revise our price guide pages using feedback, and translate a pictograph into a bar graph as an extension.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. In 2.22 we read about a spacecraft lost by a units mix-up. Today we read NASA’s own page about it and then fix our pages.
How long did the Mars Climate Orbiter fly before NASA lost contact?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Revision is part of the work. Real designers, bakers and scientists fix their work before others use it. Today you use your feedback list from 2.22.
Revision checklist. Correct: check each number a second way. Clear: every measurement has a unit; every graph has a title, labels and a scale or key. Useful: a shopper can act on it. Honest: sample data says sample.
Worked example 1: Sofia fixes a unit. Sofia’s Trail Mix card said Each bag: 9. Nine what? She weighs a bag again: 9 grams. She writes Each bag: 9 grams. She checks the total line: 6 bags × 9 grams = 54 grams, and her card says 54 grams. Correct and clear.
Worked example 2: Jamal fixes a ruler mistake. Jamal’s bookmark card said 7 1/4 inches. A classmate measured 6 1/4. Jamal sees he lined up the bookmark at the 1, not the 0. Every reading was 1 inch too long. He remeasures from 0: 6 1/4 inches.
Extension: same data, new display. A pictograph with a key of 5 shows Lemonade with 6 cups. That is 6 × 5 = 30 sales. On a bar graph with a scale of 5, the Lemonade bar stops at 30.
Practice fixing before you revise your own page.
Revision time, then the extension.
Revise your team's page. Make at least two changes from your feedback list. Write each change and how you checked it.
Extension: a sample pictograph uses a key of 10. Popcorn 3 pictures, Fruit cups 2 pictures, Granola 5 pictures. Make a table and a bar graph with a scale of 10. How many more Granola than Popcorn?
Write one sentence for our price guide that explains why every measurement has a unit. Use the reading.
A page is ready when someone else can use it without asking you.
Exit ticket: what was your most important revision today, and why?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 6, guided practice 10, revision 14, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: revising only for neatness; drawing a bar at the number of pictures instead of the value; thinking a measurement that starts at 1 is still correct.
Supports: the revision checklist as a strip on each table; sticky notes for each change. Stretch: the extension task.
Answer guide: warm-up about 9 months; add the unit; 54 grams; 6 (6 1/4 inches); 20; true; the sample-labeled page. Extension: Popcorn 30, Fruit cups 20, Granola 50; Granola has 50 − 30 = 20 more. The units sentence should mention that the Mars Climate Orbiter was lost when English and metric units were mixed up.
NASA Science, Mars Climate Orbiter mission page · U.S. government work, public domain
NASA sends spacecraft to study other planets. In 1998 it sent the Mars Climate Orbiter to Mars. A rocket launched it on December 11, 1998, from Cape Canaveral in Florida.
The orbiter’s job was to study Mars from orbit and pass messages from other Mars missions back to Earth. It flew through space for about nine months. Then, on September 23, 1999, NASA lost contact with it.
NASA studied what went wrong. The page says it was a navigation error. Software on the ground used English units. Software on the spacecraft used metric units. Nobody changed one into the other.
Because the units did not match, the math for the spacecraft’s path was wrong. The orbiter flew too close to Mars. The study found that it burned up in the planet’s air.
The numbers were not the problem. The units were. A number only makes sense when everyone knows its unit. That is why we check every unit on our pages before market day.
Source: NASA Science, Mars Climate Orbiter mission page (science.nasa.gov)