respond thoughtfully to diverse perspectives on who bears responsibility in Frankenstein, summarize points of agreement and disagreement, and qualify my own view in light of the evidence.
Instruction
By the midpoint of the novel, William and Justine are dead, and Victor has watched the creature take control of the story that will decide how we judge both of them. Who is responsible? The novel offers evidence for several answers, and this structured disagreement asks you to argue one while taking the others seriously.
Position 1: Victor. He creates a living being and abandons it within hours, fleeing in horror. He never teaches, names or protects it. When he could prevent Justine’s execution by telling the truth, he stays silent to protect his own credibility. Every death so far follows from his choices to create, abandon and conceal.
Position 2: the creature. Whatever he suffers, the creature’s own account, which you will read in full in the coming lessons, will describe real choices. Even now, before you have heard his side, the planted locket that condemns Justine is already evidence of calculation, not simple accident.
Position 3: society. Everyone the creature has met so far has responded to his appearance with terror or flight, before he has done anything to earn it. William’s death happens amid that same context of universal rejection — a rejection the creature has not chosen.
Most strong answers combine positions, and SL.9-10.1.d asks you to do exactly that kind of thinking: respond to diverse perspectives, summarize where people agree and disagree, and qualify or justify your view in light of the evidence. Qualifying is not weakness. “Victor bears primary responsibility for William’s and Justine’s deaths, but the creature’s calculated choice to plant the locket is a fact the novel does not let us ignore” is a stronger claim than either half alone.
Using nonfiction (RI.9-10.2, RI.9-10.3). The two short readings are not about the novel, but they state positions Shelley knew intimately — her father’s and her mother’s. Determine each text’s central idea, and analyze how the author develops it. Then use them as lenses: how would Godwin judge Victor’s silence at the trial? How would Wollstonecraft, who blamed “neglected education” for human misery, read the creature’s isolation so far?
Information in diverse formats (SL.9-10.2). Before recording, compile a simple chart: each death so far, who caused it directly, what choices led to it, and which narrator reports it. The chart will keep your claim tied to evidence, even though you are arguing from only half the novel.
The disagreement. Record 90 seconds: your position, two quotations, and one qualification. Reply to two classmates who hold different positions. Each reply must begin by summarizing their argument and naming what you agree with, before stating where you differ and why.
📖 Before this lesson, read: Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, Letters 1-4 & Volume I-II, Chapters 1-7 and 1-2
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: Seminar packet: Godwin and Wollstonecraft on character and circumstance
William Godwin, Enquiry Concerning Political Justice, 4th ed. (London: J. Watson, 1843), vol. 1; Mary Wollstonecraft, A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792), Project Gutenberg eBook 3420; retrieved 2026-09-26 · SLS original framing; quoted passages are public domain (Godwin, 1798/1843; Wollstonecraft, 1792)
Neither passage is about the novel. Decide how each would judge Victor so far.
first, that the actions and dispositions of mankind are the offspring of circumstances and events, and not of any original determination that they bring into the world
— William Godwin, Enquiry Concerning Political Justice, Book I, Ch. IV
I have turned over various books written on the subject of education, and patiently observed the conduct of parents and the management of schools; but what has been the result? a profound conviction, that the neglected education of my fellow creatures is the grand source of the misery I deplore
— Mary Wollstonecraft, A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792), Introduction
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which reply best meets SL.9-10.1.d?
Godwin’s central idea is that people’s actions are determined mainly by circumstances rather than inborn nature.
Complete a responsibility chart for William’s and Justine’s deaths (direct cause, prior choices, narrator). Then draft your 90-second position with two quotations and one qualification, and name how Godwin or Wollstonecraft would judge your position.
How confident are you that you can respond to opposing views fairly and qualify my own claim with evidence?
Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, Letters 1-4 & Volume I-II, Chapters 1-7 and 1-2
Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, Letters 1-4 & Volume I-II, Chapters 1-7 and 1-2 so far Bridge summary — not the primary text
A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.
Walton rescues Victor on the Arctic ice; Victor recounts his happy childhood, his growing obsession with the secret of life, and the creation itself, which fills him with such horror that he abandons his creature within hours and falls dangerously ill (Letters 1-4; Vol. I, Ch. 1-5). Months later, Victor’s young brother William is murdered, and Victor glimpses the creature near the scene and knows at once who is responsible, but says nothing; the family’s servant Justine is wrongly convicted on planted evidence and executed, while Victor’s guilt-ridden silence protects only himself (Vol. I, Ch. 6-7). Wandering alone in the Alps, Victor is confronted directly by the creature at the Montanvert glacier, who insists that Victor, as his maker, owes him a hearing before judgment (Vol. II, Ch. 1-2).