compare deals by unit price, by a common quantity and by a ratio table, and explain why the three strategies always agree.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at our puzzle: 24 bottles for $5.99 or 12 bottles for $3.19. Aaliyah priced 24 bottles both ways. Marcus found the price of one bottle. Which way do you like better, and why?
If Aaliyah and Marcus both work carefully, can they pick different winners?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Three strategies. To compare two deals we must compare the same amount. Strategy A, unit price: find the price of 1 unit of each. Strategy B, common quantity: scale both deals to the same amount, often a common multiple. Strategy C, ratio table: build a table for each deal and look for a matching row.
Worked example 1: the ketchup with unit prices. Elena checks NIST’s numbers to the thousandth of a dollar. Step 1: 64 ounces for $4.49: 4.49 ÷ 64 ≈ 0.070, so about $0.070 per ounce. Step 2: 38 ounces for $2.29: 2.29 ÷ 38 ≈ 0.060, so about $0.060 per ounce. Step 3: 7 cents > 6 cents, so the 38-ounce bottle is the better deal, as NIST said.
Worked example 2: a common quantity. Jordan compares sample juice: 8 ounces for $2.40 or 12 ounces for $3.30. Step 1: the least common multiple of 8 and 12 is 24, from Unit 1. Step 2: 24 ounces is 3 small bottles: 3 × $2.40 = $7.20. Step 3: 24 ounces is 2 large bottles: 2 × $3.30 = $6.60. Step 4: $6.60 < $7.20, so the 12-ounce bottle is the better deal. Check with Strategy A: $2.40 ÷ 8 = $0.30 and $3.30 ÷ 12 = $0.275 per ounce.
Strategy C in a picture. Jordan’s tables: small bottles (8, $2.40), (16, $4.80), (24, $7.20); large bottles (12, $3.30), (24, $6.60). The tables meet at 24 ounces, which is Strategy B shown as a table.
Why they agree. Every strategy compares equal amounts. If one bottle costs less per ounce, it also costs less for 24 ounces, because 24 ounces is just 24 groups of 1 ounce.
Choosing a strategy. Use a common quantity when the sizes have an easy common multiple. Use unit prices when they do not, or when you compare more than two items. Our report can show families both.
Solve each one with two strategies and check that they agree.
Use two strategies for each problem.
Sample: 4 pounds of apples for $5.96 or 6 pounds for $8.70. Which is the better deal? Use a unit price and a common quantity.
Sample: 3 notebooks cost $2.85. One notebook costs $ (use a leading zero and two decimal places).
Write a short how-to box for our Smart Shopper report called “Three Ways to Spot the Better Deal.” Include one example.
Fair comparisons use the same amount. Next we hunt for common ratio mistakes and learn how to fix them.
Exit ticket: solve the 24-pack puzzle with a ratio table. At which row do the two tables meet?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 6, mini lesson 10, guided practice 14, exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: SP 1181, the two-year collaboration, ketchup prices, retailer benefits, nutrition notes, store-brand sales and the hope for drugstores and auto parts stores are from the NIST release. 4.49 ÷ 64 = 0.07015… and 2.29 ÷ 38 = 0.06026…. Juice, muffin, sticker, apple and notebook prices are sample data.
Likely misconceptions: choosing a common quantity that is not a multiple of both sizes; rounding unit prices so early that close deals look equal.
Supports: a three-column organizer (A, B, C). Stretch: compare three sizes at once.
Answer guide: apples $1.49/lb vs $1.45/lb; common 12 lb: 3 × 5.96 = $17.88 vs 2 × 8.70 = $17.40, so the 6-pound bag. Exit ticket: 24-pack row (24, $5.99) vs 12-pack rows (12, $3.19), (24, $6.38); they meet at 24 bottles. For 64 vs 38 ounces, unit prices are easier because the LCM (1,216) is large.
National Institute of Standards and Technology, New Best Practices Guide Shows Unit Pricing Is a Great Deal · U.S. government work, public domain
NIST’s unit pricing guide is called Special Publication 1181. It came from two years of work by industry groups, consumer groups and researchers, who studied what makes a shelf label easy to read.
The guide says unit prices help shoppers compare packages of different sizes. In the NIST example, a 64-ounce bottle of ketchup for $4.49 cost about 7 cents per ounce, and a 38-ounce bottle for $2.29 cost about 6 cents per ounce.
Unit prices help stores too. NIST says they can improve ordering, keeping track of what is on the shelves, and pricing accuracy. A shelf label can often replace a price sticker on every item, which saves money. Labels can also point out things like low-sodium or high-fiber foods.
Research in the guide found that unit price labels increase sales of store-brand items. A NIST researcher said he hoped more kinds of stores, such as drugstores and auto parts stores, would start using them.
Source: National Institute of Standards and Technology, New Best Practices Guide Shows Unit Pricing Is a Great Deal (nist.gov)