
prove that replacing one equation by its sum with a multiple of the other produces a system with the same solutions, and use the result to explain systems with no solution or infinitely many.
Instruction
Elimination seems like a trick: you add two equations and a variable disappears. But why should the new equation have the same solution as the old ones? This lab turns the trick into a proof.
The claim. Take any system
(A) a1x + b1y = c1 (B) a2x + b2y = c2
and any number k. Replace (A) with (A) + k(B), the equation (a1 + ka2)x + (b1 + kb2)y = c1 + kc2, and keep (B). Claim: the new system has exactly the same solutions as the old one.
Proof, part 1: every old solution is a new solution. Suppose (s, t) solves the old system. Then a1s + b1t = c1 and a2s + b2t = c2 are true statements about numbers. Multiplying both sides of the second by k keeps it true. Adding equal quantities to equal quantities keeps equality, so a1s + b1t + k(a2s + b2t) = c1 + kc2. Regrouping with the distributive property gives exactly the new equation evaluated at (s, t). Since (B) is unchanged, (s, t) solves the new system.
Proof, part 2: every new solution is an old solution. Suppose (s, t) solves the new system. It satisfies (B), so it satisfies k(B). Subtracting k(B) from the new equation undoes the replacement and gives back (A), still true at (s, t). So (s, t) solves the old system.
Parts 1 and 2 together show that the two solution sets are identical. That is why each elimination step is safe: it never gains or loses a solution. Notice that part 2 needed the step to be reversible, the same idea that justified solving one-variable equations in Unit 2.
What elimination reveals. Solve 2x + 3y = 6 and 4x + 6y = 5. Replace the second with (second) − 2(first): 0x + 0y = 5 − 12, that is, 0 = −7. By the theorem, the new system has the same solutions as the old one, and no pair makes 0 = −7 true, so the original system has no solution. Graphically, the lines are parallel: both have slope −2/3 but different intercepts. For 2x + 3y = 6 and 4x + 6y = 12, the same step gives 0 = 0, which every pair satisfies, so the solutions are all the points of the single line 2x + 3y = 6: infinitely many.
Discourse protocol. Write the proof in your own words for the specific system 3x + 2y = 16, 5x − 2y = 8 with k = 1. Trade with a partner. Your partner marks any step that is not justified by a property and writes a question beside it. Revise, then present one part of the proof to your group, and answer their question: “Why does the proof need part 2?”
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Elimination on a system produces the equation 0 = 9. What does that tell you?
Why does part 2 of the proof matter?
The system 2x + 3y = 6 and 4x + 6y = 12 has infinitely many solutions.
Write both parts of the proof for the system 3x + 2y = 16 and 5x − 2y = 8, replacing the first equation by the sum of the two. Justify every step by a property of equality.
How confident are you that you can prove that elimination preserves the solutions of a system and interpret 0 = 0 and 0 = c?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Solve the system by elimination: 6x + 5y = −17 and −x + 3y = −1
Check your answer
Answer: (−2, −1)Check the ordered pair in both equations. - Solve the system by elimination: −3x − 5y = −14 and 5x + 2y = −2
Check your answer
Answer: (−2, 4)Check the ordered pair in both equations. - Solve the system by elimination: −6x − 4y = −20 and 3x − y = −5
Check your answer
Answer: (0, 5)Check the ordered pair in both equations. - Solve the system by elimination: 3x + 4y = −13 and −5x − 6y = 21
Check your answer
Answer: (−3, −1)Check the ordered pair in both equations. - Solve 3x − 6y = 9 and x − 2y = 3.
Check your answer
Answer: Infinitely many solutions (the same line)The first equation is 3 times the second; elimination gives 0 = 0. - Solve 2x + 5y = 7 and 4x + 10y = 9.
Check your answer
Answer: No solution (parallel lines)Second − 2 × first gives 0 = −5. - Solve x + y = 5 and x − y = 1.
Check your answer
Answer: (3, 2)Add: 2x = 6.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Add the equations 2x + y = 11 and x − y = 1. Solve the system, and check that the solution also satisfies the sum equation.
Check your answer
Answer: Sum 3x = 12; solution (4, 3); 3(4) = 12 ✓Equal quantities added to equal quantities stay equal. - For which k does the system 6x + ky = 10 and 3x + 2y = 5 have infinitely many solutions? For which k does 6x + ky = 12, 3x + 2y = 5 have none?
