
solve linear inequalities and explain when the inequality reverses, and rearrange a formula to solve for a quantity of interest.
Instruction
In this lab you judge other people’s reasoning. Each group gets worked solutions that contain errors. Your job is to find the first wrong line, explain why it is wrong and fix it.
Inequalities behave almost like equations. You may add or subtract the same number on both sides, and multiply or divide both sides by the same positive number, without changing which side is larger. But multiplying or dividing by a negative number reverses the order. Look at a true statement: 2 < 5. Multiply both sides by −1: −2 and −5. On a number line, −2 is to the right of −5, so −2 > −5. The sign had to flip.
Worked solution to critique. A student solved −4x + 7 > 19 like this:
- −4x > 12
- x > −3
Line 1 is correct (subtract 7). Line 2 divides by −4 without reversing the inequality. The correct result is x < −3. Test it: try x = −4, which the correct answer includes: −4(−4) + 7 = 23, and 23 > 19 is true. Try x = 0, which the student’s answer includes: 0 + 7 = 7, and 7 > 19 is false. A single test value can disprove a wrong answer.
Inequality in context. A student earns $16.50 an hour (an illustrative wage) and has already saved $140 toward a $600 laptop. How many hours h must she work? 140 + 16.5h ≥ 600, so 16.5h ≥ 460 and h ≥ 27.87… She needs at least 28 hours. The inequality answers “how many hours is enough?”, which is the real question.
Rearranging formulas. A formula is an equation with several letters. You can solve it for any one of them with the same moves you use on numbers. The temperature formula F = (9/5)C + 32 gives Fahrenheit from Celsius. To get Celsius from Fahrenheit: subtract 32 to get F − 32 = (9/5)C, then multiply both sides by 5/9 to get C = (5/9)(F − 32). Check with a known pair: 212°F gives (5/9)(180) = 100°C, the boiling point of water; 98.6°F gives (5/9)(66.6) = 37°C.
Another: the perimeter of a rectangle is P = 2L + 2W. Solved for width: W = (P − 2L)/2. A 64-foot fence around a bed 20 feet long gives W = (64 − 40)/2 = 12 feet.
Discourse protocol. For each worked solution, one student reads it aloud line by line. The group agrees on the first incorrect line, then each person writes a critique using the frame: “Line __ is incorrect because ___. The correct step is ___, because ___. A test value that shows the error is ___.” Share critiques and choose the clearest one to present. Politeness matters: you are critiquing reasoning, not people.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Start with 3 < 7 and divide both sides by −1. Which statement is true?
Solve 5 − 2x ≤ 13.
Solving F = (9/5)C + 32 for C gives C = (5/9)(F − ). At 212°F, C = .
A student solved −3x − 6 < 9 and wrote x < −5. Identify the first incorrect line of reasoning, correct it, and give a test value that shows the student’s answer is wrong.
How confident are you that you can solve an inequality correctly, explain when the sign reverses, and rearrange a formula?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Solve and graph on a number line: 7x − 7 ≤ −21
Check your answer
Answer: x ≤ −2Add 7, then divide by 7. - Solve and graph on a number line: 3x − 10 ≥ −19
Check your answer
Answer: x ≥ −3Add 10, then divide by 3. - Solve and graph on a number line: 8x + 4 < −52
Check your answer
Answer: x < −7Subtract 4, then divide by 8. - Solve and graph on a number line: 7x + 2 ≥ −19
Check your answer
Answer: x ≥ −3Subtract 2, then divide by 7. - Solve and graph on a number line: 7x − 2 < −9
Check your answer
Answer: x < −1Add 2, then divide by 7. - Solve and graph on a number line: 6x + 1 > 37
Check your answer
Answer: x > 6Subtract 1, then divide by 6. - Solve A = (1/2)bh for h.
Check your answer
Answer: h = 2A/bMultiply by 2, then divide by b. - Solve d = rt for t.
Check your answer
Answer: t = d/r - Solve y = mx + b for x.
Check your answer
Answer: x = (y − b)/m, m ≠ 0
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- A student has saved $185 toward a $749 laptop and earns $15.50 an hour (illustrative). How many whole hours must she work?
Check your answer
Answer: At least 37 hours185 + 15.5h ≥ 749 gives h ≥ 36.39. - A Death Valley afternoon reaches 104°F (illustrative). Convert it to Celsius with C = (5/9)(F − 32).
Check your answer
Answer: 40°C104 − 32 = 72; 72 × 5/9 = 40. - A phone plan costs $35 plus $8 for each gigabyte over the limit. The budget is at most $75. How many extra gigabytes can you use?
Check your answer
Answer: At most 535 + 8g ≤ 75 gives g ≤ 5.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- Solve −3(2x − 5) + 4 > 2(x + 1) − 7 and test one value in your answer.
