introduce a precise claim that distinguishes itself from alternate claims, and develop a counterclaim fairly with its own supporting evidence before answering it.
Instruction
In English 9 you learned to acknowledge a counterclaim. In English 10 the bar rises: W.9-10.1.b asks you to develop claims and counterclaims fairly, supplying evidence for each, while pointing out the strengths and limitations of both. A counterclaim with no evidence is a straw man. This workshop builds the real thing, and you now have the whole novel, through the creature’s demand for a companion, to draw on.
Step 1 — A precise claim (W.9-10.1.a). “Victor is responsible” is too broad to argue well. Precision comes from naming the mechanism: Victor’s responsibility lies less in creating life than in abandoning it; the novel’s deaths trace to three failures of care — at the creation, at Justine’s trial and, as the unit’s final lessons will show, over the promise of a companion. That claim tells the reader exactly what you will prove and in what order.
Step 2 — Distinguish it from alternate claims. In your introduction, name the other positions and say briefly how yours differs: Some readers blame the creature’s free choices — the planted locket, the declared war on his species; others blame a society that answers difference with violence. This essay argues that both are downstream of Victor’s first abandonment. This shows you know the debate.
Step 3 — Build the counterclaim at full strength. Choose the opposing argument a thoughtful reader would most likely make. Write it as its holder would: with a clear statement and at least one quotation that genuinely supports it. The strongest counterclaim available to you now is the creature’s own admission that rejection, not creation itself, turned him violent — “I was benevolent and good; misery made me a fiend” — paired with his calculated planting of evidence against Justine, which is a free, deliberate act. Quote both.
Step 4 — Answer it, don’t dismiss it. There are three honest ways. Refute: show the evidence is weaker or misread. Concede and outweigh: grant the point, then argue your evidence matters more. Concede and qualify: grant the point and narrow your claim to fit. Qualifying often produces the most convincing essays.
Step 5 — Name strengths and limitations of both. A sentence like “This reading cannot fully account for the deliberate cruelty of planting the locket” does not weaken your essay; it shows the reader you have seen the whole text.
Evidence from all three narrators. Because the essay is about responsibility in a story told by people with stakes, you must use evidence from Walton, Victor and the creature, and at least once comment on how a narrator’s position affects the evidence (RL.9-10.1).
A note on this lesson’s mentor text. The sample counterclaim-and-answer passage below is drawn from Mary Wollstonecraft’s A Vindication of the Rights of Woman, not from Frankenstein — it teaches the move (state, concede, answer) from a writer who does it cleanly, so you can see the structure before applying it to the novel yourself.
📖 Before this lesson, read: Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, Letters 1-4 & Volume I-II complete
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: Mentor passage, model counterclaim and criteria
Mary Wollstonecraft, A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792), Project Gutenberg eBook 3420; retrieved 2026-09-26 · SLS original framing, models and criteria; quoted passage is public domain (Wollstonecraft, 1792)
Read the mentor for the three moves: state, concede, answer.
A mentor: an objection stated at full strength, then answered
I foresee an obvious retort; whilst man remains such an imperfect being as he appears hitherto to have been, he will, more or less, be the slave of his appetites; and those women obtaining most power who gratify a predominant one, the sex is degraded by a physical, if not by a moral necessity. This objection has, I grant, some force; but while such a sublime precept exists, as, “be pure as your heavenly father is pure;” it would seem that the virtues of man are not limited by the Being who alone could limit them;
Annotation. Counterclaim: men are creatures of appetite. Concession: “This objection has, I grant, some force.” Answer (concede-and-outweigh): the objection ignores that human virtue is not limited by appetite.
Criteria for Stage 1 (SLS original)
- Claim: precise (it names a mechanism), contestable, distinguished from two alternate claims.
- Counterclaim: stated fairly, with at least one supporting quotation, in words its holder would sign.
- Answer: refute, concede-and-outweigh or concede-and-qualify; strengths and limitations of both sides named.
- Evidence: at least once each from Walton, Victor and the creature.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
What makes a counterclaim meet W.9-10.1.b?
Naming alternate claims in your introduction weakens your argument.
Submit Stage 1: your precise claim, two alternate claims you distinguish it from, a full counterclaim paragraph with at least one supporting quotation, and your answer to it (refute, concede-and-outweigh, or concede-and-qualify). Include evidence from all three narrators in your plan.
How confident are you that you can write a counterclaim its holder would accept, supported with evidence, and answer it honestly?
Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, Letters 1-4 & Volume I-II complete
Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, Letters 1-4 & Volume I-II complete so far Bridge summary — not the primary text
A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.
Victor creates and abandons his creature, and his silence lets Justine be executed for William’s murder (Vol. I). Forced by the creature to listen at the Montanvert glacier, Victor hears the creature’s own story: rejected everywhere on sight, he found brief hope secretly observing the De Lacey family, learned language and feeling from them, and came to understand his own exclusion through the books he read, including Paradise Lost. Rejected violently by the family he loved and shot by a stranger he saved, he declared war on humanity, murdered William, framed Justine by planting evidence, and now, at the glacier, demands that Victor make him a companion as the price of peace (Vol. II).