
revise the runaway-truck model into one force explanation, support it with data from the unit, and brainstorm escape-ramp concepts for each sub-problem.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look at your first explanation of the runaway truck from 2.01. Cross out one idea that the labs have shown is wrong or incomplete, and write what replaces it.
On a downgrade, a 10,000 kg truck and a 30,000 kg truck coast with no braking or drag. Which is true?
Revising the model. In 2.01 most teams wrote something like “the truck is heavy, so it goes fast.” The labs replace that with a force model in three parts:
Worked example 1: evidence for each link. Jamal’s team builds a table: a ∝ Fnet (cart lab slope, r2 = 0.9985); a smaller a for a larger mass at the same pull (cart extension); friction ∝ FN (friction lab slope 0.32, area effect smaller than the spread); a = g sin θ on a slope (Unit 1 ramp, within 7%). Every arrow in their model now points to data.
Worked example 2: a quantitative check. A loaded truck of 36,300 kg on a 5% gravel upgrade with μ = 0.25 (illustrative): the backward forces are mg sin 2.86° = 17,770 N and μmg cos 2.86° = 88,830 N, together 106,600 N. Then a = 106,600/36,300 = 2.94 m/s2, the same as g(sin θ + μ cos θ). The model and Newton’s second law agree exactly, which is a good sign we set up the forces correctly.
CER sentence starters. I claim … / Evidence from the cart and friction labs shows … / This happens because Fnet = ma … / A limit of this model is …
Ideate: ramp concepts for the client. Real escape ramps come in a few broad types. A gravity ramp is a long, steep paved or packed upgrade that relies mostly on the slope; its weakness is that a stopped truck can roll back. An ascending arrester bed combines an upgrade with deep loose gravel. A level or sand-pile bed relies mostly on the loose material. Some sites add steel-net arresting barriers at the end of a bed. Brainstorm at least one solution for each sub-problem (design speed, deceleration, length, site), then link them: the deceleration you choose sets the length, and the length must fit the site.
Revise the model with your team.
Ideate for the client.
For each of the four sub-problems, list at least two possible solutions. Then draw arrows that show how the solutions connect (for example, a steeper grade shortens the length, which helps the site fit). Circle the three ramp concepts your team will compare in the Build phase.
Model revised and ideas on the board. Next: prototype, test and choose.
Exit ticket: explain how solving the “deceleration” sub-problem changes the “length” and “site” sub-problems.
Materials: chart paper, the class data from 2.03 and 2.04, sticky notes for the brainstorm.
Setup: post the original 2.01 explanations so students can see the revision. All truck numbers are illustrative.
Listen for: “heavier trucks need longer ramps” (not in this model, though heavier trucks may sink deeper in reality); forgetting that the weight component reverses direction on the upgrade.
Support / stretch: give a three-box model organizer (runaway, gravel, upgrade). Stretch: add air drag qualitatively and explain why it cannot stop a runaway on its own.