
solve square root and cube root equations, identify extraneous solutions introduced by squaring, and confirm solutions with graphs.
Instruction
To solve an equation with a radical, isolate the radical and then undo it with the matching power. The one danger is that squaring is not reversible, so it can create false solutions.
Example 1. Solve √(x + 7) = x − 5.
- The radical is already isolated. Square both sides: x + 7 = (x − 5)2 = x2 − 10x + 25.
- Collect terms: x2 − 11x + 18 = 0, so (x − 9)(x − 2) = 0 and x = 9 or x = 2.
- Check in the original. x = 9: √16 = 4 and 9 − 5 = 4. True. x = 2: √9 = 3 but 2 − 5 = −3. False.
The only solution is x = 9; 2 is extraneous.
Why squaring creates extra solutions. If a = b, then a2 = b2. But the reverse fails: a2 = b2 also holds when a = −b. The squared equation x + 7 = (x − 5)2 is the squared form of both √(x + 7) = x − 5 and √(x + 7) = −(x − 5). The value 2 solves the second equation, not ours. The principal square root is never negative, so any candidate that makes the other side negative must be rejected.
Seeing it on a graph (A2.REI.B.3). Graph y = √(x + 7) and y = x − 5. They meet once, at (9, 4). At x = 2 the line is at −3 while the root curve is at +3: the graph of y = −√(x + 7), the lower half of the sideways parabola, is where the extraneous root lives.
Example 2: cube roots. Solve 3√(2x − 1) = 3. Cube both sides: 2x − 1 = 27, so x = 14. Cubing is reversible, since every real number has exactly one real cube root, so cube root equations do not produce extraneous solutions this way. Checking is still good practice: 3√27 = 3.
Example 3: isolate first. Solve √x + 2 = x. Subtract 2 first: √x = x − 2. Squaring before isolating would give (√x + 2)2 = x + 4√x + 4, which still contains a radical. Now square: x = x2 − 4x + 4, so x2 − 5x + 4 = 0 and x = 4 or x = 1. Check: √4 + 2 = 4, true; √1 + 2 = 3 ≠ 1, false. The solution is 4.
Rational exponents. Equations such as x3/2 = 27 are radical equations in disguise. Raise both sides to the 2/3 power: x = 272/3 = 9. Check: 93/2 = 33 = 27.
Precision (MP.6). Write the check as a separate line for every candidate, and write “extraneous” next to the ones that fail. In a context (A2.REI.A.1), also check that the answer makes sense: if T = 2π√(L/9.8) and you need a 3-second pendulum, L = 9.8(3/(2π))2 ≈ 2.23 m, which is positive and plausible.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
What is the solution set of √(2x + 3) = x?
Cubing both sides of a cube root equation can introduce extraneous solutions in the same way squaring can.
To solve x3/2 = 27, raise both sides to the power, giving x = .
Solve √(x + 7) = x − 5 algebraically, then graph both sides on the same axes. Mark the solution and explain, with reference to the graph, where the extraneous candidate x = 2 comes from.
How confident are you that you can solve radical equations and explain and reject extraneous solutions?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Solve √(x + 2) = x.
Check your answer
Answer: x = 2 (x = −1 is extraneous)x2 − x − 2 = 0; at −1, √1 = 1 ≠ −1. - Solve √(3x + 1) = x − 3.
Check your answer
Answer: x = 8 (x = 1 is extraneous)x2 − 9x + 8 = 0; at 1, √4 = 2 ≠ −2. - Solve 3√(x − 5) = −2.
Check your answer
Answer: x = −3Cube: x − 5 = −8. - Solve √(2x − 1) + 2 = 5.
Check your answer
Answer: x = 5Isolate: √(2x − 1) = 3. - Solve √(x + 5) = √(2x − 1).
Check your answer
Answer: x = 6Check: √11 = √11. - Solve x3/2 = 64.
Check your answer
Answer: x = 16Raise to the 2/3 power. - Solve 2√x = x − 3.
Check your answer
Answer: x = 9 (x = 1 is extraneous)Square: 4x = x2 − 6x + 9; at 1, 2 ≠ −2.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- What pendulum length gives a 2.5-second period, using T = 2π√(L/9.8)?
Check your answer
Answer: About 1.551 m - Crash investigators estimate speed from skid length with v = √(30fd) (mph, feet). With f = 0.7, how long a skid corresponds to 45 mph?
Check your answer
Answer: About 96.4 ftSquare: d = v2/(30f). - With Kepler’s law T = a3/2 (years, AU), how far from the Sun is an asteroid with a 5-year period?
Check your answer
Answer: About 2.924 AUa = 52/3.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- Solve √x + √(x − 5) = 5.
