explain how artists use sketchbooks and preparatory studies to test ideas, and set up my own sketchbook as a research and planning tool for the year.
Instruction
Finished paintings hide their own history. By the time a picture reaches a museum wall, the false starts, the rejected compositions and the figures that moved three times have been painted over. Sketchbooks and preparatory studies are where you can still see the thinking. This lesson looks at three artists whose studies survive, because the habit you build this week, using a sketchbook to decide rather than to decorate, is the habit that separates advanced work from competent work.
Caillebotte plans a street. Gustave Caillebotte’s Paris Street; Rainy Day (1877, Art Institute of Chicago) is a large painting of a Paris intersection. Before he painted it he made drawings such as the graphite Study for Paris Street; Rainy Day (1877, Art Institute of Chicago) to work out the perspective of the buildings and the place of the figures. The Art Institute also holds one of his sketchbooks (1883-1887), with drawings in graphite and watercolor. Open the finished painting and find the green lamppost. It divides the picture almost exactly in two. That is a decision, not an accident, and studies are where decisions like it get tested.
Seurat builds with value. Georges Seurat made dozens of studies for A Sunday on La Grande Jatte — 1884 (1884-86, Art Institute of Chicago). One is Seated Woman with a Parasol (1884/85), in black Conté crayon. Notice that it has almost no outlines. Seurat drew the figure as a shape of dark against light, letting the texture of the paper break up the crayon. In the painting that figure is built from small touches of color, but its silhouette was already fixed in the drawing. The study tested one question: does this shape read clearly against its background?
Hokusai’s model books. Katsushika Hokusai issued his sketches as printed books, the Hokusai manga (Art Institute of Chicago, which dates its set 1812/78), which appeared in many volumes over several decades. They are pages of people working, animals, plants, waves and faces, printed as woodblock books that other artists and students used as model books. They show a different use of the sketchbook: collecting forms from the world so they are ready when a composition needs them.
Three uses of a sketchbook. From these examples you can name three purposes. The first is collecting: drawing from observation to store forms, as Hokusai did. The second is testing: a small study that answers one question, as Seurat’s did. The third is planning: working out the structure of a composition before the final, as Caillebotte’s perspective study did. Your sketchbook this year should do all three, and every entry should say which one it is doing.
Setting up the book. Number the pages. Keep the first page as an index you update weekly. Date every entry. Write on the page: a short note in the margin saying what you were testing and what you learned is worth more than a polished drawing with no thinking attached. John Ruskin’s The Elements of Drawing (1857), written as letters to beginners, argues that drawing trains you to see what is actually in front of you rather than what you assume is there. That is the purpose of the observation pages you start today.
Alternatives. If a physical sketchbook is not practical for you, a folder of dated loose sheets or a digital sketchbook in the free app Krita meets the same requirements, as long as entries are dated and annotated.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you, and your teacher, whether the standard below has landed yet.
Seurat’s Conté crayon study of a seated woman has almost no outlines. What question was it most likely testing?
Collecting
Tap to revealDrawing from observation to store forms for later use (Hokusai’s manga).
Testing
Tap to revealA small study that answers one question (Seurat’s figure study).
Planning
Tap to revealWorking out the structure of a composition before the final (Caillebotte’s perspective study).
Annotation
Tap to revealThe note that turns a drawing into evidence of thinking.
Open Paris Street; Rainy Day and its graphite study. Name one thing Caillebotte kept from the study and one thing that changed or was added in the painting. What does the change tell you about what he was deciding?
How confident are you that you can explain three ways artists use sketchbooks and set up my own to collect, test and plan?
Painting and Study Side by Side: Caillebotte, Seurat and the Sketchbook, in Words and Numbers
Art Institute of Chicago object records 20684, 210484, 208200, 150773, 27992 and 192276 (public domain, retrieved 26 September 2026); John Ruskin, The Elements of Drawing (London, 1857), Project Gutenberg #30325 · CC0 (museum data); Public domain (Ruskin, 1857); SLS original (descriptions, measurements and worked models)
Why this reading. The lesson asks you to compare Caillebotte’s finished painting with its graphite study, and to explain what Seurat’s crayon study was testing. A student cannot open a museum wall through a text lesson, so everything you need to look at is described here in words, measured, and set beside the museum’s own record. Museum links are a bonus, not a requirement. How the descriptions were made: the Art Institute of Chicago (AIC) releases its catalog data under CC0. The statements about what is on each sheet were written by looking at public-domain reproductions, and the percentages and value maps were measured from those reproductions by Sejal Learn. Records retrieved 26 September 2026.
