
carry out a complete statistical investigation comparing two groups with real data, and communicate the findings in writing and orally.
Instruction
This task puts the whole unit to work on a question about your state or community that you choose.
1. Ask a comparison question. Good questions compare one quantity across two groups and can be answered with data you can actually get. Examples: “Are July high temperatures more variable in Kansas City than in St. Louis?” (NOAA Climate at a Glance). “Do workers in St. Charles County have longer commutes than workers in Boone County?” (Census Bureau, American Community Survey). “Do ninth graders at our school spend more time on homework than eleventh graders?” (a class survey, with permission). Avoid questions that need data you cannot collect honestly in two weeks.
2. Choose your data. All three routes earn full credit, and all three support every part of this task.
- Route A — Data Set 1, printed below. Fifteen July daily high temperatures (°F) at two airports, one inland and one on the coast, illustrative data built for this task. Inland airport: 96, 103, 105, 98, 108, 100, 104, 95, 106, 101, 99, 107, 97, 102, 101. Coastal airport: 78, 80, 77, 82, 79, 81, 76, 83, 80, 78, 79, 81, 77, 80, 82. Both groups are roughly symmetric with no outliers, so the mean and standard deviation are the statistics that fit. Your question: is July heat more variable inland than on the coast?
- Route B — Data Set 2, printed below. One-way commute times in minutes for fifteen workers in each of two counties, illustrative data built for this task. Inland county: 10, 14, 18, 20, 22, 25, 28, 30, 35, 40, 45, 50, 60, 75, 100. Coastal county: 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, 15, 17, 18, 20, 22, 25, 28, 32, 38, 55. Both groups are skewed right and each has one outlier by the 1.5 × IQR rule (100 minutes inland, fence 95; 55 minutes coastal, fence 52), so the median and IQR are the statistics that fit. Your question: do workers in the inland county have longer commutes?
- Route C — data you gather. Download real data from a named public source and document it, or run a survey. NOAA Climate at a Glance (ncei.noaa.gov/access/monitoring/climate-at-a-glance) gives monthly temperature and precipitation for any U.S. city or county, including every Missouri county; Census QuickFacts (census.gov/quickfacts) gives county commute times, incomes and education; the Bureau of Labor Statistics Local Area Unemployment Statistics (bls.gov/lau) gives county unemployment. Record the website, the table name, the date you downloaded it and any filters you used. If you survey people, write the exact question you asked and offer a way to decline.
Routes A and B need no internet and no materials. Route C asks more of your data-gathering but no more of your mathematics, so it is not scored higher.
3. Display. Make at least two kinds of display. Box plots on a common scale are best for the comparison; a histogram or dot plot for each group shows shape. Label every axis with the quantity and the unit.
4. Summarize to fit the shape. Describe each distribution’s shape, then choose statistics: mean and standard deviation for roughly symmetric data, median and IQR for skewed data or data with outliers. Compute them with CODAP or a spreadsheet and check one by hand. Identify any outliers with the 1.5 × IQR rule and decide, with a reason, how to treat them.
5. Answer the question. A strong answer compares center and spread, in context, with units: “The median commute in County A was about 8 minutes longer, and the middle half of County A’s commutes spread over a wider range.” Round to a precision the data support.
6. State the limits. Who or what is missing from the data? Could the result be different in another year or another group? What would you need to claim a cause?
The presentation. Three minutes: your question, one display, your answer with its key numbers, and one limit. Expect two questions from the class about your choices. A recorded presentation is an equal-credit alternative to a live one.
What strong reports do. They make one clear claim and support it with numbers. They explain choices a reader might question: why the median and not the mean, why those bins, why that outlier stayed. They never let a display do the arguing on its own; every figure is followed by a sentence that says what it shows.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Symmetric data, no outliers
Tap to revealReport the mean and standard deviation.
Skewed data or outliers
Tap to revealReport the median and IQR.
Outlier rule
Tap to revealMore than 1.5 × IQR below Q1 or above Q3.
Comparing two groups
Tap to revealCompare center and spread, in context, with units.
Your two box plots show County A with a median 8 minutes higher but nearly identical IQRs. Which conclusion is best supported?
How confident are you that you can carry out and present a complete statistical comparison of two groups?
Unit 1 checkpoint
Do this before you start the task. It covers the whole unit and tells you what to review first.
For 2, 5, 7, 8, 12, 15, 20, what is the IQR?
Which display shows every individual value?
With Q1 = 10 and Q3 = 25, the upper outlier fence is .
