revise our guide pages using feedback, and extend equal-area thinking to sixths and eighths of new shapes.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. One school garden program grew more food in its second year.
The garden grew over 400 pounds of food one year and over 850 pounds the next. About how did it change?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Revision studio. Today you use your feedback to make your page correct, clear, kind and honest. Then you try an extension challenge.
Revision steps. (1) Reread your feedback notes. (2) Fix correctness first: equal parts, labels and number lines. (3) Make it clear: big labels and one idea per picture. (4) Make it kind: simple words for first graders. (5) Make it honest: mark sample data.
Worked example 1: Elena revises a card. Elena’s card showed a square split into 4 strips of different widths, each labeled 1/4. She redraws the square on grid paper, 4 squares by 4 squares, so 16 squares. 16 ÷ 4 = 4, so she makes 4 strips of 4 squares each. Now each strip is truly 1/4. She adds: “Check: 4 + 4 + 4 + 4 = 16.”
Worked example 2 (extension): Jordan’s eighths. Jordan has a bed with 2 rows of 4 squares. He wants 8 equal plots. Each gets 1 square, so each is 1/8. Then he joins plots in pairs: 2 squares is 2/8 of the bed, and it is also 1/4, because 4 pairs make the whole bed. So 2/8 = 1/4.
Extension idea. A hexagon pattern block can be covered by 6 triangles, 3 rhombuses or 2 trapezoids. One triangle is 1/6 of the hexagon, one rhombus is 1/3, and one trapezoid is 1/2. Different shapes, each an equal part of the whole.
Revise and extend. Prove each answer.
Finish your revision, then try the extension.
Make your revisions. Next to each change, write which criterion it fixes: correct, clear, kind or honest.
Extension: Trace a hexagon. Show it split into halves, thirds and sixths using pattern block shapes. Label one part of each and write one pair of equivalent fractions you see.
Good work gets better when we revise it.
Exit ticket: Show your page before and after one change. Why is the new version better?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 6 minutes, mini lecture 7, guided practice 10, revision and extension 14, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: revising only for neatness; thinking a triangle and a rhombus cannot be compared; thinking 2/8 cannot equal 1/4 because the numbers are different.
Supports: pattern blocks (hexagon, trapezoid, rhombus, triangle), grid paper, a revision checklist. Stretch: split a hexagon into 6 equal parts that are not triangles.
Answer guide: warm-up about doubled; 4 squares; 1/6; 3; true; 1/2; greater. Independent extension: hexagon = 2 trapezoids (1/2 each), 3 rhombuses (1/3 each), 6 triangles (1/6 each); pairs such as 3/6 = 1/2 and 2/6 = 1/3.
U.S. Department of Agriculture, Food and Nutrition Service, School Gardens fact sheet · U.S. government work, public domain
The USDA school gardens fact sheet tells about Magdalena Municipal Schools in New Mexico. Students there grow food for their own salad bar.
The students grew mixed lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, beans, squash and more. The fact sheet says the garden even helped the schools spend less on food.
Who takes care of the garden? Students in the middle school and high school gardening clubs do. So do pre-K through eighth grade summer school students. A local farmer helps lead them.
The garden got better with practice. The fact sheet says it doubled its food in just 2 years. It grew over 400 pounds of food one year and over 850 pounds the next year.
Cooking classes used the garden food to make dishes such as salsa, soups and stews. They served some at taste tests and even to the school board.
The garden did not start out perfect. The students kept working and made it better. Revising our guide works the same way.
Source: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Food and Nutrition Service, School Gardens fact sheet (fns.usda.gov)