
use Newton’s law of universal gravitation to calculate forces and field strengths, and argue from independent data that the same inverse-square force explains an apple’s fall, the ISS orbit and the Moon’s orbit.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. An apple falls from a tree. The Moon does not fall to Earth. Newton claimed one force explains both. Write the strongest objection you can think of to that claim.
You double your distance from Earth's center. Earth's gravitational force on you becomes…
The claim. Newton proposed that the force pulling an apple to the ground and the force holding the Moon in its orbit are the same force, and that it weakens with the square of distance. Today you build and defend that argument with numbers Newton could not measure as precisely as you can.
Newton’s law of universal gravitation. Every two masses attract with a force
F = Gm1m2/r2, G = 6.674 × 10−11 N·m2/kg2 (NIST CODATA)
where r is the distance between their centers. Written as a signed force along the line joining the objects, Fg = −Gm1m2/r2: the minus sign means the force points toward the other object. Because masses are always positive, gravity always attracts.
Worked example 1: three forces. A 60 kg student standing on Earth feels F = GMEm/RE2 = 589 N, which is just their weight. Two students of 60 kg and 70 kg sitting 1.0 m apart attract each other with 2.80 × 10−7 N, far too small to notice; gravity is noticeable only when at least one mass is planet-sized. Earth and the Moon attract with 1.98 × 1020 N.
Gravitational field. Dividing the force by the small mass gives the field strength g = GM/r2, in N/kg (the same as m/s2). At Earth’s surface it is 9.82 N/kg, matching your pendulum. It falls off with distance:
At the ISS (6,791 km from Earth’s center) g = 8.64 N/kg, about 88% of the surface value. That matches the centripetal acceleration you computed from the station’s period in 4.01, 8.63 m/s2. Gravity is exactly what makes the station go around. A 70 kg astronaut there still weighs 605 N (versus 687 N on the ground); “weightlessness” is free fall.
Worked example 2: Newton’s Moon test. The Moon is 3.84 × 108 m from Earth’s center, 60.3 Earth radii. If gravity weakens as 1/r2, the Moon’s acceleration should be g/60.32 = 9.82/3,640 = 2.70 × 10−3 m/s2. Now measure it independently from the Moon’s motion: its sidereal period is 27.32 days = 2,360,448 s, so its centripetal acceleration is 4π2r/T2 = 2.72 × 10−3 m/s2. The two agree within 1.0%. An apple and the Moon obey the same law. (Earth and Moon data: NASA planetary fact sheets.)
Evaluating alternatives. A good argument rules out competitors. If gravity weakened as 1/r instead, the Moon’s acceleration would be g/60.3 = 0.163 m/s2, about 60 times the observed value. If it did not weaken at all, the Moon would need a period of only 2π√(r/g) = 10.9 hours. Only the inverse square fits.
Misconceptions to argue against. (1) “There is no gravity in space.” It extends indefinitely, weakening with distance. (2) “The Moon pulls on Earth less than Earth pulls on the Moon.” Newton’s third law: the forces are equal; the Moon’s acceleration is larger because its mass is smaller. (3) “Double the distance, half the force.” It is a quarter.
Argument structure. Claim / Evidence (at least three independent numbers: pendulum g, ISS, Moon) / Reasoning (inverse-square law, gravity as the centripetal force) / Rebuttal (show numerically why 1/r and “no weakening” fail).
Build the evidence for your argument.
Apply the law to the project.
Calculate Earth's gravitational field at 700 km altitude and at 35,786 km altitude, and the force on a 500 kg fire-watch satellite at each. Explain in two sentences why the higher satellite still needs gravity to stay in orbit.
One law reaches from an apple to the Moon. Next, we turn it into an orbit model we can use for the client.
Exit ticket: the Moon is 60.3 Earth radii away. Show with one calculation why its acceleration supports an inverse-square law and rules out a 1/r law.
How confident are you that you can I can use Newton's law of gravitation to calculate forces and fields and argue from data for the inverse-square law.
Materials: calculators, devices for the PhET sim, argument organizers, the class pendulum results from 4.03.
Setup: Earth, Moon and ISS values are from NASA fact sheets and are rounded; G is the CODATA value.
Listen for: “half the force at twice the distance”; “no gravity in space”; measuring r from Earth’s surface instead of its center.
Support / stretch: provide the Moon test as a fill-in template. Stretch: repeat the Moon test with the Moon’s actual mean distance and period from a NASA fact sheet and report the percent agreement.
Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapter 6.