The mean of 2, 4, 6, 8, 10 is and its MAD is .
The signed deviations from the mean always add to zero.
Household incomes in a county are strongly skewed right. Which summary fits best?
Adding 5 to every value in a data set changes which of these?
The standard deviation (divide by n) of 4, 6, 7, 9, 14 is about .
Deleting a real outlier to make the mean look typical is good statistical practice.
Data were recorded to the nearest half hour. Which is the best way to report a mean of 7.0500 hours?
Two box plots should be drawn on a common scale when they are compared.
Group B’s sleep data 5, 5.5, 6, 6, 6.5, 7, 7, 8.5, 9, 10 have median .
Submit: Data Story report (600-800 words with displays) and 3-minute presentation
Task: Pose a question that compares one quantity across two groups, gather and document real data, display and summarize both distributions with statistics that fit their shape, and write and present an answer that states its limits.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Plan. Question, quantity definitions with units, data source and collection plan, and a sketch of the displays you will make.
- Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed draft. A partner checks one statistic by hand, your choice of summary against the shape, and your precision; submit a revision note responding to each comment.
- Stage 3 — Revised final. 600-800 words with labeled displays on a common scale, statistics, an answer to the question, limits and a source list.
- Stage 4 — Presentation. Three minutes live or recorded, followed by two questions from classmates or your reviewer.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Question and quantities (A1.NQ.B.4) | A clear comparison question; quantities defined with units and a collection method. |
| Displays (A1.DS.A.1) | At least two appropriate displays, labeled, with groups on a common scale. |
| Statistics (A1.DS.A.2) | Center and spread chosen to fit the shape and computed correctly; outliers identified and handled with a reason. |
| Interpretation (A1.DS.A.3) | Differences in center and spread interpreted in context; effect of outliers discussed. |
| Precision and units (A1.NQ.B.3, A1.NQ.B.5) | Units consistent throughout; numbers reported to a justified precision. |
| Communication and defense (MP.3) | Clear written claim with limits; presentation answers questions with reasoning from the data. |
The Data File: Three Real Data Sets With Their Provenance
SLS compilation of NOAA NCEI Climate at a Glance city series, BLS Local Area Unemployment Statistics and BLS Average Price Data (all public domain); retrieved September 23, 2026 · Public domain (works of the United States government); compilation and worked examples SLS original
Why this reading. The task asks for a comparison question, real data, documented provenance, displays, statistics chosen to fit the shape, an answer and its limits. Route C told you to go and download something. You do not have to. Three complete data sets are printed below, each from a named federal series, each with the date it was retrieved and a note on what it leaves out. Pick one, ask a question of it, and spend your two weeks on the statistics rather than on a download. If you would rather gather your own, the last section says what documentation a report needs.
Data Set A — July heat, inland against coastal
Source: NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information, Climate at a Glance, city time series. July average maximum temperature (°F) at Fresno Yosemite International Airport (station USW00093193) and San Diego International Airport (station USW00023188), 1995–2025. Retrieved September 23, 2026.
Question it answers: is July heat more variable inland than on the coast?
Year: Fresno / San Diego — 1995: 94.7 / 73.3, 1996: 100.8 / 73.7, 1997: 95.5 / 72.2, 1998: 96.7 / 73.0, 1999: 95.6 / 72.4, 2000: 93.5 / 73.2, 2001: 96.0 / 72.8, 2002: 99.2 / 71.6, 2003: 101.3 / 74.1, 2004: 98.5 / 76.2, 2005: 101.7 / 74.2, 2006: 103.0 / 80.9, 2007: 98.2 / 73.8, 2008: 98.6 / 73.4, 2009: 100.7 / 75.3, 2010: 98.5 / 70.1, 2011: 96.5 / 74.1, 2012: 97.6 / 72.7, 2013: 101.0 / 74.2, 2014: 99.9 / 76.9, 2015: 96.8 / 75.7, 2016: 100.0 / 74.4, 2017: 101.9 / 76.0, 2018: 102.8 / 78.6, 2019: 99.0 / 73.3, 2020: 99.9 / 74.4, 2021: 103.3 / 76.0, 2022: 100.8 / 72.2, 2023: 101.8 / 74.1, 2024: 105.2 / 76.7, 2025: 97.0 / 73.3.
