complete a scaled bar graph, solve one- and two-step problems with it, and give kind, specific feedback on our price guide pages.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Graphs come in many kinds. Which kind should our Sales Graphs page use? Predict, then read.
We want to compare how many of each item sold. Which kind of graph fits best?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Parts of a bar graph. A title. A label for each bar. A number scale with a label. The scale counts by equal jumps of 1, 2, 5 or 10. Each bar stops at its number.
Between the lines. If the scale counts by 10 and a bar is halfway between 20 and 30, it shows 25.
Worked example 1: Hana’s bar graph. Sample votes for a new store item: Popcorn 30, Fruit cups 25, Granola bars 15, Stickers 40. Hana uses a scale of 5 so every number lands on a line. The Stickers bar stops at 40, and the Granola bars bar stops at 15. She checks each bar against the table.
Worked example 2: Andre’s two-step question. How many more votes did Stickers get than Popcorn and Granola bars together? Step 1: 30 + 15 = 45. Step 2: 45 is more than 40, so Stickers did not get more. Andre rewrites it: how many more votes did Popcorn and Granola bars get together than Stickers? 45 − 40 = 5 more.
Gallery critique. Visit other teams’ pages. Use three stems: I notice…, I wonder… and Try…. Check one number on every page a second way.
Use Hana’s sample vote bar graph (scale of 5).
Make the Sales Graphs bar graph, then do the gallery walk.
Make a bar graph of the practice market sales (Lemonade 24, Trail mix 18, Bookmarks 10, Pencils 6) with a scale of 2. Add a title, labels and a scale label.
Gallery walk: visit two other pages. For each, check one number a second way and write one I notice, one I wonder and one Try note.
Back at your page, list the feedback you received. Circle the two changes you will make first and explain why.
In December 1998, NASA launched the Mars Climate Orbiter. It was supposed to circle Mars and study the planet. On September 23, 1999, NASA lost contact with it.
What went wrong? NASA says the computer on the ground used English units (like feet and pounds), while the spacecraft’s own computer used metric units. Nobody changed one into the other. The numbers looked fine, but they meant different things. The spacecraft flew too close to Mars and burned up in the air around the planet.
That is why our criteria say every measurement needs a unit. A number without its unit can fool even rocket scientists.
Think about it: Look at your team’s page. Is there a number without a unit or a graph without a label? How would that confuse a shopper?
Checking is not about catching people. It is about getting it right for our shoppers.
Exit ticket: what is one question a shopper could answer with our bar graph? Write it and answer it.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 6 minutes, mini lecture 7, case study 6, guided practice 10, gallery walk 9, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: reading a bar between lines as the lower line; assuming a two-step comparison always has a positive answer in the order asked (Andre’s example); thinking feedback means only praise.
Supports: grid paper with the scale pre-numbered; feedback cards with the three stems. Stretch: make the same bar graph with a scale of 10 and explain why 25 and 15 are harder to read.
Answer guide: Stickers; 30 − 15 = 15; 110; 35; true (55 > 40); the I wonder and Try feedback. Pictograph with key 5: Popcorn 6, Fruit cups 5, Granola bars 3, Stickers 8 pictures. Bar graph scale of 2: bars at 24, 18, 10 and 6. The case study facts are from NASA’s Mars Climate Orbiter mission page (launch December 11, 1998; last contact September 23, 1999; English units on the ground, metric on board).
National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) Kids' Zone, When to Use Which Graph · U.S. government work, public domain
The National Center for Education Statistics, or NCES, collects facts about schools. Its Kids’ Zone has a tool for making graphs. One help page explains when to use each kind of graph.
Bar graphs compare different groups. They can also show change over time when the changes are big. A bar graph is a good fit when we want to compare how many cups of lemonade, bags of trail mix and bookmarks we sold.
Line graphs show how something changes over a short or long time. They show small changes better than bar graphs do. A line graph could show how a plant grows week by week.
Pie charts compare the parts of one whole. They do not show change over time.
The page also names area graphs and X-Y plots. Those are for older students and bigger questions, like whether two things change together.
The big idea: pick the graph that answers your question. Our question is which item sold the most, so we will use a bar graph.
Source: National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) Kids' Zone, When to Use Which Graph (nces.ed.gov)