Check your answer
Answer: x < 3−6x + 19 > 2x − 5 gives −8x > −24; divide by −8 and reverse. Test x = 0: 19 > −5, true.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- For the data 3, 7, 8, 13, 22, 23, 32, 36, 37, 39: find the mean, median, range and interquartile range. (Find the quartiles as the medians of the lower and upper halves, leaving out the overall median when the count is odd.)
Check your answer
Answer: mean = 22.00; median = 22.5; range = 36; IQR = 28.0 (Q1 = 8.0, Q3 = 36.0) - Which pair of statistics should summarize a strongly skewed data set?
Check your answer
Answer: Median and IQRThey resist extreme values.
Seven Worked Solutions: Six Contain an Error, One Does Not
SLS original error dossier, built on the Missouri minimum wage, Metro Transit (St. Louis) and RideKC fares and IRS standard mileage rates; rates retrieved 2026-11-03 · SLS original (the student solutions are written for this lab; the rates in them are published figures)
Why this reading. The lab says “each group gets worked solutions that contain errors.” Here they are. The seven solutions below were written for this lab; the fares, wages and mileage rates inside them are real published figures, so the contexts are ones you could check. Six contain exactly one error. One is correct. Do not assume every solution is broken: part of the skill is refusing to find a mistake that is not there. For each, name the first incorrect line, say why it is wrong, write the correct step, and give a test value that settles it.
A. Ada — hours at the minimum wage
Situation. Missouri’s minimum wage is $15.00 an hour in 2026. Ada needs to earn at least $400 in a week.
- 15h ≥ 400
- h ≥ 26.666…
- So Ada must work 26 hours.
B. Ben — spending down a fare card
Situation. Ben loads $100 on a St. Louis Metro fare card. MetroLink rides cost $2.50. He wants to keep at least $25 on the card.
- 100 − 2.5r ≥ 25
- −2.5r ≥ −75
- r ≥ 30
- So he can take 30 or more rides.
C. Cruz — two halves of a mileage year
Situation. The IRS business mileage rate was 72.5 cents from January to June 2026 and 76 cents from July to December. Cruz asks: for what mileage a would the two rates pay the same amount?
- 0.725a = 0.76a
- Divide both sides by a: 0.725 = 0.76
- That is false, so there is no solution.
D. Dana — turning Fahrenheit into Celsius
Situation. A greenhouse thermostat is labeled in Celsius and the weather report is in Fahrenheit. Dana rearranges F = (9/5)C + 32.
- Multiply both sides by 5/9: (5/9)F = C + 32
- Subtract 32: C = (5/9)F − 32
E. Eli — a youth bus pass in Kansas City
Situation. RideKC charges riders aged 6–18 $1.00 a ride and sells a youth 30-day pass for $31.25. A round trip to a job is two fares. Eli asks how many round trips d he could pay for before the pass is better.
- Cost of d round trips: 1(2d) = 1 × 2 + 1 × d = 2 + d
- 2 + d ≤ 31.25
- d ≤ 29.25
- So 29 round trips.
F. Fatima — a monthly transit budget
Situation. A household wants its monthly St. Louis MetroLink spending, at $2.50 a ride, to stay within $5 of $75.
- |2.5r − 75| ≤ 5
- 2.5r − 75 ≤ 5
- 2.5r ≤ 80
- r ≤ 32, so any number of rides up to 32 fits the budget.
G. Gita — the reduced-fare monthly pass
Situation. St. Louis Metro charges reduced-fare riders $1.25 a MetroLink ride and $39.00 for a 30-day pass. For how many rides does paying per ride cost no more than the pass?
- 1.25r ≤ 39 the condition, written down
- r ≤ 31.2 divide both sides by 1.25, a positive number, so the inequality does not reverse
- Rides are whole numbers, so paying per ride costs no more than the pass for 0 through 31 rides (31 rides cost $38.75); from 32 rides the pass is cheaper.
Sentence frames for the critique
“Line ___ is incorrect because ___. The correct step is ___, because ___. A test value that shows the error is ___, which gives ___ under the student’s answer and ___ under the correct one.” For the solution with no error, the frame changes: “Every line is justified. Line ___ is the one most likely to be challenged, and it is correct because ___.”
Two hints about where errors like to hide. First, the last line is a favorite: the algebra can be perfect and the rounding still wrong, and “at least” and “at most” round in opposite directions. Second, a step is only safe if it can be undone; if a move could destroy a solution or invent one, that is where to look.
Sources: Missouri Department of Labor and Industrial Relations, Minimum Wage (labor.mo.gov); Metro Transit (St. Louis), Fares and Passes (metrostlouis.org); RideKC (Kansas City Area Transportation Authority), Fares (ridekc.org); IRS, Standard mileage rates (irs.gov)