eyes).
Answer guide: “I think we need light to see because the toy was there but we could not see it in the dark box.” This checks 1-PS4-2:1b, 2b and 3a.
National Eye Institute (NIH), How the Eyes Work · NEI (NIH): public domain unless otherwise noted, per NEI Copyright Policy; credit: Courtesy National Eye Institute, National Institutes of Health (NEI/NIH)
Let’s follow light on a trip into your eye.
Step 1. Light reaches the clear front of your eye. This clear part helps the light get ready.
Step 2. Light goes through your pupil. Your iris, the colored part, makes the pupil big or small. Big lets in more light. Small lets in less.
Step 3. The lens inside your eye helps make the picture sharp. It sends the light to the back of your eye.
Step 4. Cells at the back catch the light. They turn it into messages.
Step 5. A nerve takes the messages to your brain. Your brain makes a picture. Now you see!
Tears help too. They keep your eyes working well.
Look at Step 1. What if no light comes? Then the trip cannot start. That is why we need light to see.
Source: National Eye Institute (NIH), How the Eyes Work (nei.nih.gov)