
grow duckweed populations under two nutrient levels, count them over three weeks, and fit exponential and logistic models to explain how resources set carrying capacity.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A cup holds 10 duckweed fronds. Each frond buds a new one about every three days. Predict the count on day 21 if nothing limits them, and explain why the real count will be lower.
Two cups start with 10 fronds. One gets four times as much fertilizer. After three weeks, what do you predict?
Why duckweed? Duckweed (Lemna) is a tiny floating flowering plant found on ponds and slow ditches in many parts of the world. Each plant is a few oval fronds, and it reproduces mostly by budding new fronds, so a population can double in a few days under good conditions. That makes it ideal for watching a population grow and hit a limit within a school unit.
Designing the experiment. You start several cups with the same number of fronds (10) and vary one factor: the nutrient level. High-nutrient cups get a small, measured dose of houseplant fertilizer; low-nutrient cups get a quarter of that dose. Everything else stays the same: cup size, water volume, light, temperature and the starting number of fronds. Frond count is the dependent variable. Replicates (three cups per treatment) show how much variation is due to chance.
Lab procedure.
| Day | High 1 | High 2 | High 3 | High mean | Low 1 | Low 2 | Low 3 | Low mean | Temp (°C) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 10 | 10 | 10 | 10 | 10 | 10 | 10 | 10 | |
| 3 | |||||||||
| … | |||||||||
| 21 |
What to expect (illustrative data). A class ran this experiment and averaged three cups per treatment. High-nutrient cups: 10 fronds on day 0, 21 on day 3, 42 on day 6, 76 on day 9, 120 on day 12, 159 on day 15, 183 on day 18 and 194 on day 21. Low-nutrient cups: 10, 20, 35, 52, 67, 75, 78 and 79. Both start the same way, nearly doubling in the first three days, but the low-nutrient cups level off much earlier. The plateaus, about 200 and about 80, estimate each cup’s carrying capacity.
Worked example 1: reading growth rates. In the high-nutrient cups the population added about (21 − 10) ÷ 3 ≈ 3.7 fronds per day at first and (183 − 159) ÷ 3 = 8 fronds per day between days 15 and 18. More fronds were added per day later, but the per-capita rate fell: 3.7 per day shared among about 15 fronds is about 0.24 per frond per day; 8 per day among about 170 is about 0.05. A falling per-capita rate as density rises is the signature of logistic growth.
Worked example 2: fitting a model. Plot the data and try N = N0ert on the first week only; then try a logistic model with a K you estimate from the plateau. The illustrative curves were produced by a logistic model with r = 0.3 per day and K = 200 or 80. A spreadsheet lets you adjust r and K until the model runs through your points.
What limits a cup of duckweed? Nutrients are one factor. The water surface is another: fronds float, so once the surface is covered, new fronds shade and crowd each other. Your conclusion should consider which factor was limiting in each treatment and how you could test it, for example with wider cups.
No duckweed? Use the illustrative class data above to graph both populations and fit the models.
Use the illustrative class data or your own counts.
Lab analysis (in your Herd Notebook).
Estimate the carrying capacity for each treatment and explain how nutrient level changed it. Cite at least three counts, and calculate the per-capita growth rate in the first and last three days for the high-nutrient cups.
Write a claim-evidence-reasoning conclusion: how do resources set carrying capacity? Then identify two sources of error (for example, miscounting overlapping fronds) and how each would affect your estimate of K.
A cup of pond plants behaves like the elk herd on a very fast clock. Next: where does the energy in an ecosystem go?
Exit ticket: how does the duckweed result help explain why the elk herd fell during the drought? Use the term carrying capacity.
How confident are you that you can measure population growth and use the data to estimate and explain carrying capacity?
Timing: set-up fills one 50-minute period; counts take about 5 minutes, three times a week, during the next lessons; the analysis is a second 50-minute period three weeks later. Start the cups on day one of the unit.
Materials: duckweed from an aquarium store or biological supplier, six identical clear cups (about 250 mL), aged or dechlorinated water, liquid houseplant fertilizer, 1 mL droppers or syringes, a bright window or a lamp on a timer, thermometers, hand lenses, goggles.
Listen for: confusing the number added per day with the per-capita rate; assuming nutrients are the only limit.
Support / stretch: provide a spreadsheet with a logistic column already built so students only adjust r and K. Stretch: plot ln N for the first week and compare its slope with the logistic r.