
present a justified derivation of the quadratic formula with an irrationality argument, and solve and defend a real design problem modeled by a quadratic equation or a linear-quadratic system.
Instruction
This portfolio closes the year with the two things mathematicians do: prove that a method works, and use it to make something.
Part A: the proof. Write the derivation of the quadratic formula from ax2 + bx + c = 0 in your own words. Number each step and give its justification: a property of equality, the definition of a square root, the perfect-square pattern. Say where the proof needs a ≠ 0 and why the ± appears. Then choose one quadratic equation with an irrational solution, solve it with the formula, and prove that the solution is irrational using the arguments from Lesson 4.3.
Part B: the design. Choose a design problem in a real space you know, or one of these starters, and model it with a quadratic equation or a linear-quadratic system.
- Mural frame (worked starter). A school mural is 20 feet by 12 feet. A painted border of uniform width w will surround it, and the budget allows paint for a total framed area of 384 square feet. The framed mural measures (20 + 2w) by (12 + 2w), so (20 + 2w)(12 + 2w) = 384. Expanding gives 4w2 + 64w + 240 = 384, so 4w2 + 64w − 144 = 0, and dividing by 4 gives w2 + 16w − 36 = 0. This factors as (w + 18)(w − 2) = 0, so w = 2 or w = −18. A width cannot be negative: the border is 2 feet wide. Check: 24 × 16 = 384.
- Garden path. A path of uniform width around or through a rectangular bed, with a fixed total area of paving stones.
- Fountain and ramp. A water jet that must land on a sloped surface at a chosen point, as in Lesson 4.4.
What Part B must include. A labeled diagram with every dimension and unit. The equation or system, with a sentence explaining where each part comes from. A solution by two different methods, for example factoring and the quadratic formula, or completing the square and a graph. Every solution interpreted, with non-viable ones rejected for a stated reason. And one “what if”: how the answer changes if one constraint changes, such as a larger paint budget.
Precision. Keep exact answers through the calculation and round only at the end, to a precision a builder could use: a quarter inch or a centimeter, not six decimal places.
The presentation. Four to five minutes, live or recorded. Present one step of your derivation in detail, chosen by your reviewer (or, if you present alone, the step you found hardest), then present your design with its diagram and solution. Answer one question on each part.
What strong portfolios do. They make every step checkable. A reader should be able to follow the proof without asking “why?” and rebuild the design from the diagram and the numbers alone.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
A 10 ft by 6 ft poster gets a border of uniform width w, and the framed area is 96 ft². Which equation models this?
For the mural, (20 + 2w)(12 + 2w) = 384 simplifies to w² + 16w − 36 = 0, whose viable solution is w = feet.
How confident are you that you can derive the quadratic formula with justification and use quadratic equations to solve and defend a design?
Unit 4 checkpoint
Do this before you start the task. It covers the whole unit and tells you what to review first.
Solve x² − 5x − 14 = 0.
(x − 3)² = 25 has only the solution x = 8.
x² + 6x + = (x + 3)².
Vertex form of x² − 8x + 10?
2x² + 12x + 5 = 2(x + 3)² − .
The discriminant of x² + 5x + 7 is −3. The equation has…
For 2x² − 3x − 4 = 0, the discriminant is .
x² + 2x + 5 = 0 has solutions…
The sum of a rational number and an irrational number is irrational.
Solve y = x² and y = 2x + 3.
The mural border (w + 18)(w − 2) = 0 is feet wide.
Dividing x² = 5x by x finds every solution.
Submit: Proof and Design Portfolio (700-1,000 words with derivation, diagram and solutions) and presentation
Task: Part A: derive the quadratic formula with every step justified, and prove that one irrational solution is irrational. Part B: model a real design problem with a quadratic equation or linear-quadratic system, solve it by two methods, interpret and check every solution, and explore one change to the constraints.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Plan. Outline of the derivation’s steps and justifications; design choice with a sketched diagram and the constraint that produces the equation.
- Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed draft. A partner marks any unjustified step in the proof and re-solves your design equation by a different method; submit a revision note.
- Stage 3 — Revised final. Complete derivation, irrationality argument, labeled design diagram, two solution methods, interpretations and a what-if, in 700-1,000 words.
