take and defend a position on whether Antigone or Creon has the stronger claim, citing the text, and build on classmates’ ideas in a recorded seminar.
Instruction
The German philosopher Hegel argued that Antigone is great tragedy because both sides are right: the family’s duty and the state’s authority are each legitimate, and the tragedy is their collision. You do not have to agree with Hegel — but you do have to take both sides seriously before you choose one. That is what this seminar is for.
Antigone’s case. Some duties are older and higher than any government. The dead must be honored; a sister owes her brother burial whatever he did. A law that commands a person to do evil — or to leave undone a sacred obligation — has no claim on her. She acts openly, accepts the penalty and does not pretend otherwise. Later writers on civil disobedience, including Thoreau in Unit 3, found in her a model.
Creon’s case. Thebes has just survived a civil war in which Polyneices led a foreign army against his own city. A ruler who lets a traitor be honored invites the next attack. Law means nothing if each person decides privately which laws to obey; “disobedience is the worst of evils.” And Creon applies the rule to his own family — Antigone is his niece and his son’s fiancée — which could be read as integrity rather than tyranny.
What complicates both. Antigone is harsh to Ismene, who wants to share her fate, and seems to seek death. Creon’s language slides from the city’s good to his own authority — “Is not the city held to be the ruler’s?” is how he answers Haemon — and he refuses every warning until too late. The play does not hand you an answer; it hands you evidence.
How characters develop (RL.9-10.3). Watch how each character changes — or refuses to change — across the play, and how their encounters with others drive the plot. Creon’s development is a hardening, then a collapse. Antigone’s is steadier, but her final lament shows a fear and grief she hid earlier. A strong seminar claim uses change over time as evidence.
The seminar. Record a 90-second claim: which character has the stronger claim, and why, quoting two passages — one of which makes your position harder to hold. End with a question you genuinely want a classmate to answer. Then reply to two classmates. SL.9-10.1.c asks you to propel the conversation: relate the discussion to broader themes, ask questions that probe reasoning, and bring in voices who have not yet spoken. Before disagreeing, restate the other person’s point in a sentence they would accept.
A rule for this seminar. Every claim is about the text. “I would have buried him too” is a feeling; “Antigone’s appeal to ‘unwritten statutes’ makes her claim independent of Creon’s authority, because…” is an argument.
📖 Before this lesson, read: Antigone, Prologue through the Second Stasimon (lines 1-625)
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: Seminar packet: Antigone, Creon and two outside voices
Sophocles, Antigone, translated by R. C. Jebb (Cambridge University Press; translation first published 1888, text here from the 1917 edition, The Tragedies of Sophocles), Wikisource https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Antigone_%28Jebb%29; Henry David Thoreau, Resistance to Civil Government (1849), Wikisource https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Resistance_to_Civil_Government; Plato, Crito, translated by B. Jowett (1892), Project Gutenberg eBook 1657 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/1657); retrieved 2026-09-26 · SLS original framing, protocol and models; quoted passages are public domain (Sophocles, tr. Jebb, 1888; Thoreau, 1849; Plato, tr. Jowett, 1892)
Every claim you make must point to a passage on this page or in the play.
Thoreau, 1849: conscience over law
I think that we should be men first, and subjects afterward. It is not desirable to cultivate a respect for the law, so much as for the right. The only obligation which I have a right to assume, is to do at any time what I think right.
Socrates in Plato’s Crito (Jowett): the country and the laws come first
Has a philosopher like you failed to discover that our country is more to be valued and higher and holier far than mother or father or any ancestor, and more to be regarded in the eyes of the gods and of men of understanding?
Protocol (SLS original)
- Prepare. Choose your claim in one sentence: “Antigone (or Creon) has the stronger claim because…”
- Two quotations. One supports you. One makes your position harder to hold, and you say how you answer it.
- End with a real question for a classmate, one you cannot answer yourself.
- Record 90 seconds. Then reply to two classmates. Each reply starts by restating their point in a sentence they would accept.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which is the strongest textual evidence that Creon’s motive shifts from the city’s good to his own authority?
In this seminar, “I would have done the same thing as Antigone” counts as a text-based claim.
Draft your 90-second claim: which character has the stronger claim, two quotations (one complicating), and a genuine question for classmates. Paste the draft here before recording.
How confident are you that you can take a position on Antigone and Creon, defend it from the text, and build on others’ ideas?
Antigone, Prologue through the Second Stasimon (lines 1-625)
Antigone, Prologue through the Second Stasimon (lines 1-625) so far Bridge summary — not the primary text
A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.
Antigone defies Creon’s edict and buries Polyneices; the Guard reports the burial, and the Chorus responds with an ode warning that cleverness without justice ruins a city (lines 1-375). Brought before Creon, Antigone confirms what she did and defends it by appeal to the unwritten statutes of the gods, which she holds outrank any mortal’s edict; Ismene, who refused to help in the prologue, now tries to share the blame and the death sentence, but Antigone refuses to let her; Creon condemns them both, and the Chorus reflects on the ancient curse over the house of Oedipus (lines 376-625).