compare two fractions with the same denominator using >, = or < and explain how I know with a model.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Jada ate 3/8 of a pizza. Luis ate 5/8 of the same size pizza.
Who ate more pizza?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Comparing fractions with the same denominator. When two fractions have the same denominator, the parts are the same size, as long as the wholes are the same. So we compare the numerators: more parts means more.
Symbols. > means is greater than. < means is less than. = means is equal to. The open side of > or < faces the greater amount.
Worked example 1: Jada and Luis. Jada ate 3/8 of a pizza and Luis ate 5/8 of the same size pizza. Both are eighths, so the slices are the same size. 3 slices is less than 5 slices. So 3/8 < 5/8. On a number line of eighths, 3/8 is to the left of 5/8.
Worked example 2: Aisha’s garden beds. Aisha planted 3/4 of one bed with lettuce. Her brother planted 1/4 of a same-size bed. Both are fourths. 3 > 1, so 3/4 > 1/4. She also checks 2/6 and 2/6: same parts, same number, so 2/6 = 2/6.
The cafeteria pans. One pan has 3/8 left. The other has 6/8 left. 6 > 3, so 6/8 > 3/8. The second pan has more left.
Watch out: the same whole. If one pizza is small and one is big, 3/8 of the big pizza could be more than 5/8 of the small one. Our guide always says same-size pizzas or beds.
Draw a model for each comparison, then use a symbol.
Make a Who Has More? card.
Write a sample story for first graders: two friends share same-size pizzas cut into eighths. Draw how much each friend eats. Write the comparison with >, = or < and a sentence that explains it.
Put 1/6, 5/6 and 3/6 on a number line of sixths. Then write them in order from least to greatest. Explain how the number line shows the order.
Same-size parts make comparing a counting job.
Exit ticket: Compare 2/4 and 3/4 of the same garden bed. Write the symbol and draw a picture that proves it.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 8, guided practice 15, independent 7, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: reversing the symbols; comparing fractions of different-size wholes; thinking the denominator decides which is bigger when denominators are the same.
Supports: an alligator or arrow reminder for > and <, fraction strips, sentence frame: “___ is greater than ___ because the parts are the same size and ___ parts is more than ___ parts.” Stretch: write a comparison that uses = with two different-looking fractions (such as 3/6 = 4/8).
Answer guide: warm-up Luis; >; less; true; 3/4; 6/8 > 3/8; equal. Nate is not right: with different-size wholes you cannot compare by numerators alone, and 3/8 of a big pizza could be more than 5/8 of a small one. Independent: 1/6 < 3/6 < 5/6; points farther right are greater. Exit ticket: 2/4 < 3/4. The cafeteria pans in the reading are an illustrative example, not from the BLS page.