The six records
| Work | Date | Medium and size | AIC accession |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gustave Caillebotte, Paris Street; Rainy Day | 1877 | Oil on canvas, 212.2 x 276.2 cm (83 1/2 x 108 3/4 in.). Inscribed lower left: G. Caillebotte. 1877 | 1964.336 |
| Gustave Caillebotte, Study for Paris Street; Rainy Day | 1877 | Graphite, with touches of erasing and touches of charcoal, on tan handmade laid paper, 30.2 x 46.5 cm (11 15/16 x 18 5/16 in.). Numerical notations in the margins | 2011.420 |
| Gustave Caillebotte, Sketchbook | June 1883 to September 1887 | Forty sheets: 30 drawings in graphite, 7 in watercolor over graphite, 3 in graphite and brush with gray wash; each sheet 11.4 x 19.5 cm (4 1/2 x 7 11/16 in.) | 2011.85 |
| Georges Seurat, Seated Woman with a Parasol (study for La Grande Jatte) | 1884/85 | Black Conté crayon on ivory laid paper, 48 x 31.5 cm (18 15/16 x 12 7/16 in.) | 1999.7 |
| Georges Seurat, A Sunday on La Grande Jatte – 1884 | 1884-86, border added 1888-89 | Oil on canvas, 207.5 x 308.1 cm (81 3/4 x 121 1/4 in.) | 1926.224 |
| Katsushika Hokusai, Hokusai manga (Sketches of Hokusai), volumes 1-3, 5-11 and 14 of 15 | 1812/78 (the AIC’s dating of its set) | Bound book, woodblock printed; 22.5 x 15.5 cm (8 7/8 x 6 1/8 in.) closed, 22.5 x 28.3 cm (8 7/8 x 11 1/8 in.) opened | 2007.628 |
All six are marked public domain by the Art Institute. Object pages, if you want the images beside the words: artic.edu/artworks/20684, 210484, 208200, 150773, 27992 and 192276.
The painting, in words
The canvas is landscape format, about 1.3 times as wide as it is tall, and the figures are close to life-size. Composition. A tall green lamppost rises from the pavement in the foreground to the top edge; measured on a reproduction it stands almost exactly halfway across, so the picture divides into a left half of open street and a right half of crowded sidewalk. Left of the post, the street recedes to a long cream-colored apartment block whose corner points into the middle distance. Just right of the post, the nearest and largest figures, a man in a top hat and dark coat holding an umbrella and a woman in a dark dress on his arm, walk toward the viewer. Beyond them, and cut off by the right edge, a pink-red wall, another umbrella and the back of a man in a top hat close the space. The AIC’s curators note that the dramatic cropping may have been inspired by photography and that the couple seem to look at something outside the frame. Value structure. Measured in thirds of the picture’s brightness range, the darkest zone is a continuous mass in the lower right, made by the two coats, the woman’s dress and the cropped figure at the edge; the lightest zone is the sky and the cream building at upper left. About 11 percent of the canvas is very dark and about 31 percent is light. Color. Gray-blue, cream and warm gray, with the green of the lamppost and the pink-red wall as the only strong accents. Edges. Distant figures dissolve in the wet haze; the couple’s faces and the umbrella handle are among the sharpest edges in the picture. The AIC adds that Caillebotte suggests rain through the retractable umbrellas and the reflections on the wet cobblestones rather than by painting raindrops.
Value map of the painting: nine rows from top to bottom, twelve columns from left to right. D is the darkest third of the picture’s brightness range, M the middle third, L the lightest third.
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | M | L | L | L | L | L | L | L | L | M | M | D |
| 2 | M | L | L | M | L | L | L | L | L | M | M | M |
| 3 | M | L | M | M | M | L | M | L | M | M | M | D |
| 4 | M | M | M | M | M | M | M | D | M | D | M | D |
| 5 | D | M | L | M | D | M | M | D | M | D | M | D |
| 6 | D | L | L | L | M | M | D | D | D | D | D | D |
| 7 | M | M | L | L | M | M | D | D | M | D | D | D |
| 8 | M | M | L | M | M | L | D | D | M | D | D | D |
| 9 | M | M | M | M | M | L | M | D | M | D | D | D |
The graphite study, in words
The AIC’s own note reads: this preparatory drawing “seems to have been freely sketched on the spot before being laid out in the studio with a straightedge and compass to regularize the perspective lines.” A caution about what follows: it was written from a public-domain reproduction of a Caillebotte perspective drawing for this picture. The reproduction’s proportions (1.53 to 1) match the AIC sheet’s (1.54 to 1), but it comes from a printed book and could not be tied to the AIC’s own image file, so treat the museum’s record, including the margin numbers, as the authority on this sheet. On the reproduction, a ruled rectangle is drawn inside the sheet, and within it the same street corner is set out in pure line with no tone at all. A tall lamppost with an ornate lantern head, a side arm and a ringed base stands at the center and is the only carefully drawn object. Two corner buildings recede on either side of it toward one vanishing point, their rooflines and window ledges drawn as long converging straight lines. On the right, a large blank wall fills the foreground. Short wavy vertical marks near the building bases stand for posts or figures not yet designed. No couple, no umbrellas and no cobblestones appear.