- Stage 4 — Presentation and defense. Four to five minutes, live or recorded, presenting a derivation step chosen by your reviewer and the design, with one question on each.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Derivation (A1.REI.A.2a, A1.REI.A.2b, A1.REI.A.1) | Every step of the derivation correct and justified; roles of a ≠ 0 and ± explained. |
| Irrationality (8.NS.A.1a) | Correct argument that a rational plus a nonzero rational multiple of an irrational is irrational. |
| Design model (A1.CED.A.1, A1.REI.B.4) | Equation or system correctly built from a labeled diagram of a real design. |
| Solving (A1.REI.A.2c, A1.SSE.A.3a) | Solved correctly by two different methods that agree. |
| Interpretation (A1.IF.C.8 / A1.SSE.A.3a / A1.SSE.A.3b, MP.4) | Every solution interpreted; non-viable solutions rejected with reasons; what-if explored with precision suited to the design. |
| Presentation (MP.3) | Derivation step and design explained clearly; questions answered with reasoning. |
Portfolio Materials: Three Design Briefs With Measurements, a Price Sheet, and Six Equations With Irrational Solutions
Constructed teaching data written for this course; all dimensions, budgets and prices are illustrative · SLS original (constructed teaching data, labeled illustrative)
Why this reading. Part B of the portfolio asks for “a labeled diagram with every dimension and unit” and a constraint that produces an equation. The lesson names three starters but gives measurements for only one of them, and Part A asks you to prove a solution irrational without saying which equations have one. This reading supplies both: three briefs with full measurements and a price sheet, and six equations whose solutions are irrational. You may still design something in a real space you know; these exist so that nobody is stuck waiting for a tape measure.
Brief 1 (illustrative). The mural border — worked, as a model
A school mural is 20 ft by 12 ft. A painted border of uniform width w will surround it, and the budget allows paint for a total framed area of 384 ft².
The framed rectangle is (20 + 2w) by (12 + 2w), so (20 + 2w)(12 + 2w) = 384. Expanding: 240 + 40w + 24w + 4w² = 384, so 4w² + 64w − 144 = 0, and dividing by 4 gives w² + 16w − 36 = 0. That factors as (w + 18)(w − 2) = 0, so w = −18 or w = 2 ft. Check: 24 × 16 = 384. Solve it a second way, by the quadratic formula, and confirm the same pair: the discriminant is 256 + 144 = 400, and √400 = 20, so w = (−16 ± 20) ÷ 2.
Brief 2 (illustrative). The garden path
A rectangular vegetable bed measures 9 m by 6 m. A path of uniform width w is to be laid around it, and the club has bought enough paving stones to cover exactly 40 m² of path.
Build the equation from the difference of two rectangles: (9 + 2w)(6 + 2w) − 54 = 40. State the domain the site allows — the bed sits in a yard 15 m by 12 m, so the path cannot exceed 3 m on either side. Solve, reject what must be rejected, and round to a precision a person laying stones could use.
Then the what-if: the club is given enough stones for 60 m² instead. Does the path still fit the yard?
Brief 3 (illustrative). The fountain that must land on the steps
A courtyard fountain’s jet follows y = −0.4x² + vx, in meters from the nozzle, where v is the launch slope set by the pump. A flight of steps runs along y = 0.3x and ends at x = 6 m. The water must land on the steps, not past their end.
Find the landing point as a function of v, then find the largest v the pump may be set to. This brief is the one whose answer is not a number but an inequality, and the portfolio’s what-if is built in.
Price sheet (illustrative), for the cost paragraph
| Material | Unit | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Exterior mural paint | per gallon, covers 350 ft² | $54.00 |
| Concrete paving stone, 30 cm square | each, covers 0.09 m² | $3.25 |
| Landscape edging | per linear meter | $6.80 |
| Decomposed granite base | per m² at 5 cm depth | $11.50 |
Use the sheet to price your design, and to check your answer for sense: if your border comes out at 40 ft wide, the paint bill will say so before your reviewer does. Round money to the cent and dimensions to a quarter inch or a centimeter, as the lesson requires, and round only at the end.
Six equations with irrational solutions, for Part A
| 2x² − 3x − 4 = 0 | x² − 6x + 2 = 0 | x² + 4x − 1 = 0 |
| 3x² + 2x − 2 = 0 | x² − 2x − 7 = 0 | 5x² − 4x − 1 = 0 |
Five of the six have irrational solutions. One does not, and finding it is the first task: compute each discriminant and ask whether it is a perfect square. Then choose one of the five, solve it with the formula, and prove the solution irrational by the two claims in Lesson 4.3 — that a nonzero rational times an irrational is irrational, and that a rational plus an irrational is irrational — each by contradiction, each written out. Say explicitly where your argument uses the fact that the number under the root is not a perfect square, because that is the hypothesis the whole proof rests on.