check planner pages for correct two-step work, equations and totals, and give kind, specific feedback.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Good readers check labels carefully. Read what the FDA says about reading a label closely. Then check this card.
A card says: “36 servings ÷ 4 servings per package = 8 packages.” What is the best check?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Today we are inspectors. We walk the gallery and check every planner page. A good inspector is careful and kind.
Three checks for every card. (1) Does the equation match the story? (2) Is each step correct? Check a second way. (3) Does the answer make sense?
Worked example 1: Grace checks a Tables and Rows card. The card says “6 tables × 8 guests = 42 guests.” Grace skip-counts by 8: 8, 16, 24, 32, 40, 48. The product is 48, not 42. Her feedback: “I notice 6 × 8 says 42. I wonder if you meant 6 × 7. Try skip-counting by 8.”
Worked example 2: Andre checks a Guest Count card. The card says “245 + 168 = 313.” Andre estimates: 250 + 170 = 420. The card is about 100 too low. He adds by place: 200 + 100 = 300, 40 + 60 = 100, 5 + 8 = 13. 300 + 100 + 13 = 413. The card forgot the regrouped hundred.
Feedback frame. “I notice … I wonder … Try …” Name the number, not the person. Give one next step.
Practice checking before the gallery walk.
Gallery walk. Visit three pages that are not your team’s.
For each page you visit, choose one card. Check its equation and its answer a second way. Write one “I notice … I wonder … Try …” note.
Use the reading. The FDA says to compare each %DV with 5 and 20. Write a sample %DV for three foods (label them sample). Tell whether each is low, high or in between, and order them from least to greatest.
This is a sample story, but it shows the kind of mistake planners must catch. A club plans a picnic for 6 tables with 8 people at each table. The planner writes 6 × 8 = 42 and orders 42 snack packs.
On picnic day, 48 people sit down. That is 48 − 42 = 6 people with no snack. That is a whole table’s worth of people, minus 2.
One quick check would have caught it: 8 + 8 + 8 + 8 + 8 + 8 = 48. This is why every page of our planner shows its equation and a second check.
Think about it: How could the planner have caught the mistake before ordering? What check will you use on your page?
Feedback is a gift when it is kind, specific and helpful.
Exit ticket: what is one change your team will make after today's feedback? Which criterion will it help: correct, clear, fair or honest?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture and case study 11, guided practice 10, gallery walk 9, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: accepting an answer because it looks like a real number; feedback that only says “good job” or “it is wrong”; in the juice box story, subtracting the 2 extra boxes.
Supports: printed feedback-frame cards; a checklist of the three checks. Pair students so each visit has a reader and a checker.
Answer guide: warm-up 4 × 8 = 32, so 9 packages; skip-count by 8 (48); true; 413; 30 ÷ 5 + 2 = j (j = 8); fair sharing; 45, and 45 − 7 = 38, so the card is right; 500 − 236 = 264, not 374 (check: 264 + 236 = 500). The %DV task is a comparison of numbers only; percents are not taught in grade 3. Collect feedback notes for the 1.24 revision studio.
U.S. Food and Drug Administration, How to Understand and Use the Nutrition Facts Label · U.S. government work, public domain
The FDA’s guide teaches readers to look closely at each part of a Nutrition Facts label. On its sample label, the FDA adds colored sections and numbers to point out each part. The FDA says these colors are not on real labels.
The guide reminds readers that every amount on the label is for one serving. The number of servings you eat changes the amounts you get. So you must check how many servings you really have.
The label also shows a percent for many nutrients, called the %DV. The FDA gives a quick guide for it. A %DV of 5 or less for a serving is low. A %DV of 20 or more is high. Readers compare each number with 5 and 20.
The FDA says to pick foods with more of some nutrients, like fiber and calcium. It says to pick foods with less of others, like sodium and added sugars.
Checking a label is like checking math. You read each number, compare it with a guide, and ask if it makes sense.
Source: U.S. Food and Drug Administration, How to Understand and Use the Nutrition Facts Label (fda.gov)