check our guide pages for correct fractions and clear graphs, and give kind, specific feedback.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Careful measuring is part of a correct recipe. Read NIST’s kitchen tips, then answer.
Which does the NIST page name as a common source of error?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Critique makes the guide trustworthy. Today every team posts its page. Visitors check the math and the graphs, then leave feedback using three stems: I notice…, I wonder… and Try….
Checking a fraction card. Estimate first, then add back. If a card says 2 1/4 − 1 1/2 = 1 3/4, add back: 1 3/4 + 1 1/2 = 3 1/4, not 2 1/4, so the card is wrong. The correct difference is 3/4.
Checking a graph. Look for a title, labels, a scale that starts at 0 and equal steps. Count the X’s on a line plot and compare with the data list.
Worked example 1: Grace checks a recipe card. A card says 1/3 cup + 1/2 cup = 2/5 cup. Grace estimates: 1/2 alone is more than 2/5, so the sum must be bigger. She finds 2/6 + 3/6 = 5/6. Her feedback: “I notice the total is less than one of the parts. I wonder if the denominators were added. Try sixths: 5/6 cup.”
Worked example 2: Mateo checks a bar graph. A sample graph’s scale reads 0, 10, 20, 40, 50. Mateo notices the jump from 20 to 40 is twice the others, so the bar for 40 looks too short. His Try: “Add 30 between 20 and 40 so every step is 10.”
Practice checking before the gallery walk.
Gallery walk. Visit at least two other pages.
For each page you visit, check two numbers with an estimate or by adding back, and check one graph or line plot against the criteria. Write one I notice, one I wonder and one Try note for each page.
Back at your own page, list every piece of feedback you received. Circle the two changes you will make first and explain why.
This is a sample story, but it shows the kind of mistake our critique looks for. A class printed a recipe card for a bag of trail mix: 2/3 cup of cereal + 1/4 cup of raisins. The card said the total was 3/7 cup. Since 3/7 is less than 1/2, they bought bags that hold 1/2 cup.
The card added the numerators (2 + 1 = 3) and the denominators (3 + 4 = 7). The real total is 8/12 + 3/12 = 11/12 cup. That is 11/12 − 6/12 = 5/12 cup more than each bag could hold, so the mix spilled at the first table.
A quick estimate would have caught it: 2/3 alone is more than 1/2, so the total could never fit in a half-cup bag.
Think about it: Which check, an estimate or a common denominator, would you use first on a recipe card, and why?
Checking is not about catching people. It is about getting it right for our families.
Exit ticket: which check works best for a subtraction card, and why?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 7, case study 6, guided practice 10, gallery walk 8, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that feedback means only praise or only error-hunting; that an estimate proves an answer exactly; checking subtraction by subtracting again instead of adding back.
Supports: feedback cards printed with the three stems; a graph checklist (title, labels, 0, equal steps, every value shown). Pair students for the gallery walk. Stretch: find an error an estimate would not catch (for example 7/12 instead of 5/12).
Answer guide: warm-up dry cup for a liquid; Gina: 11/12; missing X; false; 5/12; 0 to 20 by 2s; 3/4. Exit ticket: adding back, because subtraction and addition undo each other. Graph feedback example: I notice there is no title; I wonder why the bars start at 30; Try starting the scale at 0 and adding a title. The case study is a sample scenario, not a reported incident.
National Institute of Standards and Technology, Metric Kitchen: Culinary Measurement Tips · U.S. government work, public domain
The National Institute of Standards and Technology, or NIST, is the government’s measurement lab. It gives cooks tips for measuring well.
There are two kinds of measuring cups. Dry measuring cups are made for foods like sugar. Fill the cup and then strike off, or level, the extra with a flat edge. Fluid measuring cups are made for liquids like water. Set the cup on a flat surface and read the curved top of the liquid at eye level.
NIST says a common mistake is using a dry cup for a liquid, or a liquid cup for a dry food. For the most exact results, NIST suggests weighing ingredients on a kitchen scale.
The page has more tips. You can test a kitchen thermometer in boiling water, which boils at 100 degrees Celsius at sea level. Cooking at high altitude may need changes to a recipe. Words like teaspoon and cup can mean different amounts in different countries, so the safest way to convert a recipe is to measure the usual way and then weigh it.
Source: National Institute of Standards and Technology, Metric Kitchen: Culinary Measurement Tips (nist.gov)