
brainstorm at least three cooler designs grounded in particle and energy science and check each against our criteria and constraints.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at our design brief and the class system map. Circle the one criterion you think will be hardest to meet. Then make a prediction.
Which idea uses the most science we have learned?
Ideate means many ideas first. Engineers generate lots of ideas before judging them. Today you sketch quietly, then build on teammates’ ideas with “Yes, and…” Every idea must name the science that makes it work.
Science menu.
Worked example 1: a science-grounded idea. Malik’s team sketched a box inside a box with crumpled bubble wrap between the walls. They added a foil outer skin and two frozen water bottles. Their notes: “Trapped air slows energy in. Foil reflects sunlight. Melting ice absorbs what gets through, and the bottles do not leak.”
Worked example 2: checking an idea against the brief. Ava suggested a giant bag of loose ice. It might keep food cold, but it would leak on the bus and weigh far more than 5 kg. It fails two constraints. Her team kept the science, melting ice, but switched to sealed frozen bottles.
| Idea | Sketch | Science it uses | Criteria it should meet | Constraints it might break | Effects on people or environment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Idea 1 | |||||
| Idea 2 | |||||
| Idea 3 |
Not yet! Do not pick a winner today. In the Build phase, we compare these ideas fairly, prototype and test them.
Warm up your thinking with these cards, then sketch your ideas.
Complete the idea table for your team.
Sketch three different cooler ideas. For each one, name the science it uses, the criteria it should meet, any constraint it might break and one effect on people or the environment.
How confident are you that you can I can generate design ideas grounded in science and check them against criteria and constraints.
We have a science-backed idea bank. Next, the Build phase: compare our ideas fairly, build a prototype and test it. First, a 3DX field trip into an ice cube.
Exit ticket: pick your strongest idea. Explain how it meets two criteria and stays within two constraints, using particle or energy science.
Materials: the class design brief and system map, idea table, sticky notes, sketch paper, sample materials to handle (foam, bubble wrap, cloth, foil, cardboard, plastic bottles).
Setup: run a 5-minute silent sketch, then a 6-minute “Yes, and” round. Teams keep all three ideas; part 2 compares them systematically (MS-ETS1-2).
Listen for: ideas with no science named; ideas using dry ice, salt baths that would leak, or electricity. Redirect to the brief. Salted ice packs can get colder than 0°C; accept as a stretch idea if sealed, but keep the focus on insulation and melting.
Support / stretch: give a menu of cooler parts with the science each uses. Stretch: add a feature for a student with a food allergy whose lunch must stay separate.