compare two fractions with the same denominator using >, = or <, and explain why comparing the numerators works.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Two same-size pans of lasagna are each cut into 4 equal servings. One family eats 2 servings. Another family eats 3 servings. Which family ate more? Draw it.
Is 3/4 of a pan more or less than 2/4 of the same size pan?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Naming the method. When two fractions have the same denominator and the same whole, their pieces are the same size. So we only need to compare how many pieces: compare the numerators. The fraction with more pieces is greater.
The symbols. > means “is greater than.” < means “is less than.” = means “is equal to.” The open side of > or < faces the greater number.
Worked example 1: two pans. Ava’s family eats 2/4 of a sample pan. Ravi’s family eats 3/4 of a pan the same size. Step 1: same whole? Yes. Step 2: same denominator? Yes, fourths. Step 3: compare the numerators: 2 < 3. Step 4: so 2/4 < 3/4. Ravi’s family ate more. Check with the FDA idea: 3 servings is more than 2 servings of the same food.
Worked example 2: a number line. Sam’s sample garden bed has 8 equal rows. Tomatoes fill 5/8 and peppers fill 3/8. Step 1: draw a 0 to 1 line in eighths. Step 2: mark 3/8 and 5/8. Step 3: 5/8 is farther to the right, so it is greater. Step 4: 5/8 > 3/8. Tomatoes fill more of the bed.
Equal shares. If the numerators match too, like 4/6 and 4/6, the fractions are equal: 4/6 = 4/6.
Same whole only. 3/4 of a small pizza can be less food than 2/4 of a giant pizza. We compare fractions only when the wholes are the same size.
Check the whole and the denominator first. Then compare.
Prove each comparison with a drawing or a number line.
Which symbol makes this true? 7/8 ___ 4/8
Which fraction is greatest?
Write a sample story for our guide: two garden beds of the same size, one with 2/6 carrots and one with 4/6 carrots. Compare them with a symbol and explain.
Same denominator, same whole: compare the numerators. Next we hunt for the most common fraction mistakes and fix them.
Exit ticket: compare 3/8 and 6/8 with >, = or <. Draw a number line to prove it.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 7, mini lesson 11, practice 12, exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: the household-measure-then-grams order, dual-column labels, and the lasagna numbers (1 cup, 280 calories; 2 cups, 560 calories) are from the FDA page. All pans, beds and pizzas are sample data.
Grade limit: M03.A-F.1.1.5 compares fractions with the SAME denominator only (denominators 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 8). Do not assess comparisons like 2/3 vs 3/4.
Likely misconceptions: reversing > and < (teach “the open side faces the greater amount”); comparing parts of different wholes; thinking 0/3 is not a fraction (0/3 is 0, no parts).
Answer guide: 3/6 and 5/6: both are sixths of the same whole, so the pieces are the same size and 5 pieces is more. Garden story: 2/6 < 4/6. Exit ticket: 3/8 < 6/8, with 6/8 farther right on the line.
U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Serving Size on the Nutrition Facts Label · U.S. government work, public domain
A Nutrition Facts label starts with the serving size. The FDA says the serving size is written in a household measure, like a cup, a slice or a jar, and then in grams. A gram is a small unit for measuring how heavy something is.
The facts on most labels are for one serving. Some packages have a dual-column label. That means two columns: one for a single serving and one for the whole package. It tells you how much you get if you eat or drink the whole package at one time.
The FDA’s lasagna example shows why this matters. One serving is 1 cup and has 280 calories. Two servings are 2 cups and have 560 calories, twice as many. A calorie measures the energy food gives your body.
So the FDA says to pay attention to how many servings are in the package, and to ask how many servings you are really eating.
Source: U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Serving Size on the Nutrition Facts Label (fda.gov)