check classmates’ price cards with estimates and inverse operations and give helpful feedback.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. In our county, people check prices and scales for a living. Read about them. Today we will check each other’s pages the same careful way.
According to the reading, about how many tests do Allegheny County inspectors do each year?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Inspectors trust, but they check. Our guide goes to real families, so every number must be right. Today each team checks other teams’ cards with two tools: an estimate and an inverse operation.
Worked example 1: Nora catches a decimal point. A card says 6 folders at $0.89 cost $53.40. Nora estimates: 6 × $1 = $6. The card’s answer is about 9 times too big. She multiplies: 6 × 89 = 534 hundredths = $5.34. Her note says: “I notice the estimate is about $6. I wonder if the decimal point moved. Try counting decimal places.”
Worked example 2: Theo checks with the inverse. A packing card says 1,152 ÷ 36 = 32. Theo multiplies 36 × 32 = 1,080 + 72 = 1,152, so the card is correct. A unit price card says $9.36 ÷ 4 = $2.34. He checks 4 × 2.34 = 9.36. Correct again, and he says so.
Our critique protocol. Be kind, specific and helpful. Use three stems: I notice… (what you see), I wonder… (a question) and Try… (one next step). Comment on the math and on the criteria: correct, clear, useful and honest.
Check the labels too. Does each card show units? Does it say sample or name a real source and date? Does it say how prices were rounded?
Practice checking before the gallery walk.
Gallery walk. Visit at least two other pages.
For each page you visit, check two numbers with an estimate or an inverse operation. Write one I notice, one I wonder and one Try note for each page.
Back at your own page, list every piece of feedback you received. Circle the two changes you will make first and explain why.
This is a sample story, but it shows the kind of mistake inspectors look for. A shelf tag says a box of crayons costs $2.49. At checkout, the scanner charges $2.94. Someone typed the digits in the wrong order.
The difference is $2.94 − $2.49 = $0.45 on each box. That seems small. But if the store sells 120 boxes before anyone notices, shoppers pay 120 × $0.45 = $54.00 too much.
This is why the county tests checkout scanners, and why shoppers who see a mistake can report it. It is also why our guide shows its work.
Think about it: Why does a small error matter when it happens many times? What habit could a shopper use to catch it?
Checking is not about catching people. It is about getting it right for our families.
Exit ticket: which check works best for a division card, and why?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 7, case study 6, guided practice 10, gallery walk 8, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that feedback means only praise or only error-hunting; that an estimate proves an answer exactly; checking division by dividing again instead of multiplying.
Supports: feedback cards printed with the three stems; pair students for the gallery walk. Stretch: ask students to find an error that an estimate would not catch (for example 6.94 instead of 6.96).
Answer guide: warm-up more than 10,000; Gina: $6.96; 84 × 24 = 2,016; 2.94 − 2.49 = 0.45; 120 × 0.45 = 54.00; 5.20 ÷ 8 = 0.65. For 124 × 144: the estimate 120 × 150 = 18,000, so 1,785 is far too small; the correct product is 17,856. The case study is a sample scenario, not a reported incident.
Allegheny County, PA, Weights and Measures · Allegheny County government web page; retold in our own words with a link to the source
When you buy a gallon of gas or a pound of grapes, how do you know you got the right amount? In Allegheny County, the Bureau of Weights and Measures checks. Its job is to protect shoppers from cheating and from honest mistakes. It also protects business owners.
Inspectors check devices that weigh or measure things that are sold. They test gas pumps across the county. They also test store scales, jewelers’ scales, airport luggage scales, parking meters and the scanners at store checkout counters.
Inspections happen every year. Inspectors also make surprise visits to stores. In all, they do more than 10,000 tests each year, using test equipment approved by the Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture.
A device that passes gets a seal, which tells shoppers it is working properly. A gas pump that fails may get a red sticker or be closed until it is fixed and tested again. Shoppers who think something is wrong can report it to the county.
Source: Allegheny County, PA, Weights and Measures (alleghenycounty.us)