find and fix common mistakes when comparing and rounding big numbers, and explain the correct method.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Gus rounded 396,700 to the nearest ten thousand and got 390,000. He said, “The 9 cannot go up, so I kept it.” What do you think?
What is 396,700 rounded to the nearest ten thousand?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Mistakes are clues. Every wrong answer tells us which step went wrong. Today we play math detective with four common mistakes.
Mistake 1: comparing without lining up. A sample tally shows Week 1 with 9,870 cans and Week 2 with 10,200 cans. Ruby first said Week 1 was greater because 9 > 1. Fix: line up the places. 10,200 has a ten thousands digit and 9,870 does not. So 10,200 > 9,870.
Mistake 2: chopping instead of rounding (worked example 1). Dev rounds 247,650 to the nearest thousand and writes 247,000. He just changed the last three digits to zeros. Fix: Step 1: the neighbors are 247,000 and 248,000. Step 2: halfway is 247,500. Step 3: 247,650 is past halfway. Step 4: it rounds to 248,000.
Mistake 3: forgetting the zeros. Lucia rounds 238,855 to the nearest thousand and writes 239,855. She changed the thousands digit but kept the other digits. Fix: every digit to the right of the rounding place becomes 0: 239,000.
Mistake 4: the stuck 9 (worked example 2). Gus rounds 396,700 to the nearest ten thousand. Step 1: the neighbors are 390,000 and 400,000. Step 2: halfway is 395,000. Step 3: 396,700 is past halfway, so it rounds up. Step 4: 39 ten thousands plus 1 more ten thousand is 40 ten thousands, so the answer is 400,000. Gus kept the 9 and wrote 390,000, which is the wrong neighbor.
Our checking routine. (1) Name the two neighbors. (2) Name the halfway point. (3) Choose the closer neighbor. (4) Read your answer: does it end in zeros after the rounding place?
For each item, name the mistake or the correct answer, and use the checking routine.
Sample data: a district food drive’s weekly can counts.
Sample: Week 1, 9,870 cans; Week 2, 10,200 cans; Week 3, 10,020 cans. Put the weeks in order from least to greatest and round each to the nearest thousand.
Which number rounds to 750,000 when rounded to the nearest ten thousand?
Make up your own rounding mistake, like one of today's four. Trade with a partner and fix each other's.
We can catch and fix the four common mistakes. Next we fix mistakes with factors and prime numbers.
Exit ticket: round 599,500 to the nearest thousand. Explain what happens to the 9s.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 7, mini lesson 12, guided practice 11, independent and exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: the definitions, the 2023-2024 comparison (not statistically significant), the higher rate than 2016-2021, 751,000 children and the 2022-2024 state averages are from the USDA ERS page. We leave out the percentages and the totals in millions, which are beyond grade 4. Weekly counts are sample data.
Re-derived errors: chopping 247,650 gives 247,000; keeping digits gives 239,855; keeping the 9 in 396,700 gives 390,000; comparing first digits gives 9,870 > 10,200. Each wrong answer follows from the error described.
Supports: printed checking routine card. Stretch: what is the greatest whole number that rounds to 400,000 at the nearest ten thousand? (404,999.)
Answer guide: 9,870 < 10,020 < 10,200; rounded: 10,000, 10,000 and 10,000 (all three round to 10,000, a good talking point: rounding can hide differences). Exit ticket: 599,500 is halfway between 599,000 and 600,000, so it rounds up to 600,000; the 9s become 0s as 599 thousands becomes 600 thousands.
USDA Economic Research Service, Food Security in the U.S.: Key Statistics & Graphics · U.S. government work, public domain
The USDA Economic Research Service sorts homes into groups. Homes with low food security got enough food by changing what they ate or by getting help, such as food from a community pantry. Homes with very low food security sometimes had to eat less or skip meals because there was not enough food.
The page gives numbers for 2024 and compares them with 2023. It says the changes from 2023 to 2024 were not big enough to count as real changes. Scientists call this “not statistically significant.” It also says the 2024 rate was higher than the rates from 2016 through 2021.
Homes with children are studied too. In 2024, about 751,000 children lived in homes where at least one child had very low food security.
The page also compares states. It uses numbers from 2022, 2023 and 2024 together for each state, and the rates were different from state to state.
Source: USDA Economic Research Service, Food Security in the U.S.: Key Statistics & Graphics (ers.usda.gov)