write a 1,000-1,200 word argument about responsibility in Frankenstein that develops claim and counterclaim with evidence from all three narrators, grounded in the complete novel, and defend it orally.
Instruction
This essay is the fullest argument you have written in this course so far: 1,000-1,200 words, a precise claim, a counterclaim with its own evidence, and evidence from all three narrators — now informed by the complete novel, including its final volume.
The question. Who or what bears the greater responsibility for the deaths in Frankenstein — Victor, the creature, the society that rejects the creature, or some combination you define precisely? Your claim must be contestable: a thoughtful classmate should be able to disagree using the same novel.
What the ending adds. You now know how the story resolves: Victor’s destruction of the second creature, Clerval’s and Elizabeth’s murders, and the creature’s final, unanswerable appearance over Victor’s body. A strong essay uses this ending as evidence, not just an ending — ask what the creature’s own final words to Walton, delivered with no one left to contradict him, do to your claim.
Structure. An introduction that states your claim and distinguishes it from alternate claims. Body paragraphs that develop your reasons in a logical order, each opening with a topic sentence that advances the argument. A counterclaim section that states the opposing view at full strength with its evidence and answers it. A conclusion (W.9-10.1.e) that follows from the argument and says what your reading makes visible — about responsibility, creation, or the danger of knowledge without care — rather than repeating your introduction.
Narrators and reliability. Use evidence from Walton, Victor and the creature. At least once, analyze how a narrator’s position affects the evidence: when Victor reports the creature’s words, or when the creature describes his own innocence to Walton with Victor already dead, what might each leave out?
Theme (RL.9-10.2). Your argument should connect to a central idea the novel develops across its full arc — the responsibility of creators, the effects of rejection, the pursuit of knowledge — and show how Shelley develops it from the first creation scene to the last page.
Conventions. Use colons and semicolons purposefully (L.9-10.2.b), cite volume and chapter in MLA from the 1818 text, and spell names correctly.
The defense (SL.9-10.1.d). Record 90 seconds: your claim, your strongest evidence, and how your view changed during drafting. Then record replies to two classmates who argued differently, summarizing their claim and qualifying or justifying your own in response.
Integrity. Frankenstein is one of the most written-about novels in English. Your stages must show your own developing argument; a final that appears from nowhere will be discussed with you.
📖 Before this lesson, read: Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, Letters 1-4 & Volumes I-III complete
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: Key assignment packet: rubric and model
Mary Shelley, Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus (1818 text), Project Gutenberg eBook 41445; retrieved 2026-09-26 · SLS original framing, tables, models and keys; quoted passages are public domain (Shelley, 1818)
Choose your claim before you read the rubric.
Model thesis and outline (SLS original)
Thesis. Victor bears the greater responsibility, not because he made the creature but because at four points — the night of creation, Justine’s trial, the broken promise of a companion, and his silence about the specific threat to Elizabeth — he chose to protect himself over anyone he had made or wronged; the creature’s killings are free choices, but they are choices made inside conditions Victor built and refused to repair.
- Introduction: the question, the alternate claims, the claim.
- Body 1, abandonment: the creation scene and Victor’s word choices.
- Body 2, silence: Justine’s trial and the unnamed threat before the wedding.
- Body 3, the broken promise: Volume III’s destruction of the second creature.
- Counterclaim: the creature’s final confession to Walton; answer by concession and qualification.
- Conclusion: what the complete novel makes visible about making something you will not care for.
Rubric (SLS original, four levels)
| Criterion | 4 Exemplary | 1 Beginning |
|---|---|---|
| Claim (W.9-10.1.a) | Precise and contestable; names a mechanism of responsibility; distinguished from two alternate claims. | No arguable claim. |
| Counterclaim (W.9-10.1.b) | Stated in words its holder would sign, with its own quotation; answered by refutation, concession or qualification. | Absent. |
| Evidence and narrators (RL.9-10.1) | Evidence from Walton, Victor and the creature, drawn from across the whole novel; reliability analyzed at least once. | Little or no quotation. |
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
frame narrative
Tap to revealA story within a story.
connotation
Tap to revealThe associations a word carries.
allusion
Tap to revealA reference to another text or event.
concession
Tap to revealGranting part of an opposing argument.
qualify
Tap to revealRefine a claim to fit the evidence.
Which conclusion best meets W.9-10.1.e?
How confident are you that you can argue a contested claim about a novel with a fully supported counterclaim and evidence from multiple narrators, grounded in its complete arc?
Submit: Responsibility Argument Essay (1,000-1,200 words) + defense and two replies
Task: Argue who or what bears the greater responsibility for the deaths in Frankenstein, with a counterclaim supported by its own evidence and evidence from all three narrators, grounded in the complete novel.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Organizer. Claim, alternate claims, supported counterclaim and answer (from Lesson 2.8).
- Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed draft. A classmate who holds the counterclaim checks that it is stated fairly; submit a revision note.
- Stage 3 — Final essay. 1,000-1,200 words, MLA, volume-and-chapter citations from the 1818 text.
- Stage 4 — Recorded defense and two replies. Live defense in a scheduled session is an equal-credit alternative.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Claim (W.9-10.1.a) | Precise, contestable, distinguished from alternate claims. |
| Counterclaim (W.9-10.1.b) | Stated fairly with its own evidence; answered by refutation, concession or qualification. |
| Evidence and narrators (RL.9-10.1) | Evidence from all three narrators across the full novel; reliability analyzed at least once. |
| Theme (RL.9-10.2) | Argument connected to a central idea and its development across the novel’s complete arc. |
| Conclusion (W.9-10.1.e) | Follows from the argument and states what the reading makes visible. |
| Defense (SL.9-10.1.d) | Replies summarize others’ claims and qualify or justify the writer’s view. |
Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, Letters 1-4 & Volumes I-III complete
Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, Letters 1-4 & Volumes I-III complete so far Bridge summary — not the primary text
A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.
Walton rescues Victor on the Arctic ice and hears his full story: a happy childhood turned to obsession, a creation abandoned in horror, a brother and an innocent servant dead through Victor’s silence, and a creature who, rejected everywhere, learned language and feeling from a family he loved and lost, declared war on humanity, and demanded a companion. Victor’s broken promise to build that companion sets off the novel’s final catastrophe: Clerval’s murder, Elizabeth’s death on her wedding night, Victor’s father’s death from grief, and Victor’s own pursuit of the creature into the Arctic, where he dies aboard Walton’s ship. The creature appears one last time over Victor’s body, confesses his crimes directly to Walton, and vanishes into the ice, his fate left unresolved.