Compare the two
| Feature | In the study | In the painting |
|---|---|---|
| The lamppost | At the center of the sheet, drawn in detail, the tallest vertical | Almost halfway across the canvas; green; the couple stands just right of it |
| The corner buildings | Two blocks meeting at one vanishing point by straightedge lines | A long cream block at left; a second, smaller building far behind the umbrellas |
| The right foreground | A large empty wall | A pink-red wall, a cropped umbrella and a cropped man in a top hat |
| Figures | None resolved; wavy vertical marks only | A couple and at least ten other figures, most under umbrellas |
| Surface of the street | Converging lines | Small pink, gray and green cobblestones with reflections |
| Tone | Line only | Full range of value, darkest at lower right |
The lesson asks what Caillebotte kept, what he added, and what the difference tells you he was deciding. The table gives you the facts; the reasoning is yours.
Seurat’s Conté crayon study, in words
The AIC explains that Seurat’s many studies for La Grande Jatte fall mostly into two groups: small compositional sketches and color studies on wooden panels, and “nuanced Conté crayon drawings” of the empty landscape and of the shapes of particular figures. This drawing is a tall vertical sheet (48 x 31.5 cm). A seated woman in profile faces left, cropped at the bottom by the sheet. Her hat, head and shoulders form one dark rounded mass with the brim jutting left; the face is not drawn as a face. The darkest area is her bodice, a narrow vertical shape down the right side; her skirt spreads at the bottom into a broad mid-dark mound. One thin, pale, straight line slants from head to waist (presumably the parasol). There are no outlines: the silhouette is simply where the crayon stops, and the texture is the grain of the paper catching the crayon. Nearly half the sheet at left is bare paper, with a single soft gray smudge at middle left. Measured from a reproduction, about 21 percent of the sheet is dark and about 62 percent is light paper. The AIC says the drawing developed the expressive contours of the seated woman with a parasol who occupies the center of the finished painting. In the painting she is one figure among many, near the center of a canvas about 3 meters wide, and her outline has become one edge among a great many.
What “kept” and “tested” mean
Ruskin, in The Elements of Drawing (1857), Letter I, note 1, states the aim of a beginning draftsman: “The whole technical power of painting depends on our recovery of what may be called the innocence of the eye.” He means seeing the flat patches of tone and color in front of you before naming them as things. Seurat’s silhouette is a demonstration: it records a patch of dark against light before it is a woman.
Notice what the AIC says about the Caillebotte sketchbook: its subjects include panoramic views, portraits, intimate garden scenes, details of trees and architecture and copies after other works, and “none are studies for later works”; the museum calls it more experimental, with Caillebotte developing his use of watercolor and drawing out of doors. So the sketchbook is an example of collecting and experimenting, and the separate perspective sheet is the example of planning. The lesson’s three uses (collecting, testing, planning) are three jobs a page can do, and one book can do all three.
Setting up your own book: a worked model (SLS original)
Index page. Page 1 lists number, date, use (C for collecting, T for testing, P for planning) and a five-word title. Example line: 5 / 9 Sept / T / Dark shape reads against wall? Every entry carries four written lines: Question (what this page tests); Did (what I drew, how long, with what tool); Learned (one fact); Next (the decision it changes). Model entry (invented as a model; not by any artist): Page 5, 9 Sept, T. Question: Does the shape of the chair read against the wall using only two values? Did: Four minutes, soft graphite on its side, no outlines, 3 x 4 in. Learned: The chair’s back disappeared where it met the wall’s shadow. Next: Move the lamp so the wall behind the chair is lighter.
Copy one study. Choose the Seurat or the Caillebotte sheet, using the descriptions and the value map above. Make a copy at about 3 x 4 in. Beside it write three annotations in your own words: what the study tested, one thing you would keep if you were making the painting, and one thing the study cannot tell you. Three observation pages. Ten minutes each, three different subjects (a shoe, a hand, a corner of your room), each from a viewpoint you have not used before, each ended with the four-line entry.
The Hokusai manga is the collecting model: a bound set of woodblock-printed books, about 22.5 x 15.5 cm, of which the AIC holds eleven of the fifteen volumes. The lesson describes their contents as people at work, animals, plants, waves and faces; the record above confirms the format and the volumes held.
Sources: Art Institute of Chicago, Paris Street; Rainy Day, 1964.336 (artic.edu); Art Institute of Chicago, Study for Paris Street; Rainy Day, 2011.420 (artic.edu); Art Institute of Chicago, Seated Woman with a Parasol, 1999.7 (artic.edu); Art Institute of Chicago, Sketchbook (Caillebotte), 2011.85 (artic.edu); John Ruskin, The Elements of Drawing (Project Gutenberg) (gutenberg.org)