use what we learned about light and sound to describe what Coach Rivera’s signal device should be like.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Remember Coach Rivera. The gym is loud. The helpers are far away. Coach needs a signal.
Which signal could the helpers notice in a LOUD gym?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Engineers make a list. Before building, engineers list what a tool must do. We call these needs for the design.
What we know about sound. Shaking makes sound. Sound travels through air and a tight string. A sound must be strong to go far.
What we know about light. We need light to see. A light giver can be seen in the dark. Clear covers let light out. Mirrors can bounce light a new way.
Worked example 1: a light idea. Jada said, “Our device should flash a light. A flashlight gives off its own light, so helpers can see it in the gym. The cover must be clear so the light gets out.”
Worked example 2: a sound idea. Leo said, “Our device should make a beep pattern, like beep-beep-beep. Shaking makes sound. A pattern is easy to notice in a noisy gym.”
Our class list. Coach’s signal should: 1. reach far across the room; 2. be easy to notice; 3. use light or sound; 4. have a pattern that means “line up.”
Point to the best answer. Talk with a partner first.
Draw an idea.
Draw a first idea for Coach's signal device. Circle light or sound. Tell your teacher one thing you learned that helps your idea work.
We have a list of what Coach’s signal needs. Next time, we review all our light and sound ideas before we start building.
Exit ticket: tell a partner. Would you pick light or sound for Coach? Why?
Pacing (40 min): warm-up 4, reading 7, mini lecture 9, guided practice 9, drawing 9, exit 2.
Setup: post the class needs list with icons (arrow for far, eye/ear for notice, bulb/bell for light or sound, dots for pattern). Part 2 uses this list to test designs.
Likely misconceptions: “louder is always better” (very loud sounds can hurt ears; a pattern helps more); “any light works” (it must be bright enough and not covered).
Supports: offer starter pictures of a flashlight, bell and buzzer. Stretch: add a way for the helpers to signal back.
Answer guide: “Light, because the helpers can see a flash even when it is noisy” or “Sound, because shaking makes a beep that travels far.” This checks K-2-ETS1-1:4a.
National Park Service, Lighthouse History at Point Reyes · U.S. government work, public domain
The lighthouse by the foggy sea had a job. Send a message to ships far away. What made it work?
Bright light. Glass pieces made the light into strong beams. Sailors could see them far out at sea.
A pattern. The light flashed once every five seconds. Sailors knew the pattern. It told them which lighthouse they saw.
Sound for fog. On foggy days, the light was hard to see. So a fog signal made a sound in a pattern too.
People to help. Keepers took care of it. They lit the lamp when it got dark. All night, they wound the machine that turned the light. In the day, they cleaned the glass and fixed things.
So the signal was bright, had a pattern, used sound when light was not enough, and got good care. Coach’s signal can use these ideas!
Source: National Park Service, Lighthouse History at Point Reyes (nps.gov)