
revise a shadow clock using feedback, then test both designs in more than one situation and compare the results.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Diego’s clock read 11:00 at exactly 11:00 on Monday. Does that prove his clock is accurate? What else should he check?
A shadow clock was calibrated two weeks ago. Will its marks still match the clock today?
Junior engineers, one good reading is not enough. A design has to work in different situations. For a shadow clock, situations can mean different times of day, different days, or a light wind. We test in each one and write down the results.
Make a fair test. Change one thing at a time. Keep the clock in the same spot, facing the same way. Read the shadow at the same moment you read the real clock. Find the error: how many minutes the shadow clock is off.
Worked example 1: finding the error. At 10:00 by the school clock, Mei’s shadow points one-third of the way from the 10 mark to the 11 mark. One-third of an hour is 20 minutes. So her clock reads 10:20, and the error is 20 minutes fast. These are sample numbers.
Worked example 2: comparing designs. Jamal’s team tests both clocks on three days, one week apart. Sample errors: straight stick 5, 10 and 15 minutes; tilted pointer 5, 5 and 5 minutes. The straight stick’s error grows each week. The tilted pointer stays steady. The data helps them choose.
Make your one revision first. Then test both clocks and fill in the table.
| Situation | Real clock time | Straight stick reads | Error (min) | Tilted pointer reads | Error (min) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Morning, calm | |||||
| Midday, calm | |||||
| Fan on low (wind) |
Plan the next test like an engineer.
Name one more situation that families at Night Sky Night might face, such as late afternoon or a breezy evening. Describe how you would test your clock in that situation.
Your clocks have been revised and tested. Next class is the mid-build checkpoint, so review your shadow and gravity ideas.
Exit ticket: right now, which of your two designs is ahead? Give one piece of data.
Materials: prototypes, a small fan (wind test), rulers, data tables, a big analog clock face for teaching fractions of an hour.
Setup: Run the wind test indoors with a flashlight if needed. Keep calibration and testing on the same side of the March daylight saving switch, or the clocks will look an hour off.
Listen for: “it worked once, so it works.” Ask: “Would it work next week? In wind?” Also check that students read the real clock and the shadow at the same moment.
Support / stretch: Provide a clock face divided into quarters for reading in-between positions. Stretch: ask students to find the average error of each design.