compare strategies for comparing decimals, explain why they work, and fix common place-value mistakes.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Sofia says 0.125 is greater than 0.5 “because 125 is greater than 5.” Before you decide, picture 0.5 of a dollar and 0.125 of a dollar in coins.
Which is worth more: 0.5 of a dollar or 0.125 of a dollar?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Three mistakes detectives watch for. Mistake 1: “longer is larger,” thinking 0.125 > 0.5 because it has more digits. Mistake 2: “add a zero” when multiplying a decimal by 10. Mistake 3: reading 0.07 as “seven tenths.” Each one comes from forgetting what a digit’s place is worth.
Strategy A: line up and fill with zeros. Write both numbers with the same number of decimal places, then compare from the left. Strategy B: think money. 0.5 is 50 cents. Strategy C: number line. The number farther right is greater. All three work because they all use place value.
Worked example 1: fixing Sofia’s mistake. Step 1: write 0.5 as 0.500. Step 2: compare 0.500 and 0.125 from the left: ones 0 and 0, tenths 5 and 1. Step 3: 5 tenths > 1 tenth, so 0.5 > 0.125. Step 4: check with money: 50 cents is more than 12 and a half cents. Sofia compared 125 to 5, but those digits are in different places.
Worked example 2: two sample shelf tags. Marcus sees cereal at $0.07 per ounce and another box at $0.065 per ounce. Step 1: same unit? Yes, both per ounce. Step 2: write $0.070 and $0.065. Step 3: ones and tenths are 0; hundredths are 7 and 6, and 6 < 7. Step 4: $0.065 < $0.070, so the second box costs less per ounce, even though 0.065 has more digits.
Fixing “add a zero.” 0.7 × 10 is not 0.70. Each digit moves one place left, so the 7 tenths become 7 ones: 0.7 × 10 = 7.
Explain why it works. A good explanation names the place: “5 tenths is more than 1 tenth.” Our price guide will include a short “How to compare” box that uses this kind of sentence.
For each problem, say which strategy you used: line up, money or number line.
Be the teacher. Find and fix each mistake.
Three sample student answers: (a) 3.09 > 3.1; (b) 0.06 is read “six tenths”; (c) 4.5 ÷ 10 = 4.05. Explain each mistake and write the correct answer.
Which tag shows the lower unit price?
Write a 2-sentence “How to compare” tip for families for our price guide.
Mistakes are clues about place value. Next time we look at when and how to round, and why the order of rounding matters.
Exit ticket: explain to Sofia, in two sentences, why 0.5 > 0.125.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 6, mini lesson 11, guided practice 13, exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: the guide’s goals (easy to read, uniform across participating stores and states, benefits for ordering, inventory, WIC and nutrition information) and the ketchup example come from the NIST release. The cereal and shelf tags are sample data.
Likely misconceptions: “longer is larger”; “shorter is larger” (thinking 0.4 > 0.45 because tenths are bigger than hundredths); “add a zero”; reading place names wrong.
Supports: coins and a hundred grid for money strategy. Stretch: write three decimals between 0.29 and 0.3.
Answer guide: (a) 3.09 < 3.1, because 0 tenths < 1 tenth; (b) 0.06 is six hundredths; (c) 4.5 ÷ 10 = 0.45. Open strategy answer: 0.30 vs 0.29, 3 tenths > 2 tenths, or 30 cents > 29 cents. Tip example: “Line up the decimal points and add zeros so the numbers are the same length. Compare digits from the left.”
National Institute of Standards and Technology, New Best Practices Guide Shows Unit Pricing Is a Great Deal · U.S. government work, public domain
NIST wrote its unit pricing guide to make shelf labels easier to read, more useful and easier to understand. It also wants unit pricing to be uniform, which means done the same way in every store and state that takes part.
Why does that matter? A unit price label only helps if a shopper can compare it with another label. If one label gives the price per ounce and another gives the price per pound, the numbers cannot be compared directly. When labels match, shoppers can compare the decimals place by place.
NIST’s ketchup example shows this. The 64-ounce bottle is about 7 cents per ounce and the 38-ounce bottle is about 6 cents per ounce, so the smaller bottle is the better value per ounce.
The page says good unit pricing helps stores too. It can help them order and keep track of what is on their shelves. Labels can also point shoppers to nutrition information and to items that the WIC food program covers.
Source: National Institute of Standards and Technology, New Best Practices Guide Shows Unit Pricing Is a Great Deal (nist.gov)