find and fix common mistakes in adding, comparing and multiplying fractions, and explain each fix with a model or a measurement.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A sample draft page for our Recipe Book says: “Two batches need 1/4 cup + 1/4 cup = 2/8 cup of honey.” Something is wrong. Find it before you read on.
What is the mistake on the draft page?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Mistakes are clues. Every cook and every mathematician makes mistakes. A good Recipe Book team finds them before families do. Today we study five common fraction mistakes and how to fix each one.
Fix-it 1: adding the denominators. The draft said 1/4 + 1/4 = 2/8. Use the NIST numbers: 1/4 cup is about 60 mL, and 60 + 60 = 120 mL, which is 1/2 cup. But 2/8 cup is 2 fluid ounces, about 60 mL. A sum cannot be the same as one of its parts! The fix: keep the denominator. 1/4 + 1/4 = 2/4.
Fix-it 2: a bigger denominator means a bigger piece. Some people think 1/8 cup is more than 1/4 cup because 8 is more than 4. The table proves it is not: 1/8 cup is 1 fluid ounce, about 30 mL, and 1/4 cup is about 60 mL. More pieces in the whole means smaller pieces.
Fix-it 3 (worked example 1): multiplying the denominator. Ella’s draft says 3 batches need 3 × 1/4 = 3/12 cup of oil. Step 1: she spots the error: the 3 was multiplied by the numerator and the denominator. Step 2: she tests it: 3/12 is equivalent to 1/4, so 3 batches would get the same oil as 1 batch. That cannot be right. Step 3: the fix: 3 × 1/4 = 1/4 + 1/4 + 1/4 = 3/4 cup.
Fix-it 4 (worked example 2): subtracting the denominators. Sam’s draft says 2 3/4 − 1 1/4 = 1 2/0. Step 1: he subtracted the denominators: 4 − 4 = 0. Step 2: a denominator of 0 means the whole has 0 pieces, which makes no sense. Step 3: the fix: keep fourths. 3/4 − 1/4 = 2/4, so the answer is 1 2/4.
Fix-it 5: “each is missing one piece, so they are equal.” 5/6 and 7/8 each miss one piece of a whole, but the pieces are different sizes. 5/6 misses 1/6, and 7/8 misses only 1/8. So 7/8 > 5/6.
A checking habit. After every answer, ask: does it make sense? Doubling should give more. Taking away should give less. A denominator should never be 0.
For each draft, find the mistake, fix it, and say how you know.
Be a fraction editor.
Find the mistake and fix it: “4 × 2/5 = 8/20.” Explain why the draft answer cannot be right.
Which draft answer is correct?
Make up your own fraction mistake for a partner to fix. Write the correct answer on the back.
We can catch and fix fraction mistakes. Next we explain why our multiplication shortcut always works.
Exit ticket: Which mistake today do you think is the easiest to make? Write the mistake, the fix and a way to check.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 6, mini lesson 12, guided practice 12, exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: NIST values (opened 2026-11-20): pint = 2 cups = 16 fl oz; quart = 4 cups = 32 fl oz; 1/2 gallon = 8 cups = 64 fl oz; gallon = 4 quarts = 16 cups = 128 fl oz; pint about 480 mL; cup about 240 mL; fl oz about 30 mL. Drafts are sample. Each wrong answer was re-derived from its stated error: adding denominators gives 2/8 and 5/12 and 3 5/16; multiplying both numbers gives 3/12 (and 8/20 for 4 × 2/5); subtracting denominators gives 1 2/0. Correct answers checked: 1/4 + 1/4 = 2/4; 2/6 + 3/6 = 5/6; 3 × 1/4 = 3/4; 2 3/4 − 1 1/4 = 1 2/4; 7/8 > 5/6; 4 × 2/5 = 8/5; 1 3/8 + 2 2/8 = 3 5/8.
Likely misconceptions: the five fix-its above, plus thinking a draft is right because it “looks like” the method.
Supports: an error-analysis frame: The mistake is… The fix is… I know because… Stretch: explain why 8/20 is equivalent to 2/5.
Answer guide: 4 × 2/5: the draft multiplied the denominator too; 8/20 equals 2/5, which is one group, not four; correct answer 8/5. Honey note: keep the denominator; 60 mL + 60 mL = 120 mL = 1/2 cup = 2/4 cup.
National Institute of Standards and Technology, Metric Kitchen: Cooking Measurement Equivalencies · U.S. government work, public domain
NIST’s cooking table does more than match small spoons and cups. It also shows how big kitchen units are built from smaller ones.
A pint is 2 cups, or 16 fluid ounces. A quart is 4 cups, or 32 fluid ounces. Half a gallon is 8 cups, or 64 fluid ounces. A whole gallon is 4 quarts, which is 16 cups or 128 fluid ounces.
Each unit also has a metric match. One cup is about 240 mL, one fluid ounce is about 30 mL, and a pint is about 480 mL. NIST says all of these are approximate.
The table helps cooks check their work. If you change a recipe and get an amount that seems too small or too big, you can turn it into fluid ounces or milliliters and see if it makes sense.
Source: National Institute of Standards and Technology, Metric Kitchen: Cooking Measurement Equivalencies (nist.gov)