What the shape is, and what to use: Fresno is close to symmetric with no outliers (five-number summary 93.5, 96.8, 99.2, 101.3, 105.2), so the mean, 99.23 °F, and the standard deviation, 2.76 °F dividing by n, describe it well. San Diego (70.1, 73.0, 74.1, 75.7, 80.9) has one value above the upper fence of 79.75, the 80.9 °F of July 2006, so the median 74.1 °F and IQR 2.7 °F are the safer pair. Reporting the mean for one city and the median for the other is fine as long as you say why, and as long as you never subtract one from the other and call the result a difference.
Limits: one station each, not a whole city; an average of daily maximums, not the hottest day; instruments, siting and city growth around an airport change what a thermometer reads over thirty years.
Data Set B — two county labor markets
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Local Area Unemployment Statistics, county unemployment rate, not seasonally adjusted. Fresno County (series LAUCN060190000000003) and San Mateo County (series LAUCN060810000000003), the twelve months of 2024. Retrieved September 23, 2026.
Question it answers: how far apart are two county labor markets, in level and in month-to-month variability?
Fresno County, January through December 2024, percent: 8.4, 9.1, 8.9, 8.0, 7.3, 7.8, 8.1, 7.5, 6.7, 7.1, 7.8, 7.9.
San Mateo County, same months: 3.7, 3.6, 3.5, 3.3, 3.1, 3.8, 4.1, 4.2, 3.7, 3.8, 3.8, 3.5.
What the shape is, and what to use: both roughly symmetric, no outliers. Fresno mean 7.88%, median 7.85%, IQR 0.85 points, standard deviation 0.67 points. San Mateo mean 3.68%, median 3.70%, IQR 0.30 points, standard deviation 0.29 points. The gap is about 4.2 percentage points, and Fresno’s rate is also about 2.1 times San Mateo’s: two different comparisons, both true, and a report should say which one it means.
Limits: model-based estimates that BLS revises; not seasonally adjusted, so part of the movement within the year is the farm calendar; the rate counts only people actively looking for work. October 2025 is missing from this series altogether, because the survey was not collected during the 2025 lapse in federal appropriations — which is why this data set uses 2024.
Data Set C — the price of a staple, three years running
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Average Price Data, series APU0000701312, “Rice, white, long grain, uncooked, per lb. (453.6 gm), U.S. city average, not seasonally adjusted.” Retrieved September 23, 2026.
Question it answers: did the price of rice move between 2024 and 2026, and did it become steadier or jumpier?
2024, January through December, dollars per pound: 1.000, 1.001, 1.014, 1.025, 1.002, 1.018, 1.039, 1.085, 1.078, 1.056, 1.061, 1.032.
2025, January through December: 1.008, 1.030, 1.038, 1.031, 1.067, 1.061, 1.068, 1.059, 1.060, not collected, 1.065, 1.076.
2026, January through August: 1.059, 1.074, 1.060, 1.076, 1.071, 1.089, 1.100, 1.111.
Worked summaries: 2024 has twelve months, mean $1.034, median $1.0285, IQR $0.0505, standard deviation $0.0286. 2025 has eleven, mean $1.051, median $1.060. The eight months of 2026 so far have mean $1.080, median $1.075, IQR $0.029. Mean price rose about 4.4% from 2024 to the first eight months of 2026, and the spread narrowed.
Limits: a national average, not a local price; BLS prices are collected in a sample of outlets and published to a tenth of a cent, which is more precision than any shopper experiences; and the three groups do not have the same number of months, so say so before you compare them.
If you gather your own instead
Nothing above is required. If you would rather bring your own data, a report has to say six things about it, and the three data sets here model all six: the issuing agency, the exact series or table identifier, the period covered, the date you retrieved it, what one value measures (including its unit), and what the data leave out. A number without those six things is a rumor with a decimal point. If you survey people instead, write the exact wording of your question, say how many people you asked and how you chose them, and offer everyone a way to decline.
One habit to carry into the write-up. Each of these data sets describes a group of things — Julys, months, county-months — and not people. Your claim should describe the same things. “Fresno Julys are hotter and more variable” is supported here. “People in Fresno are hotter” is not a sentence about anything.
Sources: NOAA NCEI, Climate at a Glance: City Time Series (Fresno) (ncei.noaa.gov); NOAA NCEI, Climate at a Glance: City Time Series (San Diego) (ncei.noaa.gov); BLS, Local Area Unemployment Statistics — Fresno County (LAUCN060190000000003) (data.bls.gov); BLS, Local Area Unemployment Statistics — San Mateo County (LAUCN060810000000003) (data.bls.gov); BLS, Average Price Data — Rice, white, long grain, uncooked, per lb. (APU0000701312) (data.bls.gov)