Check your answer
Answer: k = 4 in both casesWith k = 4 the first is 2 times the second (10 = 2 × 5) or contradicts it (12 ≠ 10). - Plan A costs $20 plus $0.05 per text; plan B costs $15 plus $0.05 per text. Solve the system and interpret the result.
Check your answer
Answer: No solution: plan B is always $5 cheaper20 + 0.05t = 15 + 0.05t gives 20 = 15.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- Prove that any solution of x + 2y = 7 and 3x − y = 7 also satisfies 4x + y = 14. Then find the solution and verify all three equations.
Check your answer
Answer: (3, 2): 3 + 4 = 7, 9 − 2 = 7, 12 + 2 = 14Adding true equations gives a true equation: (x + 2y) + (3x − y) = 7 + 7.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Solve and graph: |x + 1| ≥ 4
Check your answer
Answer: x ≤ −5 or x ≥ 3Distance from −1 is at least 4: x + 1 ≤ −4 or x + 1 ≥ 4. - Solve: −4(x + 7) − 7 = −7
Check your answer
Answer: x = −7Distribute: −4x − 28 − 7 = −7; collect and isolate x.
Three Student Proofs That Elimination Is Safe, and One Step That Is Not
SLS original: three student-written proofs and a counterexample, written for this lab · SLS original
Why this reading. The lab asks you to write the proof in your own words, trade with a partner and mark any step that is not justified. That works better if you have first seen what unjustified looks like. Below are three proofs of the same claim, written by students working on the system 3x + 2y = 16 and 5x − 2y = 8 with k = 1. One is complete. One proves half of what it claims. One proves something that is not true. Read them before you write your own.
The claim they are all trying to prove. Replacing equation (A) by (A) + k(B), and keeping (B), gives a system with exactly the same solutions.
Proof 1 — Mei
“Suppose (s, t) solves both 3x + 2y = 16 and 5x − 2y = 8. Then 3s + 2t = 16 and 5s − 2t = 8 are true statements about numbers. Adding equal quantities to equal quantities keeps equality, so (3s + 2t) + (5s − 2t) = 16 + 8, which regroups by the distributive and associative properties to 8s = 24. So (s, t) satisfies the new first equation, and it still satisfies (B), which I did not touch. Therefore every solution of the old system solves the new one.
“Now suppose (s, t) solves the new system: 8s = 24 and 5s − 2t = 8. Subtract the second equation from the first, which is allowed because both are true at (s, t): 8s − (5s − 2t) = 24 − 8, giving 3s + 2t = 16, which is (A). Since (B) is still there, (s, t) solves the old system. The two solution sets contain each other, so they are equal.”
Proof 2 — Omar
“Let (s, t) solve the old system. Then 3s + 2t = 16 and 5s − 2t = 8. Add them: 8s = 24, so s = 3. Substituting into the second gives 15 − 2t = 8, so t = 3.5. And (3, 3.5) does satisfy 8x = 24 and 5x − 2y = 8. So the new system has the same solution as the old one, which is what we wanted.”
Proof 3 — Priya
“Any operation you do to both sides of an equation keeps it true. Adding k times one equation to another is doing the same thing to both sides of the first equation, because k(B) means the same number on the left as on the right. So the new equation is true whenever the old ones were, and therefore the two systems are the same. This also shows why you can multiply an equation by anything you like: multiplying both sides by k keeps it true.”
The counterexample the third proof needs
Priya’s last sentence is the one to test. Take the system x + y = 2 and x − y = 0, whose only solution is (1, 1). Multiply the first equation by 0. Multiplying both sides by the same number certainly keeps it true: 0 = 0. But the new system is 0 = 0 together with x − y = 0, and its solutions are every point on the line y = x — (5, 5), (−2, −2) and infinitely many more. The step did not lose the solution; it invented solutions. It cannot be undone, because no multiplication turns 0 = 0 back into x + y = 2.
That is the hinge of the whole lab. A step is safe when it is reversible. Adding k(B) to (A) can be undone by subtracting k(B), whatever k is, even zero. Multiplying an equation by a nonzero number can be undone by dividing. Multiplying by zero cannot be undone at all, which is why the properties of equality carry the words “nonzero” every time division is involved.
What to do with these
Decide which proof is complete, and for each of the other two name the exact sentence where it goes wrong and what it would take to fix it. One of them is not wrong so much as incomplete: it proves a true thing that is weaker than the claim. Say precisely what it proves and what it leaves out. Then answer the question the lab will ask you: why does the proof need part 2? The counterexample above is your evidence.