write a claim, evidence and reasoning argument that 2/4 = 4/8, and use equivalent fractions to compare shares of the same whole.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Remember our puzzle: Maya took 2 pieces of a pan cut into 4. Leo took 4 pieces of the same size pan cut into 8. Write your answer now, in one sentence.
Which kind of evidence is strongest for a math claim?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Claim, evidence, reasoning. A math argument has three parts. The claim answers the question. The evidence is a model or numbers anyone can check. The reasoning explains why the evidence proves the claim.
Worked example 1: the brownie puzzle. Amir writes: Claim: Maya and Leo got the same amount, because 2/4 = 4/8. Evidence 1: I laid a paper pan in fourths with 2 shaded on top of a same-size pan in eighths with 4 shaded. The shaded parts covered the same space. Evidence 2: on stacked number lines of the same length, 2/4 and 4/8 are at the same point. Reasoning: each fourth is cut into 2 eighths, so 2 fourths is 2 groups of 2 eighths, which is 4 eighths. More pieces, but each is half as big.
Worked example 2: a new puzzle. Bella’s sample pans are the same size. Sam takes 1/3 of a pan. Tia takes 3/6 of the other pan. Step 1: rename Sam’s share in sixths: 1/3 = 2/6. Step 2: now both are sixths of the same size pan. Step 3: compare numerators: 2 < 3. Step 4: 2/6 < 3/6, so Tia got more.
Rename, then compare. In grade 3 we compare fractions with the same denominator. If the denominators differ, we may find an equivalent fraction first, as Bella did.
Critique kindly. When a classmate’s argument has a gap, name the part that works first, then ask a question about the part that is missing.
Use your strips, paper pans and stacked lines as evidence.
Write an argument for our guide.
New puzzle: two same-size garden beds. One has 3/4 planted. The other has 6/8 planted. Write a claim, evidence and reasoning: is the same amount planted?
Two same-size pizzas: Uma eats 2/8 of one. Vic eats 1/4 of the other. Which is true?
Read a partner's argument. Write one thing that works and one question that would make it stronger.
We solved our puzzle with proof: 2/4 = 4/8. Next we check everything we learned and plan our Fair Share Pizza and Garden Guide.
Exit ticket: in one sentence each, write the claim, one piece of evidence and the reasoning for 2/4 = 4/8.
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 6, mini lesson 12, practice and argument writing 13, exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: the 50-cent value, the Presidential Seal details (eagle, olive branch for peace, 13 arrows for war, shield, 50 stars), Independence Hall in 1975-76 and the Declaration of Independence note are from the Mint page. Bella’s pans and the pizzas are sample data.
Grade limit: M03.A-F.1.1.5 compares same denominators; we only rename with simple equivalences already proved with models (1/3 = 2/6, 1/4 = 2/8, 1/2 = 2/4 = 4/8, 3/4 = 6/8).
Likely misconceptions: “more pieces is more”; using different-size pans as evidence; renaming by adding (1/3 = 2/4).
Answer guide: garden beds: Claim: the same amount is planted. Evidence: stacked lines or strips show 3/4 and 6/8 at the same point. Reasoning: each fourth is 2 eighths, so 3 fourths is 6 eighths. A strong brownie argument uses two of: overlaid pans, stacked lines, strips.
United States Mint, Coin Classroom: Half Dollar · U.S. Mint educational page (the footer reads All rights reserved); facts are retold in our own words and nothing is quoted
The half dollar is the 50-cent coin of the United States. The U.S. Mint says the design on its back is full of symbols. A symbol is a picture that stands for an idea.
The back of the coin shows the Presidential Seal. An eagle, our national bird, holds an olive branch in one claw and 13 arrows in the other. The olive branch stands for peace. The arrows stand for war. A shield is in front of the eagle. A ring of 50 stars, one for each state, goes around the design.
In 1975 and 1976, the back showed a different picture for the country’s 200th birthday: Independence Hall in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Important events, like the signing of the Declaration of Independence, happened there.
Math has symbols too. The = sign stands for “is the same amount as.” One half dollar, 50 cents, is the same amount as two quarters, 25 + 25 cents.
Source: United States Mint, Coin Classroom: Half Dollar (kids.usmint.gov)