Check your answer
Answer: x = 9Isolate one root: √(x − 5) = 5 − √x. Square: x − 5 = 25 − 10√x + x, so √x = 3. Check: 3 + 2 = 5.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Solve: (x + 4) / (x − 1) = 5 / (x − 1)
Check your answer
Answer: No solution (x = 1 is extraneous)Multiplying by x − 1 gives x + 4 = 5, so x = 1; but that makes the denominator zero. - Multiply: (−x)(−2x2 + 5x − 5)
Check your answer
Answer: 2x3 − 5x2 + 5x
Twelve Radical Equations, With Every Candidate Checked in Writing
SLS original check file for Algebra 2 A Lesson 4.2; every candidate is substituted into the original equation and the result printed · SLS original
Why this reading. The lesson’s instruction is to write the check as a separate line for every candidate and to write “extraneous” beside the ones that fail. That is a habit, and a habit needs repetitions on problems whose answers you can confirm. Twelve are below, with the substitution shown rather than described. Work each one before you read its row.
The check file
| Equation | After undoing the radical | Candidates | Left side at each | Right side at each | Solution set |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| √(x + 7) = x − 5 | x2 − 11x + 18 = 0 | 9, 2 | 4; 3 | 4; −3 | {9}, 2 extraneous |
| √(2x + 3) = x | x2 − 2x − 3 = 0 | 3, −1 | 3; 1 | 3; −1 | {3}, −1 extraneous |
| √x + 2 = x | x2 − 5x + 4 = 0 | 4, 1 | 4; 3 | 4; 1 | {4}, 1 extraneous |
| √(x + 5) = x − 1 | x2 − 3x − 4 = 0 | 4, −1 | 3; 2 | 3; −2 | {4}, −1 extraneous |
| √(3x + 1) = x − 3 | x2 − 9x + 8 = 0 | 8, 1 | 5; 2 | 5; −2 | {8}, 1 extraneous |
| √x = −3 | x = 9 | 9 | 3 | −3 | { }, 9 extraneous |
| √(x − 1) = √(2x − 7) | x = 6 | 6 | √5 | √5 | {6} |
| √(x + 4) + √(x − 1) = 5 | √(x − 1) = 2 | 5 | 3 + 2 = 5 | 5 | {5} |
| ∛(2x − 1) = 3 | 2x − 1 = 27 | 14 | 3 | 3 | {14} |
| ∛(x2 − 8) = 2 | x2 = 16 | 4, −4 | 2; 2 | 2; 2 | {−4, 4} |
| x3/2 = 27 | x = 272/3 | 9 | 27 | 27 | {9} |
| (x − 1)2/3 = 4 | x − 1 = ±8 | 9, −7 | 4; 4 | 4; 4 | {−7, 9} |
Read the pattern in the failures
Rows 1 to 6 all lose a candidate, and in every one of them the rejected value is the one that makes the right-hand side negative while the left side, a principal square root, is nonnegative. That is not a coincidence, it is the entire mechanism. Squaring turns √A = B into A = B2, and A = B2 is equally the squared form of √A = −B. The squared equation cannot tell the two apart, so it hands you the solutions of both and leaves the sorting to you.
Row 6 is the extreme case, kept short on purpose. √x = −3 has no solution before you do any work at all, because a principal square root is never negative. Squaring dutifully produces x = 9, and a student who does not check reports 9. This is the shortest possible demonstration that the check is part of the method and not a formality at the end of it.
Rows 9 to 12 lose nothing, and for two different reasons. Rows 9 and 10 use cube roots, and cubing is reversible on the real numbers: a3 = b3 forces a = b, with no second case to worry about. Notice that row 10 has two solutions anyway — because x2 = 16 has two — and both survive the check. “Two candidates” and “one is extraneous” are unrelated facts, and conflating them is a real error.
Row 12 is the subtle one and repays a minute. (x − 1)2/3 = 4 means the cube root of x − 1, squared. Squaring at the end destroys the sign, so both x − 1 = 8 and x − 1 = −8 work: ∛8 = 2 and 22 = 4, while ∛(−8) = −2 and (−2)2 = 4. Both check. An even numerator in the exponent behaves like squaring; an odd numerator does not. Compare row 11, where x3/2 = 27 has the single solution 9, since a 3/2 power is defined only for x ≥ 0 to begin with.
Row 1 on a graph
Values of y = √(x + 7), y = x − 5 and y = −√(x + 7):
| x | −7 | −3 | 2 | 5 | 7 | 9 | 11 | 14 | 18 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| √(x + 7) | 0 | 2 | 3 | 3.464 | 3.742 | 4 | 4.243 | 4.583 | 5 |
| x − 5 | −12 | −8 | −3 | 0 | 2 | 4 | 6 | 9 | 13 |
| −√(x + 7) | 0 | −2 | −3 | −3.464 | −3.742 | −4 | −4.243 | −4.583 | −5 |
The line meets the upper curve once, at x = 9 where both are 4. It meets the lower curve at x = 2, where both are −3. That second meeting is where the extraneous candidate lives: it is a genuine intersection, just not of the two graphs in your equation. Together the two curves are the sideways parabola x = y2 − 7, which is what squaring the equation quietly substituted for the half you asked about.
One last habit
Row 8 has two radicals, and the first move is not to square — it is to isolate one of them. Squaring √(x + 4) + √(x − 1) = 5 directly gives (x + 4) + 2√((x + 4)(x − 1)) + (x − 1) = 25, which still has a radical, now with a product under it. Moving one root to the other side first leaves a single radical after the first squaring and none after arranging, and the whole problem collapses to √(x − 1) = 2. Isolate, then undo, then check — in that order, every time.