
Protect the Rider: A Better Helmet Liner
How should a helmet liner be designed, and from what material, so that it keeps the force on a rider’s head as low as possible in a fall?
The mystery: Many communities require young riders to wear a helmet, and every new car carries crumple zones and airbags: how can a few centimeters of white foam make the difference when a head meets the pavement? Client: a community bike-share program’s youth-safety team.
calculate momentum and impulse, read impulse as the area under a force-time graph, and explain why a longer stopping time means a smaller average force.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. A bike helmet’s liner is only a few centimeters of white foam. Write one sentence: how can so little material protect a head that hits the pavement? Keep your answer; you will revise it by the end of the unit.
The same egg is dropped from the same height onto a tile floor and onto a folded towel. Compare the change in momentum of the egg in the two cases.
The phenomenon. Many states and cities require young riders of bicycles, scooters and skateboards to wear a properly fitted and fastened helmet that meets a federal safety standard, and every new car carries crumple zones and airbags for the same physical reason. A helmet is a few centimeters of foam. How can so little material turn a skull fracture into a headache? The answer is a single idea: impulse.
Momentum. An object’s momentum is its mass times its velocity: p = mv. It is a vector, so its direction is the direction of motion, and its unit is kg·m/s. A 1,500 kg car at 2 m/s and a 60 kg sprinter at 50 m/s would have the same momentum, 3,000 kg·m/s, but no sprinter runs 50 m/s; that is why a slow car is still dangerous.
From Newton’s second law to impulse. Write Newton’s second law with acceleration as a change in velocity: Fnet = ma = mΔv/Δt. Multiply both sides by Δt:
FnetΔt = mΔv = Δp
The left side is the impulse J, measured in N·s (the same unit as kg·m/s). To stop a moving head, the ground or the helmet must deliver an impulse equal to the head’s whole momentum. That number is fixed by the mass and the speed. What we can choose is how long the stop takes. Stretch Δt, and the average force F = Δp/Δt shrinks in proportion.
Worked example 1: a head hitting pavement. Take a 5.0 kg head (illustrative; an adult head is roughly this mass) moving at 6.0 m/s, about the speed reached after falling 1.84 m. Its momentum is 5.0 × 6.0 = 30 kg·m/s, so stopping it needs an impulse of 30 N·s.
Six times the stopping time gives one-sixth the average force. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission bicycle-helmet standard (16 CFR 1203) fails a helmet if the peak acceleration of the test headform exceeds 300 g. At constant deceleration, staying under 300 g = 2,940 m/s2 from 6.0 m/s needs at least 6.0 / 2,940 = 2.04 ms and 6.1 mm of stopping distance. Real forces are not constant, so the peak sits above the average, which is why liners are thicker than this minimum.
Force-time graphs. A real impact force rises and falls. On a force-time graph, the area under the curve is the impulse. The two pulses below enclose the same area, 30 N·s. Without a helmet the pulse is a tall spike: a triangle 1 ms wide must peak at 2 × 30 / 0.001 = 60,000 N. With the helmet the triangle is 6 ms wide and peaks at 10,000 N.
Worked example 2: airbags do the same thing. A 70 kg occupant in a car moving at 13.4 m/s (30 mph) has 938 kg·m/s of momentum. Belt and airbag stretching the stop to 0.12 s give an average force of 7,817 N, about 11.4 times body weight, spread over the chest and face. Hitting the dashboard in 0.012 s gives 78,167 N, ten times more, on a small area (stopping times illustrative).
Common misconceptions. (1) “The helmet reduces the momentum change.” No: the head still goes from 6.0 m/s to zero. The helmet reduces the force by stretching the time. (2) “A bouncy helmet would be better.” A bounce reverses the velocity, so Δp is larger, not smaller. Good liners crush instead of springing back. (3) “Force and momentum are the same thing.” Momentum is what an object has; force is the rate at which momentum changes.
Driving question for the unit. How should a helmet liner be designed, and from what material, so that it keeps the force on a rider’s head as low as possible in a fall?
Work with a partner. Write the momentum before and after for every problem before you compute a force.
Start your Design Notebook for the unit.
Sketch a force-time graph for a bare head and a helmeted head that both stop from 30 kg·m/s. Label the stopping times, the peak forces and the equal areas. Then explain in two or three sentences why the helmeted pulse must be lower if it is wider.
Impulse explains why stopping slowly is safer. Next lesson, we meet our client and launch the helmet-liner project.
Exit ticket: a 0.45 kg soccer ball moving at 20 m/s is stopped by a goalkeeper's hands in 0.050 s. Find the ball's momentum, the impulse and the average force. Then explain how the keeper could make the force smaller.
How confident are you that you can I can use impulse = FΔt = Δp and a force-time graph to explain why a helmet reduces the force on a rider's head.
Materials: mini whiteboards, a bike helmet with its EPS liner visible (a cut-away or retired helmet is ideal), calculators.
Setup: post each student’s Do Now sentence on the Wonder Board; 3.06 and 3.10 return to them. The head mass and stopping times are illustrative.
Listen for: “the helmet absorbs momentum”; force and momentum used as synonyms; forgetting that a bounce doubles-up the momentum change.
Sensitivity: some students may know someone hurt in a bike or car crash. Keep the focus on design and prevention, and let students pass on personal stories.
Support / stretch: give a two-column “before / after” momentum template. Stretch: find the minimum liner crush distance that keeps a 6.0 m/s head under 150 g at constant deceleration.
Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapter 8; OpenStax College Physics 2e, chapter 8.