find and fix common fraction mistakes about equal parts, number lines and comparing, and explain the correct thinking.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. The Moon phase called “first quarter” looks like half of a circle. Is the name wrong? Talk with a partner.
Why might a Moon that looks like a half be called a quarter?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Mistakes are clues. Today we are fraction fixers. Each mistake below is a real one that students make. We find what went wrong and fix it kindly.
Fix-up 1: unequal parts. Bo draws a circle with 4 pieces of different sizes and colors one: “1/4.” Fix: fourths must be equal. Redraw with 4 equal parts.
Worked example 1: counting marks. Cara draws a 0 to 1 line with 4 equal jumps. She counts the tick marks: 0, then 3 marks in the middle, then 1. That is 5 marks, so she labels the first jump 1/5. Step 1: find the error: she counted marks, not jumps. Step 2: count the jumps: 4. Step 3: so each jump is 1/4, and the first point after 0 is 1/4.
Worked example 2: shaded over not shaded. Dev sees a bar with 8 equal parts and 3 shaded. He writes 3/5, because 3 parts are shaded and 5 are not. Step 1: the denominator should be ALL the equal parts in the whole: 3 + 5 = 8. Step 2: the numerator is the shaded parts: 3. Step 3: the fraction shaded is 3/8.
Fix-up 4: bigger number, bigger piece? Eli says 1/8 of a pizza is more than 1/4 because 8 is more than 4. Fix: the 8 means the same pizza is cut into more pieces, so each piece is smaller.
Fix-up 5: different wholes. Fay says the first quarter Moon is wrongly named because it looks like a half. Fix: the quarter is a fraction of the month’s journey; the half is a fraction of the Moon’s face we see. Different wholes. We compare and name fractions only with the whole in mind.
Find the mistake, then fix it. Draw every fix.
Make a Fix-Up card for our guide.
Draw a mistake a first grader might make when cutting a pizza into fourths. Next to it, draw the fix and write one sentence of advice.
Ivy says 1/6 of a garden bed is bigger than 1/3 of the same bed because 6 is bigger than 3. Which is the best fix?
A 0 to 1 line has 6 equal jumps. It has tick marks, counting the marks at 0 and 1. (write a number)
We fixed five common mistakes. Next we prove that equal fractions land on the same point by lining up number lines.
Exit ticket: which mistake from today do you think is the easiest to make? Tell how you will check for it in your own work.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 7, mini lesson 12, fix-up practice 11, exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: Space Place says the shape is not changing but our view is; the Sun is the only light source; one half is always lit; first and third quarter both look like a half moon; waxing means getting bigger and waning means getting smaller; 27.3 days to orbit and 29.5 days new moon to new moon. The “quarter of the way through its monthly journey” wording is from the NASA Science Moon Phases page used in 2.07. Do not explain why the third quarter has its name; the two NASA pages describe it differently.
Each error was re-derived: Cara: 4 jumps have 5 marks, so counting marks gives fifths. Dev: 3 shaded and 5 unshaded gives 3/5. Gus: 2 shaded and 4 unshaded gives 2/4. A 6-jump line has 7 marks.
Supports: a Fix-Up checklist: whole? equal parts? count all the parts? count jumps? same whole and same denominator before comparing?
Answer guide: notes should name the error, show the correct fraction and give a reason, for example “the pieces must be the same size.” First grader card: unequal pizza pieces fixed by cutting in half and in half again.
NASA Space Place, What Are the Moon's Phases? · NASA web content; NASA material is generally not subject to copyright. Retold in our own words, nothing quoted
NASA Space Place is NASA’s website for kids. It explains that the Moon’s shape is not really changing. Our view of the Moon changes.
The Moon does not make its own light. The Sun is the only source of light in our solar system. Sunlight always lights up one half of the Moon, the side facing the Sun. The other side is dark.
As the Moon moves around Earth, we see different amounts of the lit side. Space Place names eight phases. At first quarter, we see a half moon. At third quarter, we see a half moon too, but the other half is lit. Waxing means getting bigger, and waning means getting smaller.
The Moon takes about 27.3 days to go around Earth. But because of how sunlight hits it, it takes about 29.5 days to go from one new moon to the next.
Source: NASA Space Place, What Are the Moon's Phases? (spaceplace.nasa.gov)