tell the problem our signal device must solve, and name our criteria and constraints.
Phase 4: Build
Let’s think. Your friend is far away, across the room. The room is noisy. You want to say “Line up!” You cannot walk over. What could you do?
Which one could send a message across the room?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Signal makers, welcome to Build! You found out so much about sound and light. Sound comes from things that vibrate. We see things when there is light. Some things let light through. Some things block it. Now you will use those ideas.
Our problem. Remember Coach Rivera? The gym is big and loud. The helpers stand at the far wall. They cannot hear Coach say “time to line up.” Our driving question: How can we design a device that uses light or sound to send a message to someone far across the room?
A signal is a message. It can be a flash of light. It can be a sound, like a tap or a ring. Our class has a code. One signal means yes. Two signals mean no. Three signals mean line up.
Worked example 1: Mia in the gym. Mia’s brother is across the gym. It is very noisy. Mia calls his name. He does not hear her. Mia says, “The problem is, he is too far, and it is too loud.” She has found the problem.
Worked example 2: Omar and the flashlight. Omar’s partner sits far away. Omar shines a flashlight on the wall near her. Flash, flash. Two flashes! His partner holds up the “no” card. The message worked. Omar never points the light at her eyes.
Our Signal Card. Engineers write down what a design must do. These are the criteria. They come from the list we made for Coach: reach far, easy to notice, light or sound, and a pattern. Engineers also write down the limits. These are the constraints. Here are ours.
| Our Signal Card | What it means |
|---|---|
| Criterion: Reach Far | Helpers across the room can see it or hear it. |
| Criterion: Easy to Notice | Helpers notice it, even in a noisy room. |
| Criterion: Light or Sound | The device uses light or sound to send the message. |
| Criterion: Pattern | A pattern means a message. Our class code: 1 signal = yes. 2 signals = no. 3 signals = line up. |
| Constraint: Kit Only | We use only the class kit. |
| Constraint: Safe | Never shine a light in eyes. No sounds that hurt ears. |
| Constraint: Time | We build in the class time we have. |
Listen to each question. Point to your answer.
Draw and tell.
Draw two people far apart. Draw how one person could send a message to the other. Tell a partner about your picture.
Look at the Signal Card. Circle the rule you think will be the hardest. Tell why.
Great problem-finding, signal makers! Next time, we will learn about light signals and sound signals people have used.
Exit ticket: tell a friend one way it helps people to send a message far away.
How confident are you that you can I can name one thing our device must do.
Pacing (40 min): warm-up 5, mini lecture and Signal Card 10, reading 7, guided practice 10, drawing and closure 8.
Materials: Signal Card poster, yes / no / line-up response cards (one set per student), a flashlight for a quick demo, crayons.
Criteria wording: the four criteria match the needs list from 1.13 (reach far, easy to notice, light or sound, pattern). If your class wrote its own list, keep your class’s words and update the Signal Card.
Misconceptions: louder is always better (our Safe constraint says no hurting-loud sounds); a signal must use words (a pattern of flashes or taps can carry a message).
Supports: read every question aloud and show picture icons for light and sound. Stretch: ask a student to invent a fourth code signal.
Answer guide: drawings show two people apart and a light or sound going between them. Strong “why it helps” answers: to get help, to stay safe, to find each other, to talk when it is noisy.
National Park Service, Junior Ranger: My Favorite Tree · U.S. government work, public domain
Park rangers help kids stay safe outside. They have a tip for hikers. Pack a whistle!
A whistle is very loud. People far away can hear it. So rangers say: use it only in an emergency. An emergency is a time when you really need help.
What if you get lost from your group? First, stop walking. Call out the names of the people in your group. Stay by a tree, so your group can find you.
No answer? Then use your whistle. Give three quick tweets. Then wait. Count to 30. Then do it again. The three tweets are a message. They say, “I need help. Come find me.”
Think about it. A whistle uses sound. It sends a message far away. The message is short and clear. Our signal device will do the same kind of job. It will use light or sound to send a message across our room.
Source: National Park Service, Junior Ranger: My Favorite Tree (nps.gov)