present our design proposal to school decision makers, explain how our data prove students want it, and answer questions with math.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Today our guests are the principal, the grounds crew and parent-teacher group members. Before you present, read how the playground handbook says to arrange a play area.
Where does the CPSC handbook say moving equipment, such as swings, should go?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Design Day. Each team has 4 minutes to present and 2 minutes for questions. Your guests want to know three things: What do students want? What exactly would be built? What will it cost, and is it safe?
A strong presentation follows the proposal. (1) The driving question and your answer in one sentence. (2) Your data display with a center and a spread, and why you chose them. (3) Your plan on the grid with areas. (4) Materials and costs. (5) Your recommendation.
Worked example 1: Nia’s opening. “We surveyed 40 sixth graders from every homeroom. Their median rating for garden boxes was 6 out of 10, with an IQR of 4, so most students are interested but not all. We recommend three boxes now, with space for three more.” Nia gives the center, the spread and what they mean in one breath.
Worked example 2: Caleb answers a question. A guest asks, “Why not report the average?” Caleb answers: “Our data had one student who said 0 minutes, which pulled the mean down to about 16.3. The median, 20, is closer to what most students said. We show both on our poster.” He uses evidence, not just opinion.
Listening well. While other teams present, write one question that uses math, such as “How did you check the area of your use zone?”
Rehearse with a partner team before the guests arrive.
After Design Day.
Write down the hardest question a guest asked your team. How did you answer it? How would you answer it now?
Use the reading. Check your plan against two CPSC layout rules. Does your layout follow them? If not, what would you move?
Thank our guests.
Exit ticket: Write a two-sentence thank-you note to one guest that names something you learned from their question.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 5 minutes, mini lecture 4, rehearsal 6, presentations about 22 (adjust to the number of teams), closure 3. Invite guests a week ahead and give them a one-page question guide.
Likely misconceptions: reading every number aloud instead of explaining what it means; defending a measure with “it’s always better” instead of the data’s shape.
Supports: presentation note cards with the five parts; assigned roles (data, plan, cost, recommendation); students may present a recorded or written version if speaking to guests is a barrier.
Answer guide: the outlier answer; 416 sq ft; true; “Most ratings are 6 to 8, but one student rated it 1.” Score the presentation on the four criteria (correct, clear, useful, honest) with 1-4 points each. Leave the final proposals in the main office as promised.
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Public Playground Safety Handbook · U.S. government work, public domain
The CPSC handbook says a play area should be organized into different sections. That keeps children from getting hurt when activities clash or when kids run from one activity to another.
The handbook says active, physical play should be kept separate from quieter play. Playground equipment, open fields and sand boxes should be in different sections. Popular, heavily used equipment should be spread out so one spot does not get crowded.
Different types of equipment have different use zones, and those zones must stay clear. The handbook gives some general rules. Moving equipment, such as swings and merry-go-rounds, should go toward a corner, side or edge of the play area. Slide exits should be placed in an area that is not crowded.
The handbook also notes that composite play structures, which join many play pieces into one big structure, have become popular on public playgrounds.
For our presentations, these rules are questions to expect. A good plan shows where each section goes, how big each use zone is, and why the layout keeps students safe.
Source: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Public Playground Safety Handbook (cpsc.gov)